rename to_arc to clone_arc

to_arc converts a `*const C` into an `Option<Arc<T>>`. It had a lot of
verbiage to explain what it was doing with reference counts. I think the
conceptual model becomes a lot simpler if we rename the function to
reflect what it is really doing: cloning the arc.

src/acceptor.rs

@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ use crate::rslice::{rustls_slice_bytes, rustls_str};
 use crate::server::rustls_server_config;
 use crate::{
     ffi_panic_boundary, free_box, rustls_result, set_boxed_mut_ptr, to_box, to_boxed_mut_ptr,
-    try_arc_from_ptr, try_callback, try_mut_from_ptr, try_ref_from_ptr, try_take, Castable,
+    try_callback, try_clone_arc, try_mut_from_ptr, try_ref_from_ptr, try_take, Castable,
     OwnershipBox,
 };
 use rustls_result::NullParameter;
@@ -400,7 +400,7 @@ impl rustls_accepted {
         ffi_panic_boundary! {
             let accepted: &mut Option<Accepted> = try_mut_from_ptr!(accepted);
             let accepted = try_take!(accepted);
-            let config: Arc<ServerConfig> = try_arc_from_ptr!(config);
+            let config: Arc<ServerConfig> = try_clone_arc!(config);
             match accepted.into_connection(config) {
                 Ok(built) => {
                     let wrapped = crate::connection::Connection::from_server(built);

src/client.rs

@@ -22,8 +22,8 @@ use crate::rslice::NulByte;
 use crate::rslice::{rustls_slice_bytes, rustls_slice_slice_bytes, rustls_str};
 use crate::{
     ffi_panic_boundary, free_arc, free_box, set_boxed_mut_ptr, to_arc_const_ptr, to_boxed_mut_ptr,
-    try_arc_from_ptr, try_box_from_ptr, try_mut_from_ptr, try_ref_from_ptr, try_slice,
-    userdata_get, Castable, OwnershipArc, OwnershipBox,
+    try_box_from_ptr, try_clone_arc, try_mut_from_ptr, try_ref_from_ptr, try_slice, userdata_get,
+    Castable, OwnershipArc, OwnershipBox,
 };
 
 /// A client config being constructed. A builder can be modified by,
@@ -442,7 +442,7 @@ impl rustls_client_config_builder {
             let keys_ptrs: &[*const rustls_certified_key] = try_slice!(certified_keys, certified_keys_len);
             let mut keys: Vec<Arc<CertifiedKey>> = Vec::new();
             for &key_ptr in keys_ptrs {
-                let certified_key: Arc<CertifiedKey> = try_arc_from_ptr!(key_ptr);
+                let certified_key: Arc<CertifiedKey> = try_clone_arc!(key_ptr);
                 keys.push(certified_key);
             }
             config.cert_resolver = Some(Arc::new(ResolvesClientCertFromChoices { keys }));
@@ -545,7 +545,7 @@ impl rustls_client_config {
             }
             CStr::from_ptr(server_name)
         };
-        let config: Arc<ClientConfig> = try_arc_from_ptr!(config);
+        let config: Arc<ClientConfig> = try_clone_arc!(config);
         let server_name: &str = match server_name.to_str() {
             Ok(s) => s,
             Err(std::str::Utf8Error { .. }) => return rustls_result::InvalidDnsNameError,

src/lib.rs

@@ -368,19 +368,16 @@ where
     Arc::into_raw(Arc::new(src)) as *const _
 }
 
-/// Convert a const pointer to a [`Castable`] to an optional `Arc` over the underlying rust type.
+/// Given a const pointer to a [`Castable`] representing an `Arc`, clone the `Arc` and return
+/// the corresponding Rust type.
 ///
-/// Sometimes we create an `Arc`, then call `into_raw` and return the resulting raw pointer
-/// to C, e.g. using [`to_arc_const_ptr`]. C can then call a rustls-ffi function multiple times
-/// using that same raw pointer. On each call, we need to reconstruct the Arc, but once we reconstruct
-/// the Arc, its reference count will be decremented on drop. We need to reference count to stay at 1,
-/// because the C code is holding a copy.
+/// The caller still owns its copy of the `Arc`. In other words, the reference count of the
+/// `Arc` will be incremented by 1 by the end of this function.
 ///
-/// This function turns the raw pointer back into an Arc, clones it to increment the reference count
-/// (which will make it 2 in this particular case), and `mem::forget`s the clone. The `mem::forget`
-/// prevents the reference count from being decremented when we exit this function, so it will stay
-/// at 2 as long as we are in Rust code. Once the caller drops its `Arc`, the reference count will
-/// go back down to 1, since the C code's copy remains.
+/// To achieve that, we need to `mem::forget` the `Arc` we get back from `into_raw`, because
+/// `into_raw` _does_ take back ownership. If we called `into_raw` without `mem::forget`, at the
+/// end of the function that Arc would be dropped and the reference count would be decremented,
+/// potentially to 0, causing memory to be freed.
 ///
 /// Does nothing, returning `None`, when passed a `NULL` pointer. Can only be used when the
 /// `Castable` has specified a cast type equal to [`OwnershipArc`].
@@ -389,7 +386,7 @@ where
 ///
 /// If non-null, `ptr` must be a pointer that resulted from previously calling `Arc::into_raw`,
 /// e.g. from using [`to_arc_const_ptr`].
-pub(crate) fn to_arc<C>(ptr: *const C) -> Option<Arc<C::RustType>>
+pub(crate) fn clone_arc<C>(ptr: *const C) -> Option<Arc<C::RustType>>
 where
     C: Castable<Ownership = OwnershipArc>,
 {
@@ -566,32 +563,20 @@ macro_rules! try_ref_from_ptr {
 
 pub(crate) use try_ref_from_ptr;
 
-/// Convert a const pointer to a [`Castable`] to an optional `Arc` over the underlying
-/// [`Castable::RustType`]. See [`to_arc`] for more information.
-///
-/// Does nothing, returning `None`, when passed `NULL`. Can only be used with `Castable`'s that
-/// specify an ownership type of [`OwnershipArc`].
-pub(crate) fn try_arc_from<C>(from: *const C) -> Option<Arc<C::RustType>>
-where
-    C: Castable<Ownership = OwnershipArc>,
-{
-    to_arc(from)
-}
-
 /// If the provided pointer to a [`Castable`] is non-null, convert it to a reference to an `Arc` over
 /// the underlying rust type using [`try_arc_from`]. Otherwise, return
 /// [`rustls_result::NullParameter`], or an appropriate default (`false`, `0`, `NULL`) based on the
 /// context. See [`try_arc_from`] for more information.
-macro_rules! try_arc_from_ptr {
+macro_rules! try_clone_arc {
     ( $var:ident ) => {
-        match $crate::try_arc_from($var) {
+        match $crate::clone_arc($var) {
             Some(c) => c,
             None => return $crate::panic::NullParameterOrDefault::value(),
         }
     };
 }
 
-pub(crate) use try_arc_from_ptr;
+pub(crate) use try_clone_arc;
 
 /// Convert a mutable pointer to a [`Castable`] to an optional `Box` over the underlying
 /// [`Castable::RustType`].

src/server.rs

@@ -30,8 +30,8 @@ use crate::session::{
 };
 use crate::{
     ffi_panic_boundary, free_arc, free_box, set_boxed_mut_ptr, to_arc_const_ptr, to_boxed_mut_ptr,
-    try_arc_from_ptr, try_box_from_ptr, try_mut_from_ptr, try_ref_from_ptr, try_slice,
-    userdata_get, Castable, OwnershipArc, OwnershipBox, OwnershipRef,
+    try_box_from_ptr, try_clone_arc, try_mut_from_ptr, try_ref_from_ptr, try_slice, userdata_get,
+    Castable, OwnershipArc, OwnershipBox, OwnershipRef,
 };
 
 /// A server config being constructed. A builder can be modified by,
@@ -170,7 +170,7 @@ impl rustls_server_config_builder {
     ) {
         ffi_panic_boundary! {
         let builder: &mut ServerConfigBuilder = try_mut_from_ptr!(builder);
-        let verifier: Arc<AllowAnyAuthenticatedClient> = try_arc_from_ptr!(verifier);
+        let verifier: Arc<AllowAnyAuthenticatedClient> = try_clone_arc!(verifier);
         builder.verifier = verifier;
         }
     }
@@ -186,7 +186,7 @@ impl rustls_server_config_builder {
     ) {
         ffi_panic_boundary! {
             let builder: &mut ServerConfigBuilder = try_mut_from_ptr!(builder);
-            let verifier: Arc<AllowAnyAnonymousOrAuthenticatedClient> = try_arc_from_ptr!(verifier);
+            let verifier: Arc<AllowAnyAnonymousOrAuthenticatedClient> = try_clone_arc!(verifier);
 
             builder.verifier = verifier;
         }
@@ -273,7 +273,7 @@ impl rustls_server_config_builder {
         let keys_ptrs: &[*const rustls_certified_key] = try_slice!(certified_keys, certified_keys_len);
         let mut keys: Vec<Arc<CertifiedKey>> = Vec::new();
         for &key_ptr in keys_ptrs {
-            let certified_key: Arc<CertifiedKey> = try_arc_from_ptr!(key_ptr);
+            let certified_key: Arc<CertifiedKey> = try_clone_arc!(key_ptr);
             keys.push(certified_key);
         }
             builder.cert_resolver = Some(Arc::new(ResolvesServerCertFromChoices::new(&keys)));
@@ -333,7 +333,7 @@ impl rustls_server_config {
         conn_out: *mut *mut rustls_connection,
     ) -> rustls_result {
         ffi_panic_boundary! {
-            let config: Arc<ServerConfig> = try_arc_from_ptr!(config);
+            let config: Arc<ServerConfig> = try_clone_arc!(config);
 
             let server_connection = match ServerConnection::new(config) {
                 Ok(sc) => sc,