Merge branch 'funcref'

WebAssembly · Apr 28, 2024 · 9d2d677 · 9d2d677
2 parents cd8b5c5 + ec004f6
commit 9d2d677
Show file tree

Hide file tree

Showing 32 changed files with 527 additions and 229 deletions.
diff --git a/.github/workflows/ci-interpreter.yml b/.github/workflows/ci-interpreter.yml
@@ -3,11 +3,11 @@ name: CI for interpreter & tests
 on:
   push:
     branches: [ main ]
-    paths: [ interpreter/**, test/** ]
+    paths: [ .github/**, interpreter/**, test/** ]
 
   pull_request:
     branches: [ main ]
-    paths: [ interpreter/**, test/** ]
+    paths: [ .github/**, interpreter/**, test/** ]
 
   # Allows you to run this workflow manually from the Actions tab
   workflow_dispatch:

diff --git a/.github/workflows/ci-spec.yml b/.github/workflows/ci-spec.yml
@@ -3,11 +3,11 @@ name: CI for specs
 on:
   push:
     branches: [ main ]
-    paths: [ document/** ]
+    paths: [ .github/**, document/** ]
 
   pull_request:
     branches: [ main ]
-    paths: [ document/** ]
+    paths: [ .github/**, document/** ]
 
   # Allows you to run this workflow manually from the Actions tab
   workflow_dispatch:

diff --git a/.github/workflows/w3c-publish.yml b/.github/workflows/w3c-publish.yml
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
+name: Publish to W3C TR space
+
+on:
+  push:
+    branches: [ main ]
+    paths: [ .github/**, document/** ]
+
+  # Allows you to run this workflow manually from the Actions tab
+  workflow_dispatch:
+
+jobs:
+  publish-to-w3c-TR:
+    if: github.repository == 'WebAssembly/spec'
+    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
+    steps:
+      - name: Checkout repo
+        uses: actions/checkout@v2
+        with:
+          submodules: "recursive"
+      - name: Setup Node.js
+        uses: actions/setup-node@v3
+        with:
+          node-version: 16
+      - name: Setup Bikeshed
+        run: pip install bikeshed && bikeshed update
+      - name: Setup TexLive
+        run: sudo apt-get update -y && sudo apt-get install -y latexmk texlive-latex-recommended texlive-latex-extra texlive-fonts-recommended
+      - name: Setup Sphinx
+        run: pip install six && pip install sphinx==5.1.0
+      - name: Publish all specs to their https://www.w3.org/TR/ URLs
+        run: cd document && make -e WD-echidna-CI
+        env:
+          STATUS: --md-status=WD
+          W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_CORE: ${{ secrets.W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_CORE }}
+          W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_JSAPI: ${{ secrets.W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_JSAPI }}
+          W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_WEBAPI: ${{ secrets.W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_WEBAPI }}
+          YARN_ENABLE_IMMUTABLE_INSTALLS: false
diff --git a/document/Makefile b/document/Makefile
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
-DIRS     = core js-api web-api
+DIRS     = js-api web-api core
 FILES    = index.html
 BUILDDIR = _build
+TAR      = tar
 
 # Global targets.
 
@@ -24,6 +25,25 @@ clean: $(DIRS:%=clean-%)
 .PHONY: diff
 diff: $(DIRS:%=diff-%)
 
+# macOS: do “brew install tar” & run “make” as: TAR=gtar make -e WD-tar
+.PHONY: WD-tar
+WD-tar:
+	for dir in $(DIRS); \
+		do STATUS=--md-status=WD TAR=$(TAR) $(MAKE) -e -C $$dir $@;\
+	done
+
+# macOS: do “brew install tar” & run “make” as: TAR=gtar make -e WD-echidna
+.PHONY: WD-echidna
+WD-echidna:
+	for dir in $(DIRS); \
+		do $(MAKE) -e -C $$dir $@;\
+	done
+
+.PHONY: WD-echidna-CI
+WD-echidna-CI:
+	for dir in $(DIRS); \
+		do $(MAKE) -e -C $$dir $@;\
+	done
 
 # Directory-specific targets.
 

diff --git a/document/core/Makefile b/document/core/Makefile
@@ -9,6 +9,8 @@ BUILDDIR      = _build
 STATICDIR     = _static
 DOWNLOADDIR   = _download
 NAME          = WebAssembly
+DECISION_URL  = https://github.com/WebAssembly/meetings/blob/main/main/2017/WG-12-06.md
+TAR           = tar
 
 # Internal variables.
 PAPEROPT_a4     = -D latex_paper_size=a4
@@ -78,7 +80,7 @@ publish-main: clean main bikeshed-keep deploy
 all:	pdf html bikeshed
 
 .PHONY: main
-main:	pdf html
+main:	macrosok pdf html
 
 # Dirty hack to avoid rebuilding the Bikeshed version for every push.
 .PHONY: bikeshed-keep
@@ -95,6 +97,10 @@ GENERATED = appendix/index-instructions.rst
 %.rst: %.py
 	(cd `dirname $@`; ./`basename $^`)
 
+.PHONY: macrosok
+macrosok:	$(GENERATED)
+	sh util/check_macros.sh
+
 .PHONY: pdf
 pdf:	$(GENERATED) latexpdf
 	mkdir -p $(BUILDDIR)/html/$(DOWNLOADDIR)
@@ -148,7 +154,7 @@ bikeshed: $(GENERATED)
 	@echo
 	@echo =========================================================================
 	mkdir -p $(BUILDDIR)/bikeshed_mathjax/
-	bikeshed spec index.bs $(BUILDDIR)/bikeshed_mathjax/index.html
+	bikeshed spec $(STATUS) index.bs $(BUILDDIR)/bikeshed_mathjax/index.html
 	mkdir -p $(BUILDDIR)/html/bikeshed/
 	(cd util/katex/ && yarn && yarn build && npm install --only=prod)
 	python3 util/mathjax2katex.py $(BUILDDIR)/bikeshed_mathjax/index.html \
@@ -163,9 +169,11 @@ bikeshed: $(GENERATED)
 	@echo "Build finished. The HTML page is in $(BUILDDIR)/html/bikeshed/."
 
 .PHONY: WD-tar
+# macOS tar has no “--transform” option (only GNU tar does), so on macOS,
+# do “brew install tar” & run “make” like this: “TAR=gtar make -e WD-tar”
 WD-tar: bikeshed
 	@echo "Building tar file..."
-	tar cvf \
+	$(TAR) cvf \
 		$(BUILDDIR)/WD.tar \
 		--transform='s|$(BUILDDIR)/html/bikeshed/||' \
 		--transform='s|index.html|Overview.html|' \
@@ -190,6 +198,20 @@ WD-echidna: WD-tar
 	@echo
 	@echo "Published working draft. Check its status at https://labs.w3.org/echidna/api/status?id=`cat $(BUILDDIR)/WD-echidna-id.txt`"
 
+.PHONY: WD-echidna-CI
+WD-echidna-CI: WD-tar
+	@if [ -z $(W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_CORE) ] || \
+			[ -z $(DECISION_URL) ] ; then \
+		echo "Must provide W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_CORE and DECISION_URL environment variables"; \
+		exit 1; \
+	fi
+	curl 'https://labs.w3.org/echidna/api/request' \
+		-F "tar=@$(BUILDDIR)/WD.tar" \
+		-F "token=$(W3C_ECHIDNA_TOKEN_CORE)" \
+		-F "decision=$(DECISION_URL)" | tee $(BUILDDIR)/WD-echidna-id.txt
+	@echo
+	@echo "Published working draft. Check its status at https://labs.w3.org/echidna/api/status?id=`cat $(BUILDDIR)/WD-echidna-id.txt`"
+
 .PHONY: diff
 diff: bikeshed
 	@echo "Downloading the old single-file html spec..."

diff --git a/document/core/appendix/index-instructions.py b/document/core/appendix/index-instructions.py
@@ -405,48 +405,48 @@ def Instruction(name, opcode, type=None, validation=None, execution=None, operat
     Instruction(r'\F32X4.\REPLACELANE~\laneidx', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{20}', r'[\V128~\F32] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vec-replace_lane', r'exec-vec-replace_lane'),
     Instruction(r'\F64X2.\EXTRACTLANE~\laneidx', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{21}', r'[\V128] \to [\F64]', r'valid-vec-extract_lane', r'exec-vec-extract_lane'),
     Instruction(r'\F64X2.\REPLACELANE~\laneidx', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{22}', r'[\V128~\F64] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vec-replace_lane', r'exec-vec-replace_lane'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{23}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ieq'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{24}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ine'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{25}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ilt_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{26}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ilt_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{27}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-igt_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{28}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-igt_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{29}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ile_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2A}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ile_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2B}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ige_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2C}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ige_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2D}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ieq'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2E}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ine'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2F}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ilt_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{30}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ilt_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{31}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-igt_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{32}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-igt_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{33}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ile_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{34}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ile_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{35}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ige_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{36}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ige_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{37}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ieq'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{38}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ine'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{39}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ilt_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3A}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ilt_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3B}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-igt_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3C}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-igt_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3D}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ile_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3E}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ile_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3F}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ige_s'),
-    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{40}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-ige_u'),
-    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{41}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-feq'),
-    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{42}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fne'),
-    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VLT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{43}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-flt'),
-    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VGT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{44}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fgt'),
-    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VLE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{45}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fle'),
-    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VGE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{46}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fge'),
-    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{47}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-feq'),
-    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{48}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fne'),
-    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VLT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{49}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-flt'),
-    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VGT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4A}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fgt'),
-    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VLE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4B}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fle'),
-    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VGE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4C}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vbinop', r'exec-vbinop', r'op-fge'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{23}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ieq'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{24}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ine'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{25}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ilt_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{26}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ilt_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{27}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-igt_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{28}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-igt_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{29}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ile_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VLE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2A}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ile_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2B}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ige_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I8X16.\VGE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2C}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ige_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2D}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ieq'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2E}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ine'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{2F}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ilt_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{30}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ilt_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{31}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-igt_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{32}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-igt_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{33}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ile_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VLE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{34}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ile_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{35}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ige_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I16X8.\VGE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{36}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ige_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{37}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ieq'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{38}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ine'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{39}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ilt_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3A}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ilt_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGT\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3B}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-igt_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGT\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3C}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-igt_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3D}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ile_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VLE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3E}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ile_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGE\K{\_s}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{3F}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ige_s'),
+    Instruction(r'\I32X4.\VGE\K{\_u}', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{40}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-ige_u'),
+    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{41}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-feq'),
+    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{42}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fne'),
+    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VLT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{43}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-flt'),
+    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VGT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{44}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fgt'),
+    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VLE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{45}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fle'),
+    Instruction(r'\F32X4.\VGE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{46}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fge'),
+    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VEQ', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{47}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-feq'),
+    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VNE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{48}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fne'),
+    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VLT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{49}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-flt'),
+    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VGT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4A}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fgt'),
+    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VLE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4B}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fle'),
+    Instruction(r'\F64X2.\VGE', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4C}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vrelop', r'exec-vrelop', r'op-fge'),
     Instruction(r'\V128.\VNOT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4D}', r'[\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vvunop', r'exec-vvunop', r'op-inot'),
     Instruction(r'\V128.\VAND', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4E}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vvbinop', r'exec-vvbinop', r'op-iand'),
     Instruction(r'\V128.\VANDNOT', r'\hex{FD}~~\hex{4F}', r'[\V128~\V128] \to [\V128]', r'valid-vvbinop', r'exec-vvbinop', r'op-iandnot'),

diff --git a/document/core/appendix/properties.rst b/document/core/appendix/properties.rst
@@ -21,7 +21,7 @@ In order to state and prove soundness precisely, the typing rules must be extend
 
 
 .. index:: context, recursive type, recursive type index
-.. context-rec:
+.. _context-ext:
 
 Contexts
 ~~~~~~~~
@@ -717,10 +717,14 @@ where :math:`\val_1 \gg^+_S \val_2` denotes the transitive closure of the follow
 
 * Let :math:`\reftype^\ast` be the concatenation of all :math:`\reftype_i` in order.
 
+* Let :math:`m` be the length of :math:`\moduleinst.\MIFUNCS`.
+
 * Let :math:`n` be the length of :math:`\moduleinst.\MIDATAS`.
 
+* Let :math:`x^\ast` be the sequence of :ref:`function indices <syntax-funcidx>` from :math:`0` to :math:`m-1`.
+
 * Then the module instance is valid with :ref:`context <context>`
-  :math:`\{\CTYPES~\deftype^\ast,` :math:`\CFUNCS~\functype^\ast,` :math:`\CTABLES~\tabletype^\ast,` :math:`\CMEMS~\memtype^\ast,` :math:`\CGLOBALS~\globaltype^\ast,` :math:`\CELEMS~\reftype^\ast,` :math:`\CDATAS~{\ok}^n\}`.
+  :math:`\{\CTYPES~\deftype^\ast,` :math:`\CFUNCS~\functype^\ast,` :math:`\CTABLES~\tabletype^\ast,` :math:`\CMEMS~\memtype^\ast,` :math:`\CGLOBALS~\globaltype^\ast,` :math:`\CELEMS~\reftype^\ast,` :math:`\CDATAS~{\ok}^n,` :math:`\CREFS~x^\ast\}`.
 
 .. math::
    ~\\[-1ex]
@@ -762,7 +766,8 @@ where :math:`\val_1 \gg^+_S \val_2` denotes the transitive closure of the follow
          \CMEMS & \memtype^\ast, \\
          \CGLOBALS & \globaltype^\ast, \\
          \CELEMS & \reftype^\ast, \\
-         \CDATAS & {\ok}^n ~\}
+         \CDATAS & {\ok}^n, \\
+         \CREFS & 0 \dots (|\funcaddr^\ast|-1) ~\}
          \end{array}
        \end{array}
    }

diff --git a/document/core/binary/modules.rst b/document/core/binary/modules.rst
@@ -105,6 +105,9 @@ Id  Section
 12  :ref:`data count section <binary-datacountsec>`
 ==  ===============================================
 
+.. note::
+   Section ids do not always correspond to the :ref:`order of sections <binary-module>` in the encoding of a module.
+
 
 .. index:: ! custom section
    pair: binary format; custom section