Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Feedback #1

Open
wants to merge 28 commits into
base: feedback
Choose a base branch
from
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
71 changes: 36 additions & 35 deletions README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,3 +1,4 @@
[![Review Assignment Due Date](https://classroom.github.com/assets/deadline-readme-button-24ddc0f5d75046c5622901739e7c5dd533143b0c8e959d652212380cedb1ea36.svg)](https://classroom.github.com/a/2OGTtL0Y)
# Junior Seminar (CMPSC 580) Own Project Repository

## Semester: Spring 2024
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -62,69 +63,69 @@ requirements and it is expected that an exceptional project will exceed
these requirements.

- **General Project Requirements**
- [ ] The project prototype and proposal were submitted on time on GitHub
- [ ] The pitch slides were submitted on time via the [Google Slides](https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/154V9XquBwLsIVaasJO24e4KglLS9eeVW5e-3mX2OjWc/edit?usp=sharing)
- [ ] The prototype demo video was submitted on time via the [Google Form](https://forms.gle/7UebHZU4CFzfTrY57)
- [ ] The GitHub repository of the project contains evidence of many commits (multiple commits each week)
- [ ] The GitHub repository of the project has a passing build status in GitHub Actions
- [ ] The proposal has the correct format created through the use of Markdown and includes the sections outlined in the provided template
- [ ] The title of the project is both interesting and appropriate
- [ ] The project proposal cites at least ten references, with five references being published, peer-reviewed articles
- [ ] The project proposal consists of at least `2000` words
- [ ] The project proposal follows a logical flow at the level of sections,
- [X] The project prototype and proposal were submitted on time on GitHub
- [X] The pitch slides were submitted on time via the [Google Slides](https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/154V9XquBwLsIVaasJO24e4KglLS9eeVW5e-3mX2OjWc/edit?usp=sharing)
- [X] The prototype demo video was submitted on time via the [Google Form](https://forms.gle/7UebHZU4CFzfTrY57)
- [X] The GitHub repository of the project contains evidence of many commits (multiple commits each week)
- [X] The GitHub repository of the project has a passing build status in GitHub Actions
- [X] The proposal has the correct format created through the use of Markdown and includes the sections outlined in the provided template
- [X] The title of the project is both interesting and appropriate
- [X] The project proposal cites at least ten references, with five references being published, peer-reviewed articles
- [X] The project proposal consists of at least `2000` words
- [X] The project proposal follows a logical flow at the level of sections,
subsections, and individual paragraphs
- [ ] The project proposal includes appropriate visual aids, which fall under the broad
- [X] The project proposal includes appropriate visual aids, which fall under the broad
categories of:
* `image`
* `figure`
* `table`
* `graph`
- [ ] The project proposal highlights and explains the societal impacts and ethical
- [X] The project proposal highlights and explains the societal impacts and ethical
implications of the completed research
- [ ] There are no typographical or grammatical errors in the proposal
- [ ] There is no extraneous text in the proposal
- [ ] Prototype contains a README outlining its key features, software and hardware requirements needed to use the prototype, and steps necessary to run the prototype
- [ ] Prototype works as intended
- [ ] Prototype's implementation contains appropriate documentation (comments)
- [X] There are no typographical or grammatical errors in the proposal
- [X] There is no extraneous text in the proposal
- [X] Prototype contains a README outlining its key features, software and hardware requirements needed to use the prototype, and steps necessary to run the prototype
- [X] Prototype works as intended
- [X] Prototype's implementation contains appropriate documentation (comments)

The project proposal is required to contain the following five sections:

- **Introduction Section Requirements**
- [ ] The introduction section clearly describes the proposed project
- [ ] The introduction section motivates the proposed project work
- [ ] The introduction section contains specific project goals and/or research questions that the project aims to answer
- [X] The introduction section clearly describes the proposed project
- [X] The introduction section motivates the proposed project work
- [X] The introduction section contains specific project goals and/or research questions that the project aims to answer

- **Related Work Section Requirements**
- [ ] The related work section references and describes relevant literature
- [ ] The related work section contains concise, scholarly review of the literature
- [X] The related work section references and describes relevant literature
- [X] The related work section contains concise, scholarly review of the literature
explaining the background to the proposed research
- [ ] The related work section explains how relevant literature connects to the proposed project and provides the context for the aims of the proposed project in relation to existing work on the topic
- [ ] The related work section does not provide a "laundry list" of the related literature
- [ ] The related work section situates the proposed project in the broader scope
- [X] The related work section explains how relevant literature connects to the proposed project and provides the context for the aims of the proposed project in relation to existing work on the topic
- [X] The related work section does not provide a "laundry list" of the related literature
- [X] The related work section situates the proposed project in the broader scope

- **Prototype Section Requirements**
- [ ] The prototype section explains the process utilized in the completed study
- [ ] The prototype section addresses as many of the necessary methodology used in the prototype development. For example, the following may be relevant to the project:
- [X] The prototype section explains the process utilized in the completed study
- [X] The prototype section addresses as many of the necessary methodology used in the prototype development. For example, the following may be relevant to the project:
* `description of algorithms`
* `programming languages`
* `libraries`
* `platforms`
* `software tools`
* `hardware`
- [ ] The prototype section explains how the developed proof-of-concept prototype demonstrates project feasibility (given your prototype, how can we be sure that the full artifact of the proposed project can be successfully completed by you in two semesters)
- [X] The prototype section explains how the developed proof-of-concept prototype demonstrates project feasibility (given your prototype, how can we be sure that the full artifact of the proposed project can be successfully completed by you in two semesters)

- **Preliminary Results and Outcomes Section Requirements**
- [ ] The preliminary results and outcomes section describes how the work is validated
- [ ] The preliminary results and outcomes results section includes a description of experiments
- [X] The preliminary results and outcomes section describes how the work is validated
- [X] The preliminary results and outcomes results section includes a description of experiments
such that a reader should be able to reproduce them or other results/outcomes as relevant to the prototype
- [ ] The preliminary results and outcomes contains at least one graph, table of data, or
- [X] The preliminary results and outcomes contains at least one graph, table of data, or
some other relevant presentation of the results from the experimental study

- **Conclusions and Future Work Section Requirements**
- [ ] The conclusions and future Work section provides a summary of the proposed research and its preliminary outcomes
- [ ] The conclusions and future Work section discusses the impact of the proposed research project
- [ ] The conclusions and future Work outlines, with sufficient depth and detail, further and future work that is necessary to fully complete the proposed project
- [ ] The conclusions and future Work includes an literature/evidence- or results-based appraisal of ethical issues related to the proposed research
- [X] The conclusions and future Work section provides a summary of the proposed research and its preliminary outcomes
- [X] The conclusions and future Work section discusses the impact of the proposed research project
- [X] The conclusions and future Work outlines, with sufficient depth and detail, further and future work that is necessary to fully complete the proposed project
- [X] The conclusions and future Work includes an literature/evidence- or results-based appraisal of ethical issues related to the proposed research

## GatorGrade

Expand Down
Loading
Loading