Mobile connect button

[Corantin]

• add icon only for mobile connect button
• move doc link to same place as non mobile
• move pre-beta to under the Gardens title to fit more in mobile view

Before (no connect button):

After (non sticky navbar):

[vercel]

The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git ↗︎

Name	Status	Preview	Comments	Updated (UTC)
gardens-v2	✅ Ready (Inspect)	Visit Preview	💬 Add feedback	Oct 1, 2024 5:31pm

[Corantin]

!ai

[github-actions]

## Pull Request Review Summary

This series of reviews covers changes related to wallet connection, UI simplification, and navigation improvements. While the reviews highlight positive aspects like improved UX and error handling, they also point out potential issues and provide actionable suggestions.

Main Takeaways:

• Network Mismatch Handling: The improved feedback mechanism for incorrect network connections is a great addition, making the user experience smoother.
• UI Simplification: Simplifying the UI and removing the collapsible menu is a step in the right direction. However, careful consideration should be given to mobile responsiveness and potential accessibility impacts.
• Navigation Changes: The changes to the navigation bar, particularly for mobile, are positive. However, visual hierarchy and accessibility should be double-checked, and inline styles should be replaced with reusable classes for better maintainability.
• Potential Bugs: The incomplete switchNetwork functionality is a concern that needs to be addressed before merging.

Actionable Items:

• Complete switchNetwork implementation and add thorough error handling.
• Test the UI changes rigorously on different screen sizes and devices.
• Conduct accessibility testing, especially after UI changes.
• Consider user feedback on the UI changes to validate their effectiveness.
• Improve the visual hierarchy of navigation elements, especially after removing the dropdown.
• Replace inline styles with reusable CSS classes for better maintainability.

Overall:

The pull requests demonstrate a focus on user experience and code quality. Addressing the highlighted concerns and implementing the suggestions will further enhance the application's usability and robustness.

## Pull Request Review: Connect Wallet Component Enhancements

This pull request introduces several changes to the ConnectWalletButton component, aiming to improve user experience and address potential issues.

Summary:

• Improved Network Mismatch Handling: The component now provides clearer visual feedback when the user is connected to the wrong network.
• Enhanced UI/UX: Minor adjustments to button styling and layout improve readability and visual appeal.
• Potential Bug Introduced: The switchNetwork functionality seems incomplete and might introduce a bug.

File: apps/web/components/ConnectWalletButton.tsx

Detailed Review:

• Lines 42, 47-49: The addition of isWrongNetwork clearly identifies network mismatch scenarios. This improves usability as users get immediate feedback about incorrect network connections.
• Line 63: Replacing the "Connect wallet" text with an empty span for smaller screens cleans up the UI, as the icon is sufficiently informative.
• Lines 88-91: Adding the pr-2 class and conditionally rendering the exclamation icon within the button significantly improves clarity. Users instantly recognize a network issue.
• Lines 99-107: Using a ternary operator for the conditional icon rendering is more concise and improves readability compared to the previous nested structure.
• Lines 162-167: Potential Bug: The onClick handler for the "Switch to {chainFromPath?.name ?? ""}" button seems incomplete. It's crucial to ensure this functionality is thoroughly tested and implemented correctly to prevent unexpected behavior.

Suggestions:

• Complete switchNetwork Implementation: Ensure the switchNetwork logic within the onClick handler is finalized and rigorously tested.
• Consider Additional Error Handling: Implement robust error handling for the switchNetwork functionality. This could involve displaying informative error messages to the user or providing options to retry.

Overall:

This pull request introduces valuable improvements to the ConnectWalletButton component, particularly in handling network mismatches. However, it's essential to address the potential bug in the switchNetwork functionality before merging.

Pull Request Review: UI Simplification and Responsiveness

This pull request focuses on simplifying the UI, potentially improving mobile responsiveness by removing a collapsible menu structure. Let's break down the changes and identify potential areas for improvement.

Summary:

• Simplified Navigation: The collapsible menu structure (Disclosure component) is removed, aiming for a simpler, always-visible navigation bar.
• Modal Size Constraint: A max-w-5xl class is added to the Modal component, likely to ensure the modal scales well on larger screens.

File-Specific Comments:

/components/Modal.tsx:

• Positive: Adding max-w-5xl is a good practice to prevent modals from becoming too wide on large screens. This improves readability and aesthetics.
• Suggestion: Consider adding a max-h-[90vh] class or similar to the modal container to prevent very tall modals from exceeding the viewport height. This ensures all modal content is scrollable and viewable.

/components/NavBar.tsx:

• Potential Trade-off: Removing the Disclosure component suggests a shift towards a permanently visible navigation bar. While this simplifies the UI, ensure it doesn't negatively impact the mobile experience.
  • Suggestion: If space is limited on mobile, consider a compact version of the navigation for smaller screens (e.g., using icons and potentially a "More" dropdown for less frequently used links).
• Accessibility: Double-check that removing the collapsible menu doesn't introduce any accessibility issues for users who rely on keyboard navigation.
• Branding: Moving the "pre-beta" text below "Gardens" improves visual hierarchy.
• Consistency: The removal of links to documentation and the ConnectWallet component suggests they might be relocated. Ensure consistency in their placement across the application.

General Suggestions:

• Testing: After these UI changes, thorough testing on different screen sizes and devices is crucial to ensure a seamless user experience.
• User Feedback: Consider gathering user feedback on these UI changes to validate their effectiveness and identify any areas for improvement.

Overall:

This pull request makes good progress in simplifying the UI. The focus on responsiveness and user experience is evident. However, careful consideration of the mobile experience and thorough testing are essential before merging.

Pull Request Review

This pull request simplifies the navigation bar by removing the dropdown menu on smaller screens and replacing it with direct links and a call to action.

Summary:

The changes improve the user experience on smaller screens by making navigation more straightforward.

File: [Filename not provided - Assuming component responsible for the navigation]

Positive Changes:

• Improved Mobile UX: Removing the dropdown and using direct links makes navigation clearer and more efficient on smaller screens.
• Clear Call to Action: Adding the "Connect Wallet" button directly in the header can increase user engagement with the platform's core functionality.

Suggestions:

• Consider Visual Hierarchy: With the removal of the dropdown, ensure the remaining navigation elements have appropriate visual weighting. The "Docs" link could potentially get lost. Consider increasing its font size or adding a button style similar to the "Connect Wallet" button.
• Accessibility Check: After the changes, perform accessibility testing to ensure all users can easily navigate the site. Pay particular attention to keyboard navigation and screen reader compatibility.
• Link Styling: The "Docs" link currently uses inline styles. For better maintainability and consistency, consider creating a reusable CSS class or leveraging existing styles from a design system.

Overall:

This pull request simplifies the navigation and improves the mobile user experience. With the suggested adjustments for visual hierarchy and link styling, this change will create a more user-friendly and consistent experience.

</details>

[Mati0x]

LOOKS GOOD!