diff --git a/studio/schemas/documents/redirect.ts b/studio/schemas/documents/redirect.ts
index 9c99a2fb1..969643d6b 100644
--- a/studio/schemas/documents/redirect.ts
+++ b/studio/schemas/documents/redirect.ts
@@ -110,8 +110,10 @@ const redirect = defineType({
       if (
         typeof sourceSlug !== "string" ||
         typeof destinationType !== "string" ||
-        typeof destinationReferenceSlug !== "string" ||
-        typeof destinationExternalURL !== "string"
+        (destinationType === "reference" &&
+          typeof destinationReferenceSlug !== "string") ||
+        (destinationType === "external" &&
+          typeof destinationExternalURL !== "string")
       ) {
         return {};
       }