Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Multi-hop routes not working automatically ; erroneous auto-transport creation #1793

Open
0pcom opened this issue Mar 27, 2024 · 2 comments
Open

Multi-hop routes not working automatically ; erroneous auto-transport creation #1793

0pcom opened this issue Mar 27, 2024 · 2 comments
Labels
breaking issue breaks critical functionality bug Something isn't working multi-hop routing

Comments

@0pcom
Copy link
Collaborator

0pcom commented Mar 27, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Regardless of the minimum hops set, the visor will attempt to make a direct transport to another public key.

A visor was started with minimum hops = 1

transports were created to several heavily transported visors (skywire-cli rtree -s | head -n100) .

A proxy server with potential multihop routes was selected and connected to.

$ skywire cli rtfind 03d8ee5d4c2c29a3d028b3a210281a52b1693120bc71e9a52ae58e2da2803284b0
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 03f1a1b354e412340ca1e8c3e59e738f1879d52213d973ad1a102c2f6e192033d8 @ 6b188449-1ece-0468-9c11-ea0494ce6444 03f1a1b354e412340ca1e8c3e59e738f1879d52213d973ad1a102c2f6e192033d8 -> 0313a76e2c331669a0cb1a3b749930881f9881cca89b59ee52365d1c15141d9d83 @ 8376c4b3-acbc-0170-9094-2d75ae39dd88 0313a76e2c331669a0cb1a3b749930881f9881cca89b59ee52365d1c15141d9d83 -> 03d8ee5d4c2c29a3d028b3a210281a52b1693120bc71e9a52ae58e2da2803284b0 @ 162bc304-8f29-0dbd-b348-24fc86126078]
 reverse: [03d8ee5d4c2c29a3d028b3a210281a52b1693120bc71e9a52ae58e2da2803284b0 -> 029fda16bb7998c1a83ad8cc5e685cf73e41d6d6c9a3a4c74d6e1668d0dc321062 @ a883750c-abbc-01aa-9768-37d3c987d09b 029fda16bb7998c1a83ad8cc5e685cf73e41d6d6c9a3a4c74d6e1668d0dc321062 -> 0360889c923eb2d898044f1e6f8e3012cc919bda20c8b81a9a9d86f802ac850cda @ 70cbd927-fdac-025d-a79f-daf7b8cd4431 0360889c923eb2d898044f1e6f8e3012cc919bda20c8b81a9a9d86f802ac850cda -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 2ea1316b-2a31-0a45-b9c4-4273c99ef371]

when the proxy server was started, a direct transport was established automatically to that visor which should not happen in this instance

When the transport was deleted, the connection was broken - despite the possibility of alternative routes and despite having more than 1 hop configured
@0pcom 0pcom added bug Something isn't working breaking issue breaks critical functionality multi-hop routing labels Mar 27, 2024
@0pcom 0pcom pinned this issue Mar 27, 2024
@0pcom 0pcom changed the title Multi-hop routes not working automatically Multi-hop routes not working automatically ; erroneous auto-transport creation Mar 28, 2024
@0pcom
Copy link
Collaborator Author

0pcom commented Apr 4, 2024 •
edited
Loading

A test of manual route creation shows that, despite the existence of a route, when starting the proxy another, a transport and another direct route is created ; the proxy actually uses that one to connect instead of the existing route!

perhaps I did not configure the route correctly @mrpalide ?

[user@linux ~]$ skywire cli route rm 1
OK
[user@linux ~]$ skywire cli route rm 8
OK
[user@linux ~]$ skywire cli route
id     type     local-port     remote-port     remote-pk     next-route-id     next-transport-id     expire-at
[user@linux ~]$ skywire cli route add c -i 1 -j 2 -k 743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed -l 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -m 49154 -p 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -q 4 --keep-alive 300s
skywire cli route add b -i 2 -j 3 -k 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 --keep-alive 300s
skywire cli route add a -i 3 -j 3 -k 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 -l 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -m 49154 -p 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -q 4 --keep-alive 300s
Routing Rule Key: 1
Routing Rule Key: 2
unknown shorthand flag: 'j' in -j
[user@linux ~]$ skywire cli route add a -i 3  -k 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 -l 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -m 49154 -p 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -q 4 --keep-alive 300s
unknown shorthand flag: 'k' in -k
[user@linux ~]$ skywire cli route add a -i 3   -l 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -m 49154 -p 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -q 4 --keep-alive 300s
Routing Rule Key: 3
[user@linux ~]$ skywire-cli proxy start -k 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9
Starting......
Running!

perhaps the issue is apparent here, some routes have the same route id! Here's the routing table:

$ skywire-cli route
id     type                    local-port     remote-port     remote-pk                                                              next-route-id     next-transport-id                        expire-at
2      Forward                 49154          4               02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105     2                 743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed     5m0s
3      IntermediaryForward     -              -               -                                                                      3                 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4     5m0s
3      Consume                 49154          4               02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9     -                 -                                        5m0s
3      Forward                 49157          3               02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9     3                 c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4     30s
10     Consume                 3              49157           0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c     -                 -                                        30s

Visor debug logging

[2024-04-04T09:28:38.078997535-05:00] DEBUG [router]: ROUTING TABLE CONTENTS: map[1:FWD(keyRtID:1, nxtRtID:2, nxtTpID:743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed, rAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:4, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49154)]
[2024-04-04T09:28:38.213824181-05:00] DEBUG [router]: ROUTING TABLE CONTENTS: map[1:FWD(keyRtID:1, nxtRtID:2, nxtTpID:743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed, rAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:4, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49154) 2:INTER(keyRtID:2, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4)]
[2024-04-04T09:29:34.80055862-05:00] DEBUG [router]: ROUTING TABLE CONTENTS: map[1:FWD(keyRtID:1, nxtRtID:2, nxtTpID:743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed, rAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:4, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49154) 2:INTER(keyRtID:2, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4) 3:REV(keyRtID:3, rAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:4, lAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:49154)]
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.527061841-05:00] INFO [visor]: Changing skysocks-client Settings to map["--addr":":1080" "--srv":"02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9" "app":"skysocks-client"]
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.527105778-05:00] INFO [visor:config]: Flushing config to file. config_version="v1.3.20-rc2-3-g9052899e8" filepath="/opt/skywire/skywire.json"
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.527402983-05:00] INFO [visor:config]: Flushing config to file. config_version="v1.3.20-rc2-3-g9052899e8" filepath="/opt/skywire/skywire.json"
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.527599869-05:00] INFO [visor]: Updated Settings.
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.527812322-05:00] DEBUG [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: No app discovery associated with app. appName="skysocks-client"
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.658191327-05:00] DEBUG [proc_manager]: Accepting proc conn... remote=127.0.0.1:50094
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.658297348-05:00] DEBUG [proc_manager]: Read hello from proc. hello="{"proc_key":"22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68"}" remote=127.0.0.1:50094
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.658334528-05:00] DEBUG [proc_manager]: Accepted proc conn. hello="{"proc_key":"22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68"}" remote=127.0.0.1:50094
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.658965306-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Established transport exist. Type: dmsg
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.659010898-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Requesting new routes from 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c to 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.658343708-05:00] DEBUG (STDOUT) [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: Version "v1.3.20-rc2-5-g3fc123817" built on "2024-04-03T14:45:35Z" against commit "3fc123817a902be7106ec4b43d00e3ff218b3186"
[2024-04-04T09:29:57.658426307-05:00] DEBUG [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: Associated and serving proc conn.
[2024-04-04T09:29:59.426735138-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Found routes Forward: [[0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 @ c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4] [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 @ 743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -> 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 @ 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4] [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 0305918027b75cabffab6f0f7a50c6eee59c3c6f994687ea23a7ea477ec195d753 @ 723bf75e-b398-014a-beb7-f0d5729607da 0305918027b75cabffab6f0f7a50c6eee59c3c6f994687ea23a7ea477ec195d753 -> 02058471ce833042566d7128cf708976a7fec5669f48647041e6e585ba29bd95c3 @ 3ed790c4-b9a8-0af8-81d5-aff79ede8101 02058471ce833042566d7128cf708976a7fec5669f48647041e6e585ba29bd95c3 -> 022d2e9ff0ab2b5ad03851b07a61c32b403570423a2b5a4567e2f4d2aabcd1119d @ d63d79c7-04d7-0e1b-870f-07e3c84fd84d 022d2e9ff0ab2b5ad03851b07a61c32b403570423a2b5a4567e2f4d2aabcd1119d -> 037d6cddd7efa411fbc7e9d7e81d625dbe8ce05c8ffeda06f12916c345be15693b @ 451b2979-a33d-08ff-8cc4-f5022496f62d 037d6cddd7efa411fbc7e9d7e81d625dbe8ce05c8ffeda06f12916c345be15693b -> 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 @ a06cdb5b-de78-02fb-bffb-fbee8ce69da0] [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 0274bd1ed89452f8edc41e3e8dde72b076f235e003e7b17043aad6b6c1c8a02ed0 @ de2fc411-a83c-0b07-b364-d3f85afb7b99 0274bd1ed89452f8edc41e3e8dde72b076f235e003e7b17043aad6b6c1c8a02ed0 -> 0359298e04891c531f2d8b7737eabd3e6c0ae907a3989b1747e8d6c9be23d78c48 @ 4b699ce9-e9cc-09c0-8fcc-8bba9c467972 0359298e04891c531f2d8b7737eabd3e6c0ae907a3989b1747e8d6c9be23d78c48 -> 02c447d38c79766fc96a68f1f7fb951d987d7df13e5f54307f85385584b9c37947 @ 5c97222b-a993-068f-aebf-9923f0914806 02c447d38c79766fc96a68f1f7fb951d987d7df13e5f54307f85385584b9c37947 -> 031eefdaa55b37d792a2c902beccf378448b7baecf34a9e1407253f0c444aa057c @ 79b40064-86f3-06af-8fcf-4aa86ee2ce2a 031eefdaa55b37d792a2c902beccf378448b7baecf34a9e1407253f0c444aa057c -> 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 @ 2cc9b18e-b4da-09a9-9c59-782ac48ddc10]]. Reverse [[02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4] [02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -> 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 @ 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed] [02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -> 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 @ 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -> 0219453427908bc29cc532906878f9d9693c2692fa2569d92f2f7236d749c88233 @ 573e4f6a-1f06-0ef0-8105-0189ab9cf7d1 0219453427908bc29cc532906878f9d9693c2692fa2569d92f2f7236d749c88233 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 5c202a3e-dea2-0ac8-ae1d-31f0d536ed19] [02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -> 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 @ 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -> 0217863fffc270544581ec3d69d95fc5e0bf9a61decedf335f421c8fe6a14bced5 @ c195d08d-8f09-0264-b6c3-edb8c395b02f 0217863fffc270544581ec3d69d95fc5e0bf9a61decedf335f421c8fe6a14bced5 -> 0374623449e68528ff4c18a8cba9b42c424c2dd4ee7e2b38b18aa7828b014a72e5 @ b033fd73-1a02-0290-914f-f957bb95371c 0374623449e68528ff4c18a8cba9b42c424c2dd4ee7e2b38b18aa7828b014a72e5 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 7622075a-3b19-0c20-b9f0-fd5da1ce815c] [02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 -> 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 @ 05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4 02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105 -> 03827409b68b9d90f33f69204895bd0463710ccdb679177a8d83a64c4538d2270d @ ebc79f2c-b3f5-08d5-be22-cc82951cbba0 03827409b68b9d90f33f69204895bd0463710ccdb679177a8d83a64c4538d2270d -> 027d8dc3b54367df8b81cbefd3ff3fcbbbd9775f448b80e3bb11e97a174c4cbb22 @ d7fa6519-6d92-06d7-b69c-fc823a860a74 027d8dc3b54367df8b81cbefd3ff3fcbbbd9775f448b80e3bb11e97a174c4cbb22 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 181221ec-d15d-0598-bfac-b742cc6e240f]]
[2024-04-04T09:30:00.558192586-05:00] DEBUG [router]: handling setup request: setupPK(0324579f003e6b4048bae2def4365e634d8e0e3054a20fc7af49daf2a179658557)
[2024-04-04T09:30:01.466244616-05:00] DEBUG [router]: ROUTING TABLE CONTENTS: map[1:FWD(keyRtID:1, nxtRtID:2, nxtTpID:743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed, rAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:4, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49154) 2:INTER(keyRtID:2, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4) 3:REV(keyRtID:3, rAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:4, lAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:49154) 9:FWD(keyRtID:9, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4, rAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157)]
[2024-04-04T09:30:01.466325241-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Save new Routing Rule with ID 9 FWD(keyRtID:9, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4, rAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157)
[2024-04-04T09:30:01.466386239-05:00] DEBUG [router]: ROUTING TABLE CONTENTS: map[1:FWD(keyRtID:1, nxtRtID:2, nxtTpID:743f7683-78da-0401-a334-c74fc0c564ed, rAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:4, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49154) 2:INTER(keyRtID:2, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:05352249-ca49-0001-aefc-1d520078ecf4) 3:REV(keyRtID:3, rAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:4, lAddr:02f933f978a025b9ccca71d585f0c75ec79710ccdd665d392988eb906ba69ba105:49154) 9:FWD(keyRtID:9, nxtRtID:3, nxtTpID:c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4, rAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3, lAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157) 10:REV(keyRtID:10, rAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157, lAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3)]
[2024-04-04T09:30:01.466440831-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Save new Routing Rule with ID 10 REV(keyRtID:10, rAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157, lAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3)
[2024-04-04T09:30:01.466496797-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Saving route group rules with desc: rAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157, lAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3
[2024-04-04T09:30:01.466670929-05:00] DEBUG [RouteGroup rAddr:0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c:49157, lAddr:02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9:3]: Sent handshake via transport c36129a1-02ee-01ee-bbd5-1df55e0220a4
[2024-04-04T09:30:02.501737577-05:00] DEBUG [router]: Created new routes to 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9 on port 49157
[2024-04-04T09:30:02.502065798-05:00] DEBUG (STDOUT) [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: Connected to 02a49534505bd949af5e14c8ec2ad6df54664f643c7af0a8f866ed7619e826c2c9
[2024-04-04T09:30:02.503473764-05:00] DEBUG (STDOUT) [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: Serving proxy client :1080
[2024-04-04T09:30:02.502303655-05:00] INFO [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: App skysocks-client is Running
[2024-04-04T09:30:14.259203565-05:00] DEBUG (STDOUT) [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: Listening skysocks client on :1080Accepted skysocks client
[2024-04-04T09:30:14.268582418-05:00] DEBUG (STDOUT) [proc:skysocks-client:22a1aac016a64590a43473830a477b68]: Opened session skysocks client

@0pcom
Copy link
Collaborator Author

0pcom commented Apr 17, 2024

Another attempt at a test of multihop routes

using transport setup-node I created transports between (10) US visors providing proxy servers of version 1.3.21 currently

skywire cli proxy list -v v1.3.21 -c US | while read _pk ; do skywire svc tps add -t dmsg -1 $_pk -2 $(skywire cli proxy list -v v1.3.21 -c US | grep -v "$_pk" | shuf -n 1) ; done

I ran the above command a few times so that enough transports would exist between those visors

after setting min_hops in the visor's config to 3 i start a visor and made transports to all of the above visors

skywire cli proxy list -v v1.3.21 -c US | while read _pk ; do skywire cli tp add -t dmsg $_pk ; done

then i check for routes

skywire cli proxy list -v v1.3.21 -c US | while read _pk ; do echo $_pk ; skywire cli route find -n2 $_pk ; echo ; done
022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 @ bf97fc52-a273-0016-b063-d7a7518fbf13 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 -> 022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a @ 01e348e4-fe70-0934-b63c-457285d05e59]
 reverse: [022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 5b38f859-3019-05d2-90b2-98c0436eb042 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221]
025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c @ 6e5ec87d-4595-04f1-b6cf-62c9e95e0ee8 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c -> 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 @ 4e0bb625-ea1a-05eb-ab3d-e7e63be78ea4]
 reverse: [025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 -> 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c @ 4e0bb625-ea1a-05eb-ab3d-e7e63be78ea4 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 6e5ec87d-4595-04f1-b6cf-62c9e95e0ee8]
02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ e3127e3f-b939-06e2-82cb-e0a091986a82 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 @ 8c71315d-c08d-05ac-8f0e-064df06ec798]
 reverse: [02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 -> 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 @ de23cd99-4e4c-00a7-a53f-4dcf7760354e 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 5b6598fd-4e13-0a72-8745-f1d587427178]
029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ 6cf783d5-9332-0686-bb2b-62ddd3304fbe]
 reverse: [029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 6cf783d5-9332-0686-bb2b-62ddd3304fbe 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221]
03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf @ 2a420c66-2670-0da8-9e55-276ddeeabbeb 0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf -> 03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63 @ 0aac49d6-b79d-0723-9add-05390e5bd4aa]
 reverse: [03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63 -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 423c17d5-c0d8-0b51-87ab-d4502cf504c6 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221]
03419b3c3f9db0404b44afc532a91eb2c108499f7575d0e7937dd8d076d385b607
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 @ eb54647a-67ab-097b-83ff-b93072e542a2 02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 -> 03419b3c3f9db0404b44afc532a91eb2c108499f7575d0e7937dd8d076d385b607 @ cd455d03-7698-0a42-bb22-bf99c24ec828]
 reverse: [03419b3c3f9db0404b44afc532a91eb2c108499f7575d0e7937dd8dskywire cli proxy list -v v1.3.21 -c US | while read _pk ; do echo $_pk ; skywire cli route find -n2 $_pk ; echo ; done
022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 @ bf97fc52-a273-0016-b063-d7a7518fbf13 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 -> 022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a @ 01e348e4-fe70-0934-b63c-457285d05e59]
 reverse: [022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 5b38f859-3019-05d2-90b2-98c0436eb042 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221]
025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c @ 6e5ec87d-4595-04f1-b6cf-62c9e95e0ee8 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c -> 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 @ 4e0bb625-ea1a-05eb-ab3d-e7e63be78ea4]
 reverse: [025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 -> 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c @ 4e0bb625-ea1a-05eb-ab3d-e7e63be78ea4 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 6e5ec87d-4595-04f1-b6cf-62c9e95e0ee8]
02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ e3127e3f-b939-06e2-82cb-e0a091986a82 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 @ 8c71315d-c08d-05ac-8f0e-064df06ec798]
 reverse: [02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 -> 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 @ de23cd99-4e4c-00a7-a53f-4dcf7760354e 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 5b6598fd-4e13-0a72-8745-f1d587427178]
029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ 6cf783d5-9332-0686-bb2b-62ddd3304fbe]
 reverse: [029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 6cf783d5-9332-0686-bb2b-62ddd3304fbe 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221]
03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf @ 2a420c66-2670-0da8-9e55-276ddeeabbeb 0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf -> 03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63 @ 0aac49d6-b79d-0723-9add-05390e5bd4aa]
 reverse: [03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63 -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 423c17d5-c0d8-0b51-87ab-d4502cf504c6 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ 22d0bf88-378f-0af9-8009-060887e0d221]
076d385b607 -> 02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 @ cd455d03-7698-0a42-bb22-bf99c24ec828 02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ eb54647a-67ab-097b-83ff-b93072e542a2]
0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 @ 5b6598fd-4e13-0a72-8745-f1d587427178 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 -> 0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c @ 8460b401-7258-0f48-ac0d-9f8929f279d9]
 reverse: [0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ bfb204ff-c558-046c-9742-e5a540d6f8d8 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ e3127e3f-b939-06e2-82cb-e0a091986a82]
0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 @ 5b6598fd-4e13-0a72-8745-f1d587427178 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 -> 0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf @ 57abbfd2-b3a8-04b5-b4dd-da7c18da42b4]
 reverse: [0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf -> 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 @ 0bedbfbd-c6f5-092a-8259-96ca71cac18f 025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419 -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ bf97fc52-a273-0016-b063-d7a7518fbf13]
03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ e3127e3f-b939-06e2-82cb-e0a091986a82 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 @ 3ffbc6d9-f11c-0c7f-9e07-28ba7a081a43]
 reverse: [03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367 -> 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec @ 3ffbc6d9-f11c-0c7f-9e07-28ba7a081a43 029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ e3127e3f-b939-06e2-82cb-e0a091986a82]
03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0
forward: [0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c -> 022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a @ f8a80bcf-35f1-0d67-bd43-37d39e1771e2 022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a -> 03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 @ 5b38f859-3019-05d2-90b2-98c0436eb042]
 reverse: [03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0 -> 022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a @ 5b38f859-3019-05d2-90b2-98c0436eb042 022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a -> 0323272a60895f56aad82cb767fb5c413807adcf7c9fb0578b1b1c5807c7f29d4c @ f8a80bcf-35f1-0d67-bd43-37d39e1771e2]

the above was with 2 hops, however when I check for a route with 3 hops, none are returned

$ skywire cli proxy list -v v1.3.21 -c US | while read _pk ; do echo $_pk ; skywire cli route find -n3 $_pk ; echo ; done
022e504c96fae546deae42f1109a9effed6ba5e427f01ec864f1fedcab6723b25a
[2024-04-17T07:58:32.124210935-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

025b8f1a36bbdc1678811c26035ce1b84e92a3bf75ab439790c82143e81a07b419
[2024-04-17T07:58:32.817154881-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

02781a0ac87d137d612bdefc5d68f420125887771e2d5cf6bc710c83ffc3b9d696
[2024-04-17T07:58:33.479610006-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

029eb3bd20846d6488132310236e2eab7d3b5dd92fb06050c765ce8f0b916eb8ec
[2024-04-17T07:58:34.150888919-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

03075370d8cc7f2b66d19795ca47f8bfe26ee5cd755029c59616c900319c2f4b63
[2024-04-17T07:58:34.80636321-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

03419b3c3f9db0404b44afc532a91eb2c108499f7575d0e7937dd8d076d385b607
[2024-04-17T07:58:35.466311774-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

0362aae9abdff59026a881fe1991e8262a2047c26842334b23744a942b2f298e0c
[2024-04-17T07:58:36.166703458-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

0383713043445e71158edc5a967207ac0e92b474218965052497b26212f4538eaf
[2024-04-17T07:58:36.84586608-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

03a3dfc9819cd6cddd97e3b2af553151f2c02263e7da0a5d55857d56a5efc59367
[2024-04-17T07:58:37.525304288-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

03edb4ea9cc744bed9c72af65c70c2e3b24f3d946f40d9ac4052538d800e1ea2d0
[2024-04-17T07:58:38.176468899-05:00] FATAL [skywire-cli]: transport not found

there should be sufficient transports in this instance to support a route with 3 hops, but none are returned.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
breaking issue breaks critical functionality bug Something isn't working multi-hop routing
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
1 participant
@0pcom