diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 877ed247..17e1877b 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ - [[PR 1]](https://github.com/parthenon-hpc-lab/athenapk/pull/1) Add isotropic thermal conduction and RKL2 supertimestepping ### Changed (changing behavior/API/variables/...) +- [[PR 97]](https://github.com/parthenon-hpc-lab/athenapk/pull/97) Fixed Schure cooling curve. Removed SD one. Added description of cooling function conventions. - [[PR 84]](https://github.com/parthenon-hpc-lab/athenapk/pull/84) Bump Parthenon to latest develop (2024-02-15) ### Fixed (not changing behavior/API/variables/...) @@ -18,6 +19,11 @@ ### Removed (removing behavior/API/varaibles/...) ### Incompatibilities (i.e. breaking changes) +- [[PR 97]](https://github.com/parthenon-hpc-lab/athenapk/pull/97) + - Removes original `schure.cooling` cooling curve as it had unknown origin. + - To avoid confusion, only cooling table for a single solar metallicity are supported + from now on (i.e., the parameters to specify temperature and lambda columns have been removed). + - Added `schure.cooling_#Z` curves (and associated notebook to calculate it from the paper tables). - [[PR 84]](https://github.com/parthenon-hpc-lab/athenapk/pull/84) Bump Parthenon to latest develop (2024-02-15) - Updated access to block dimension: `pmb->block_size.nx1` -> `pmb->block_size.nx(X1DIR)` (and similarly x2 and x3) - Update access to mesh size: `pmesh->mesh_size.x1max` -> `pmesh->mesh_size.xmax(X1DIR)` (and similarly x2, x3, and min) diff --git a/docs/cooling/cooling.ipynb b/docs/cooling/cooling.ipynb new file mode 100644 index 00000000..31b183b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling/cooling.ipynb @@ -0,0 +1,369 @@ +{ + "cells": [ + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "33ca3da4-e1e2-4dff-bf33-88072e57508e", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "import numpy as np\n", + "import unyt\n", + "\n", + "import scipy as sp\n", + "import scipy.interpolate\n", + "\n", + "import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n", + "import matplotlib as mpl" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "eadb3f5c-e2aa-44b9-8828-555cac0c8c42", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "## Load data from [Schure 2009](https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912495) Tables 2 and 4" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "6e9bfaf9-9e06-48bf-933d-b3e201e4c5f5", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "elemental_rates_data = np.genfromtxt(\"schure_table_4.txt\",\n", + " skip_header=4,\n", + " dtype=float, delimiter='\\t', names=True) \n", + "elements = elemental_rates_data.dtype.names[1:]\n", + "\n", + "log_temperature = elemental_rates_data[\"T\"]\n", + "\n", + "cooling_rates = unyt.unyt_array(np.empty( (log_temperature.size,len(elements)) ),\"cm**3*erg/s\")\n", + "\n", + "for j,element in enumerate(elements):\n", + " cooling_rates[:,j] = unyt.unyt_array(10**elemental_rates_data[element],\"cm**3*erg/s\")\n", + "\n", + "\n", + "schure_table2_data = np.loadtxt(\"schure_table_2.txt\")" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "0dda7ed5-24d0-4ab5-a703-7baa71d1e1b8", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "## Compute Cooling rates ($\\Lambda_N$) from Schure Table 4 and eq. 3" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "dd992955-c664-4dc5-9a40-0c25ebafdc88", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "z1_log_cr = np.log10( cooling_rates.sum(axis=1) )\n", + "\n", + "def compute_cr(n_over_n_sun):\n", + " return (cooling_rates*n_over_n_sun).sum(axis=1)\n", + "\n", + "z05_log_cr = np.log10( compute_cr(np.array( [1,1.0] + [1./2.,]*(len(elements)-2) ) ))\n", + "z03_log_cr = np.log10( compute_cr(np.array( [1,1] + [0.3,]*(len(elements)-2) ) ))" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "59b73548-47cf-438d-bc8b-41a691b7f5e8", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "## Compute $\\Lambda_{hd}$ from $n_e/n_H$ in Table 2 and eq. 1" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "17526d49-46cd-41ce-b12f-f682de1cdba3", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "#ne_over_nh = sp.interpolate.CubicSpline(schure_table2_data[:,0],schure_table2_data[:,3])\n", + "\n", + "start = np.where(schure_table2_data[:,0] == log_temperature[0])[0][0]\n", + "end = np.where(schure_table2_data[:,0] == log_temperature[-1])[0][0]\n", + "ne_over_nh = schure_table2_data[start:end+1,3]" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "12c2e08a-721a-4535-87b6-8d0688627d5d", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "log_x_hd = np.log10(ne_over_nh)\n", + "schure_data = np.vstack((log_temperature,log_x_hd+z1_log_cr,log_x_hd+z05_log_cr,log_x_hd+z03_log_cr))" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "abb949f6-e0eb-43d6-80db-9242e6b11ded", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "## Save the schure data with a thorough note" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "9783bc26-4023-41f4-b7ad-f5dbbab8fc7d", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "header=\"\"\"Cooling rates generated from Schure 2009 (doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912495)\n", + "containing temperatures in the first column (in log10 K) and collisional ionisation\n", + "equilibrium (CIE) cooling rates (in log10 erg cm^3/s).\n", + "Cooling rates are in the convention Lambda_hd from eq. 1,\n", + "where the proton ratio n_e/n_H is taken from table 2.\n", + "Lambda_N is computed from eq. 3. The cooling rate Lambda_N(X_i,T) from eq. 3 is contained\n", + "in table 4. n_i/n_i(solar) is taken to be 1.0 for all elements for Z=1 while for Z=0.5\n", + "and Z=0.3 n_i/n_i(solar) is set to 1 for H and He and set to 0.5 and 0.3 respectively for\n", + "all other elements. Made by Forrest Glines (forrestglines@gmail.com)\n", + "-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\"\"\"" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "b82b388b-b1db-42c0-b491-ec0acf998dd3", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "for i, z in enumerate([1.0, 0.5, 0.3]):\n", + " np.savetxt(f\"schure.cooling_{z:.1f}Z\",\n", + " schure_data.T[:,[0, i + 1]],\n", + " header=header + f\"log10 T [K] Z={z:.1f} log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s]\",\n", + " fmt=(\"%1.2f\",\"%2.4f\"))" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "ebd552ea-937d-4d26-9517-cffaf98dbeb4", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "### Process Gnat Sternberg Cooling Table" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "1a9b0fd3-a27e-46eb-b356-4d46e53bcc55", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "gnat_sternberg_data = np.loadtxt(\"gnat_sternberg_cie_table.txt\", skiprows=23)" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "fdf5d5db-a0eb-43e7-9283-29339d1d6d5a", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "header=\"\"\"Adapted from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt\n", + "Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas \n", + "Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg\n", + "Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies\n", + "-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n", + "Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1.\n", + "-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\\n\"\"\"" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "0abce35b-6775-4c43-b6a8-2ed0cd6f0e1c", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "for i, z in enumerate([1e-3, 1e-2, 1e-1, 1, 2]):\n", + " np.savetxt(f\"gnat-sternberg.cooling_{z:.1g}Z\",\n", + " np.log10(gnat_sternberg_data[:,[0, i + 1]]),\n", + " header=header + f\"log10 T [K] Z={z:.1g} log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s]\",\n", + " fmt=(\"%1.2f\",\"%2.4f\"))" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "6c7c385d-21ed-42e5-ba60-8ae76cea7185", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "## Load other cooling tables (See [Sutherland and Dopita 1993](https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/link_gateway/1993ApJS...88..253S/doi:10.1086/191823) )" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "9177f991-65fc-46a9-a8e1-8c121da5f68f", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "enzo_schure_data = np.loadtxt(\"enzo_schure.cooling\") #Schure cooling table with enzo roots\n", + "#gnat_sternberg_data = np.loadtxt(\"gnat-sternberg.cooling\")\n", + "#sutherland_dopita_data = np.loadtxt(\"cooling_data/sutherland_dopita.cooling\") #SD table with PLUTO roots\n", + "sutherland_dopita_table6_data = np.loadtxt(\"sutherland_dopita_table_6.txt\")" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "markdown", + "id": "702382fd-8067-4a7f-bb85-45838f236ff1", + "metadata": {}, + "source": [ + "## Make some plots" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "ef31148e-36d4-4ff7-b950-712e84224f12", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "fig,ax = plt.subplots()\n", + "\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,z1_log_cr,label=\"$\\\\Lambda_N$ Schure $Z_\\\\odot$\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,z05_log_cr,label=\"$\\\\Lambda_N$ Schure $0.5 Z_\\\\odot$\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,z03_log_cr,label=\"$\\\\Lambda_N$ Schure $0.3 Z_\\\\odot$\")\n", + "\n", + "\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,log_x_hd+z1_log_cr,label=\"$\\\\Lambda_{hd}$ Schure $Z_\\\\odot$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,log_x_hd+z05_log_cr,label=\"$\\\\Lambda_{hd}$ Schure $0.5 Z_\\\\odot$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,log_x_hd+z03_log_cr,label=\"$\\\\Lambda_{hd}$ Schure $0.3 Z_\\\\odot$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "\n", + "#ax.plot(enzo_schure_data[:,0],enzo_schure_data[:,1],label=\"Legacy Schure $Z_\\\\odot$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "#ax.plot(enzo_schure_data[:,0],enzo_schure_data[:,2],label=\"Legacy Schure $0.5 Z_\\\\odot$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "#ax.plot(schure_table2_data[:,0],schure_table2_data[:,1],label=\"Schure Table 2 $Z=1$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "\n", + "#ax.plot(gnat_sternberg_data[:,0],gnat_sternberg_data[:,4],label=\"GS $Z=1$\",linestyle=\":\")\n", + "#ax.plot(sutherland_dopita_data[:,0],sutherland_dopita_data[:,2],label=\"SD $Z=1$\",linestyle=\"-\")\n", + "#ax.plot(sutherland_dopita_data[:,0],sutherland_dopita_data[:,1],label=\"SD $Z=1/3$\",linestyle=\":\")\n", + "\n", + "#ax.plot(sutherland_dopita_table6_data[:,0],sutherland_dopita_table6_data[:,5],label=\"SD Table 6 $Z=1$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.legend(ncols=2)\n", + "\n", + "#ax.set_xlim(log_temperature.min(),log_temperature.max())\n", + "\n", + "ax.set_xlim(3.8,8.2)\n", + "ax.set_ylim(-23,-20)\n", + "#ax.set_ylim(-26,-20)\n", + "\n", + "ax.set_ylabel(\"Cooling Rate -- $ \\\\log \\\\Lambda$ [ cm${}^{3}$ erg/s ]\")\n", + "ax.set_xlabel(\"Temperature -- $ \\\\log T$ [ K ]\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.grid()\n", + "\n", + "plt.show()\n" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "0261a25f-2c1a-49b7-987e-3c5bf1deedf5", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "fig,ax = plt.subplots()\n", + "\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,log_x_hd+z1_log_cr,label=\"My $\\\\Lambda_{hd}$\",linestyle=\"-\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,schure_table2_data[start:end+1,2],label=\"Schure Table 2 $\\\\Lambda_{hd}$\",linestyle=\":\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,z1_log_cr,label=\"My $\\\\Lambda_{N}$\",linestyle=\"-\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,enzo_schure_data[:,1],label=\"Enzo $\\\\Lambda_{N}$\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,schure_table2_data[start:end+1,2],label=\"Schure Table 1 $\\\\Lambda_{N}$\",linestyle=\":\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.legend()\n", + "\n", + "#ax.set_xlim(log_temperature.min(),log_temperature.max())\n", + "\n", + "ax.set_xlim(3.8,8.2)\n", + "ax.set_ylim(-23,-20)\n", + "#ax.set_ylim(-26,-20)\n", + "\n", + "ax.set_ylabel(\"Cooling Rate -- $ \\\\log \\\\Lambda$ [ cm${}^{3}$ erg/s ]\")\n", + "ax.set_xlabel(\"Temperature -- $ \\\\log T$ [ K ]\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.grid()\n", + "\n", + "plt.show()\n" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "693b185a-a4c4-4602-b841-b43bfa909601", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [ + "fig,ax = plt.subplots()\n", + "\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,\n", + " (10**(log_x_hd+z1_log_cr) - 10**schure_table2_data[start:end+1,2])/10**(log_x_hd+z1_log_cr),\n", + " label=\"$\\\\Lambda_{hd}$: Mine - Schure Table 2\",linestyle=\"-\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,\n", + " (10**(z1_log_cr) - 10**schure_table2_data[start:end+1,1])/10**(z1_log_cr),\n", + " label=\"$\\\\Lambda_{N}$: Mine - Schure Table 2\",linestyle=\"--\")\n", + "ax.plot(log_temperature,\n", + " (10**(z1_log_cr) - 10**enzo_schure_data[:,1])/10**(z1_log_cr),\n", + " label=\"$\\\\Lambda_{N}$: Mine - Enzo\",linestyle=\"-\")\n", + "\n", + "\n", + "ax.legend()\n", + "\n", + "#ax.set_xlim(log_temperature.min(),log_temperature.max())\n", + "\n", + "ax.set_xlim(3.8,8.2)\n", + "#ax.set_ylim(-23,-20)\n", + "#ax.set_ylim(-26,-20)\n", + "\n", + "ax.set_ylabel(\"Relative difference in $\\\\Lambda$\")\n", + "ax.set_xlabel(\"Temperature -- $ \\\\log T$ [ K ]\")\n", + "\n", + "ax.grid()\n", + "\n", + "plt.show()" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "fb9b70d5-32e4-43db-9fcd-f1c7c481b5a4", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [] + } + ], + "metadata": { + "kernelspec": { + "display_name": "Python 3 (ipykernel)", + "language": "python", + "name": "python3" + }, + "language_info": { + "codemirror_mode": { + "name": "ipython", + "version": 3 + }, + "file_extension": ".py", + "mimetype": "text/x-python", + "name": "python", + "nbconvert_exporter": "python", + "pygments_lexer": "ipython3", + "version": "3.12.5" + } + }, + "nbformat": 4, + "nbformat_minor": 5 +} diff --git a/docs/cooling/cooling_curves_LambdaHD.png b/docs/cooling/cooling_curves_LambdaHD.png new file mode 100644 index 00000000..24479cea Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/cooling/cooling_curves_LambdaHD.png differ diff --git a/docs/cooling/cooling_curves_nHneLambda.png b/docs/cooling/cooling_curves_nHneLambda.png new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b37fc0fc Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/cooling/cooling_curves_nHneLambda.png differ diff --git a/docs/cooling/gnat_sternberg_cie_table.txt b/docs/cooling/gnat_sternberg_cie_table.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..01d22595 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling/gnat_sternberg_cie_table.txt @@ -0,0 +1,224 @@ +## Downloaded from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt +Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas +Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg +Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies +================================================================================ +Byte-by-byte Description of file: datafile13.txt +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- + Bytes Format Units Label Explanations +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- + 1- 10 A10 K Temperature Temperature + 12- 19 A8 10-13.J.m+3.s-1 Lambda(Z=1e-3) Cooling Efficiency (erg cm^3 + s^-1) + 21- 28 A8 10-13.J.m+3.s-1 Lambda(Z=1e-2) Cooling Efficiency (erg cm^3 + s^-1) + 30- 37 A8 10-13.J.m+310-1 Lambda(Z=1e-1) Cooling Efficiency (erg cm^3 + s^-1) + 39- 46 A8 10-13.J.m+3.s-1 Lambda(Z=1) Cooling Efficiency (erg cm^3 + s^-1) + 48- 55 A8 10-13.J.m+3.s-1 Lambda(Z=2) Cooling Efficiency (erg cm^3 + s^-1) +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +Note (1): Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1. +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +1.0000e+04 4.70e-24 4.98e-24 7.78e-24 5.59e-23 3.77e-22 +1.0470e+04 7.62e-24 7.79e-24 9.55e-24 3.09e-23 6.96e-23 +1.0970e+04 1.23e-23 1.25e-23 1.39e-23 2.86e-23 4.76e-23 +1.1490e+04 1.97e-23 1.98e-23 2.11e-23 3.41e-23 4.93e-23 +1.2030e+04 3.08e-23 3.09e-23 3.22e-23 4.51e-23 5.98e-23 +1.2600e+04 4.66e-23 4.67e-23 4.81e-23 6.16e-23 7.68e-23 +1.3200e+04 6.78e-23 6.80e-23 6.93e-23 8.39e-23 1.00e-22 +1.3830e+04 9.40e-23 9.41e-23 9.58e-23 1.11e-22 1.28e-22 +1.4480e+04 1.22e-22 1.22e-22 1.24e-22 1.41e-22 1.60e-22 +1.5170e+04 1.47e-22 1.47e-22 1.49e-22 1.67e-22 1.88e-22 +1.5890e+04 1.65e-22 1.65e-22 1.67e-22 1.86e-22 2.09e-22 +1.6640e+04 1.71e-22 1.71e-22 1.73e-22 1.94e-22 2.17e-22 +1.7430e+04 1.69e-22 1.69e-22 1.71e-22 1.92e-22 2.15e-22 +1.8250e+04 1.59e-22 1.59e-22 1.61e-22 1.82e-22 2.06e-22 +1.9120e+04 1.46e-22 1.47e-22 1.49e-22 1.70e-22 1.93e-22 +2.0020e+04 1.32e-22 1.32e-22 1.34e-22 1.55e-22 1.79e-22 +2.0970e+04 1.18e-22 1.18e-22 1.21e-22 1.43e-22 1.67e-22 +2.1960e+04 1.05e-22 1.05e-22 1.08e-22 1.31e-22 1.57e-22 +2.3000e+04 9.40e-23 9.42e-23 9.67e-23 1.21e-22 1.49e-22 +2.4090e+04 8.44e-23 8.46e-23 8.72e-23 1.14e-22 1.43e-22 +2.5240e+04 7.60e-23 7.63e-23 7.91e-23 1.08e-22 1.39e-22 +2.6430e+04 6.88e-23 6.91e-23 7.21e-23 1.03e-22 1.38e-22 +2.7680e+04 6.25e-23 6.29e-23 6.63e-23 1.00e-22 1.38e-22 +2.8990e+04 5.71e-23 5.75e-23 6.13e-23 9.85e-23 1.40e-22 +3.0370e+04 5.23e-23 5.27e-23 5.67e-23 9.77e-23 1.43e-22 +3.1810e+04 4.77e-23 4.82e-23 5.27e-23 9.77e-23 1.48e-22 +3.3310e+04 4.35e-23 4.40e-23 4.91e-23 9.88e-23 1.54e-22 +3.4890e+04 3.98e-23 4.04e-23 4.58e-23 1.01e-22 1.62e-22 +3.6540e+04 3.65e-23 3.71e-23 4.32e-23 1.04e-22 1.72e-22 +3.8280e+04 3.35e-23 3.42e-23 4.09e-23 1.08e-22 1.84e-22 +4.0090e+04 3.09e-23 3.16e-23 3.92e-23 1.14e-22 1.97e-22 +4.1990e+04 2.88e-23 2.96e-23 3.79e-23 1.21e-22 2.13e-22 +4.3980e+04 2.72e-23 2.81e-23 3.72e-23 1.29e-22 2.30e-22 +4.6060e+04 2.61e-23 2.71e-23 3.72e-23 1.38e-22 2.50e-22 +4.8240e+04 2.57e-23 2.68e-23 3.79e-23 1.49e-22 2.73e-22 +5.0530e+04 2.60e-23 2.72e-23 3.95e-23 1.62e-22 2.98e-22 +5.2920e+04 2.74e-23 2.87e-23 4.21e-23 1.77e-22 3.27e-22 +5.5430e+04 3.00e-23 3.15e-23 4.62e-23 1.94e-22 3.58e-22 +5.8050e+04 3.41e-23 3.57e-23 5.18e-23 2.13e-22 3.93e-22 +6.0800e+04 3.99e-23 4.17e-23 5.92e-23 2.35e-22 4.31e-22 +6.3680e+04 4.74e-23 4.93e-23 6.83e-23 2.59e-22 4.72e-22 +6.6700e+04 5.63e-23 5.83e-23 7.89e-23 2.85e-22 5.15e-22 +6.9860e+04 6.56e-23 6.78e-23 9.00e-23 3.12e-22 5.59e-22 +7.3170e+04 7.43e-23 7.67e-23 1.00e-22 3.37e-22 6.02e-22 +7.6630e+04 8.11e-23 8.36e-23 1.09e-22 3.61e-22 6.42e-22 +8.0260e+04 8.49e-23 8.75e-23 1.14e-22 3.80e-22 6.77e-22 +8.4070e+04 8.55e-23 8.84e-23 1.16e-22 3.97e-22 7.09e-22 +8.8050e+04 8.35e-23 8.64e-23 1.16e-22 4.10e-22 7.38e-22 +9.2220e+04 7.95e-23 8.26e-23 1.13e-22 4.20e-22 7.63e-22 +9.6590e+04 7.42e-23 7.74e-23 1.09e-22 4.28e-22 7.83e-22 +1.0120e+05 6.86e-23 7.19e-23 1.05e-22 4.32e-22 7.98e-22 +1.0600e+05 6.29e-23 6.62e-23 9.94e-23 4.32e-22 8.03e-22 +1.1100e+05 5.74e-23 6.07e-23 9.39e-23 4.27e-22 7.99e-22 +1.1620e+05 5.22e-23 5.55e-23 8.86e-23 4.20e-22 7.88e-22 +1.2170e+05 4.76e-23 5.08e-23 8.35e-23 4.11e-22 7.76e-22 +1.2750e+05 4.33e-23 4.66e-23 7.89e-23 4.03e-22 7.66e-22 +1.3350e+05 3.95e-23 4.28e-23 7.52e-23 3.99e-22 7.62e-22 +1.3990e+05 3.61e-23 3.94e-23 7.21e-23 3.99e-22 7.65e-22 +1.4650e+05 3.31e-23 3.64e-23 6.96e-23 4.02e-22 7.74e-22 +1.5340e+05 3.04e-23 3.38e-23 6.77e-23 4.08e-22 7.88e-22 +1.6070e+05 2.80e-23 3.15e-23 6.62e-23 4.15e-22 8.05e-22 +1.6830e+05 2.58e-23 2.94e-23 6.49e-23 4.22e-22 8.21e-22 +1.7630e+05 2.39e-23 2.75e-23 6.39e-23 4.29e-22 8.37e-22 +1.8460e+05 2.22e-23 2.59e-23 6.29e-23 4.35e-22 8.50e-22 +1.9340e+05 2.06e-23 2.44e-23 6.21e-23 4.41e-22 8.64e-22 +2.0260e+05 1.92e-23 2.31e-23 6.15e-23 4.47e-22 8.79e-22 +2.1210e+05 1.80e-23 2.19e-23 6.11e-23 4.54e-22 8.94e-22 +2.2220e+05 1.68e-23 2.08e-23 6.06e-23 4.60e-22 9.08e-22 +2.3270e+05 1.58e-23 1.98e-23 6.00e-23 4.64e-22 9.16e-22 +2.4370e+05 1.49e-23 1.89e-23 5.90e-23 4.62e-22 9.13e-22 +2.5530e+05 1.40e-23 1.79e-23 5.73e-23 4.52e-22 8.95e-22 +2.6740e+05 1.32e-23 1.70e-23 5.46e-23 4.33e-22 8.56e-22 +2.8000e+05 1.25e-23 1.60e-23 5.10e-23 4.03e-22 7.97e-22 +2.9330e+05 1.11e-23 1.43e-23 4.62e-23 3.67e-22 7.25e-22 +3.0720e+05 1.05e-23 1.34e-23 4.21e-23 3.31e-22 6.55e-22 +3.2180e+05 9.95e-24 1.25e-23 3.86e-23 3.00e-22 5.93e-22 +3.3700e+05 9.46e-24 1.19e-23 3.58e-23 2.76e-22 5.46e-22 +3.5300e+05 9.01e-24 1.13e-23 3.37e-23 2.59e-22 5.12e-22 +3.6970e+05 8.61e-24 1.08e-23 3.23e-23 2.48e-22 4.91e-22 +3.8720e+05 8.25e-24 1.03e-23 3.12e-23 2.41e-22 4.77e-22 +4.0560e+05 7.92e-24 9.98e-24 3.06e-23 2.38e-22 4.70e-22 +4.2480e+05 7.63e-24 9.67e-24 3.01e-23 2.36e-22 4.66e-22 +4.4490e+05 7.36e-24 9.39e-24 2.97e-23 2.34e-22 4.64e-22 +4.6600e+05 7.10e-24 9.13e-24 2.93e-23 2.33e-22 4.60e-22 +4.8800e+05 6.87e-24 8.87e-24 2.89e-23 2.30e-22 4.56e-22 +5.1110e+05 6.65e-24 8.62e-24 2.83e-23 2.26e-22 4.48e-22 +5.3540e+05 6.44e-24 8.35e-24 2.75e-23 2.20e-22 4.35e-22 +5.6070e+05 6.24e-24 8.06e-24 2.63e-23 2.10e-22 4.15e-22 +5.8730e+05 6.05e-24 7.77e-24 2.50e-23 1.98e-22 3.92e-22 +6.1510e+05 5.88e-24 7.49e-24 2.36e-23 1.86e-22 3.68e-22 +6.4420e+05 5.72e-24 7.22e-24 2.22e-23 1.73e-22 3.42e-22 +6.7480e+05 5.59e-24 7.00e-24 2.12e-23 1.64e-22 3.24e-22 +7.0670e+05 5.47e-24 6.81e-24 2.02e-23 1.55e-22 3.07e-22 +7.4020e+05 5.36e-24 6.66e-24 1.97e-23 1.51e-22 2.98e-22 +7.7530e+05 5.26e-24 6.54e-24 1.93e-23 1.47e-22 2.91e-22 +8.1200e+05 5.18e-24 6.43e-24 1.90e-23 1.46e-22 2.88e-22 +8.5040e+05 5.10e-24 6.35e-24 1.88e-23 1.44e-22 2.85e-22 +8.9070e+05 5.04e-24 6.28e-24 1.87e-23 1.44e-22 2.84e-22 +9.3290e+05 4.98e-24 6.22e-24 1.86e-23 1.43e-22 2.83e-22 +9.7710e+05 4.93e-24 6.15e-24 1.83e-23 1.41e-22 2.79e-22 +1.0000e+06 4.90e-24 6.12e-24 1.83e-23 1.41e-22 2.78e-22 +1.0470e+06 4.87e-24 6.07e-24 1.80e-23 1.38e-22 2.74e-22 +1.0960e+06 4.85e-24 6.02e-24 1.77e-23 1.36e-22 2.68e-22 +1.1480e+06 4.83e-24 5.97e-24 1.74e-23 1.33e-22 2.62e-22 +1.2020e+06 4.82e-24 5.94e-24 1.72e-23 1.30e-22 2.57e-22 +1.2590e+06 4.81e-24 5.91e-24 1.70e-23 1.28e-22 2.53e-22 +1.3180e+06 4.81e-24 5.88e-24 1.66e-23 1.25e-22 2.47e-22 +1.3800e+06 4.81e-24 5.86e-24 1.64e-23 1.23e-22 2.42e-22 +1.4450e+06 4.81e-24 5.85e-24 1.62e-23 1.20e-22 2.37e-22 +1.5140e+06 4.82e-24 5.83e-24 1.59e-23 1.17e-22 2.31e-22 +1.5850e+06 4.84e-24 5.81e-24 1.55e-23 1.13e-22 2.23e-22 +1.6600e+06 4.85e-24 5.78e-24 1.51e-23 1.09e-22 2.14e-22 +1.7380e+06 4.87e-24 5.75e-24 1.46e-23 1.04e-22 2.04e-22 +1.8200e+06 4.89e-24 5.72e-24 1.41e-23 9.80e-23 1.92e-22 +1.9060e+06 4.91e-24 5.70e-24 1.35e-23 9.23e-23 1.81e-22 +1.9950e+06 4.94e-24 5.67e-24 1.30e-23 8.64e-23 1.69e-22 +2.0890e+06 4.88e-24 5.56e-24 1.23e-23 8.05e-23 1.57e-22 +2.1880e+06 4.92e-24 5.55e-24 1.18e-23 7.53e-23 1.47e-22 +2.2910e+06 4.96e-24 5.54e-24 1.14e-23 7.05e-23 1.37e-22 +2.3990e+06 5.00e-24 5.55e-24 1.10e-23 6.61e-23 1.28e-22 +2.5120e+06 5.05e-24 5.56e-24 1.07e-23 6.21e-23 1.20e-22 +2.6300e+06 5.09e-24 5.57e-24 1.03e-23 5.82e-23 1.12e-22 +2.7540e+06 5.14e-24 5.59e-24 1.00e-23 5.48e-23 1.05e-22 +2.8840e+06 5.20e-24 5.61e-24 9.75e-24 5.15e-23 9.84e-23 +3.0200e+06 5.25e-24 5.64e-24 9.51e-24 4.85e-23 9.23e-23 +3.1620e+06 5.31e-24 5.67e-24 9.29e-24 4.58e-23 8.68e-23 +3.3110e+06 5.39e-24 5.73e-24 9.13e-24 4.34e-23 8.20e-23 +3.4670e+06 5.47e-24 5.79e-24 8.99e-24 4.13e-23 7.76e-23 +3.6310e+06 5.55e-24 5.86e-24 8.91e-24 3.96e-23 7.42e-23 +3.8020e+06 5.64e-24 5.93e-24 8.84e-24 3.81e-23 7.11e-23 +3.9810e+06 5.73e-24 6.01e-24 8.79e-24 3.69e-23 6.85e-23 +4.1690e+06 5.82e-24 6.09e-24 8.77e-24 3.58e-23 6.61e-23 +4.3650e+06 5.92e-24 6.18e-24 8.76e-24 3.48e-23 6.41e-23 +4.5710e+06 6.01e-24 6.26e-24 8.77e-24 3.40e-23 6.24e-23 +4.7860e+06 6.11e-24 6.36e-24 8.79e-24 3.32e-23 6.07e-23 +5.0120e+06 6.22e-24 6.45e-24 8.81e-24 3.26e-23 5.93e-23 +5.2480e+06 6.32e-24 6.55e-24 8.85e-24 3.19e-23 5.79e-23 +5.4950e+06 6.43e-24 6.65e-24 8.89e-24 3.14e-23 5.68e-23 +5.7540e+06 6.53e-24 6.75e-24 8.94e-24 3.09e-23 5.57e-23 +6.0260e+06 6.64e-24 6.86e-24 9.00e-24 3.06e-23 5.49e-23 +6.3100e+06 6.76e-24 6.97e-24 9.08e-24 3.03e-23 5.42e-23 +6.6070e+06 6.87e-24 7.08e-24 9.15e-24 3.01e-23 5.36e-23 +6.9180e+06 6.99e-24 7.19e-24 9.24e-24 2.99e-23 5.31e-23 +7.2440e+06 7.11e-24 7.31e-24 9.35e-24 2.99e-23 5.31e-23 +7.5860e+06 7.23e-24 7.43e-24 9.45e-24 2.98e-23 5.27e-23 +7.9430e+06 7.35e-24 7.55e-24 9.56e-24 2.98e-23 5.26e-23 +8.3180e+06 7.48e-24 7.68e-24 9.66e-24 2.97e-23 5.23e-23 +8.7100e+06 7.60e-24 7.80e-24 9.77e-24 2.96e-23 5.20e-23 +9.1200e+06 7.73e-24 7.93e-24 9.87e-24 2.95e-23 5.16e-23 +9.5500e+06 7.86e-24 8.06e-24 9.98e-24 2.94e-23 5.13e-23 +1.0000e+07 8.00e-24 8.19e-24 1.01e-23 2.92e-23 5.08e-23 +1.0470e+07 8.16e-24 8.35e-24 1.02e-23 2.89e-23 5.00e-23 +1.0960e+07 8.33e-24 8.52e-24 1.03e-23 2.86e-23 4.92e-23 +1.1480e+07 8.51e-24 8.68e-24 1.04e-23 2.82e-23 4.82e-23 +1.2020e+07 8.68e-24 8.85e-24 1.05e-23 2.75e-23 4.66e-23 +1.2590e+07 8.87e-24 9.03e-24 1.06e-23 2.69e-23 4.52e-23 +1.3180e+07 9.05e-24 9.21e-24 1.07e-23 2.62e-23 4.36e-23 +1.3800e+07 9.21e-24 9.35e-24 1.08e-23 2.54e-23 4.18e-23 +1.4450e+07 9.39e-24 9.53e-24 1.09e-23 2.46e-23 4.00e-23 +1.5140e+07 9.59e-24 9.72e-24 1.10e-23 2.37e-23 3.81e-23 +1.5850e+07 9.80e-24 9.91e-24 1.11e-23 2.30e-23 3.64e-23 +1.6600e+07 9.99e-24 1.01e-23 1.12e-23 2.22e-23 3.47e-23 +1.7380e+07 1.02e-23 1.03e-23 1.13e-23 2.15e-23 3.30e-23 +1.8200e+07 1.04e-23 1.05e-23 1.14e-23 2.09e-23 3.16e-23 +1.9060e+07 1.06e-23 1.07e-23 1.16e-23 2.04e-23 3.03e-23 +1.9950e+07 1.08e-23 1.09e-23 1.17e-23 2.00e-23 2.92e-23 +2.0890e+07 1.11e-23 1.11e-23 1.19e-23 1.96e-23 2.83e-23 +2.1880e+07 1.13e-23 1.14e-23 1.21e-23 1.93e-23 2.75e-23 +2.2910e+07 1.15e-23 1.16e-23 1.22e-23 1.91e-23 2.69e-23 +2.3990e+07 1.17e-23 1.18e-23 1.24e-23 1.90e-23 2.64e-23 +2.5120e+07 1.20e-23 1.20e-23 1.26e-23 1.89e-23 2.60e-23 +2.6300e+07 1.22e-23 1.23e-23 1.28e-23 1.89e-23 2.57e-23 +2.7540e+07 1.24e-23 1.25e-23 1.31e-23 1.89e-23 2.55e-23 +2.8840e+07 1.27e-23 1.27e-23 1.33e-23 1.90e-23 2.54e-23 +3.0200e+07 1.29e-23 1.30e-23 1.35e-23 1.91e-23 2.53e-23 +3.1620e+07 1.31e-23 1.32e-23 1.37e-23 1.92e-23 2.54e-23 +3.3110e+07 1.34e-23 1.35e-23 1.40e-23 1.94e-23 2.56e-23 +3.4670e+07 1.37e-23 1.38e-23 1.43e-23 1.97e-23 2.58e-23 +3.6310e+07 1.40e-23 1.41e-23 1.46e-23 2.00e-23 2.60e-23 +3.8020e+07 1.43e-23 1.44e-23 1.49e-23 2.03e-23 2.63e-23 +3.9810e+07 1.46e-23 1.47e-23 1.52e-23 2.06e-23 2.67e-23 +4.1690e+07 1.49e-23 1.50e-23 1.55e-23 2.09e-23 2.70e-23 +4.3650e+07 1.52e-23 1.52e-23 1.58e-23 2.12e-23 2.74e-23 +4.5710e+07 1.55e-23 1.55e-23 1.61e-23 2.16e-23 2.79e-23 +4.7860e+07 1.58e-23 1.58e-23 1.64e-23 2.20e-23 2.83e-23 +5.0120e+07 1.61e-23 1.61e-23 1.67e-23 2.24e-23 2.88e-23 +5.2480e+07 1.64e-23 1.64e-23 1.70e-23 2.27e-23 2.91e-23 +5.4950e+07 1.66e-23 1.67e-23 1.73e-23 2.31e-23 2.96e-23 +5.7540e+07 1.69e-23 1.70e-23 1.75e-23 2.34e-23 3.00e-23 +6.0260e+07 1.72e-23 1.72e-23 1.78e-23 2.38e-23 3.05e-23 +6.3100e+07 1.74e-23 1.75e-23 1.81e-23 2.41e-23 3.08e-23 +6.6070e+07 1.77e-23 1.78e-23 1.83e-23 2.44e-23 3.12e-23 +6.9180e+07 1.79e-23 1.80e-23 1.86e-23 2.47e-23 3.15e-23 +7.2440e+07 1.82e-23 1.82e-23 1.88e-23 2.50e-23 3.19e-23 +7.5860e+07 1.84e-23 1.85e-23 1.91e-23 2.52e-23 3.21e-23 +7.9430e+07 1.86e-23 1.87e-23 1.93e-23 2.55e-23 3.24e-23 +8.3180e+07 1.88e-23 1.89e-23 1.95e-23 2.56e-23 3.25e-23 +8.7100e+07 1.91e-23 1.91e-23 1.97e-23 2.58e-23 3.26e-23 +9.1200e+07 1.92e-23 1.93e-23 1.99e-23 2.59e-23 3.27e-23 +9.5500e+07 1.94e-23 1.95e-23 2.00e-23 2.60e-23 3.26e-23 +1.0000e+08 1.96e-23 1.96e-23 2.02e-23 2.61e-23 3.27e-23 diff --git a/docs/cooling/plot_lambda.py b/docs/cooling/plot_lambda.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ccb9b5bc --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling/plot_lambda.py @@ -0,0 +1,73 @@ +import numpy as np +import matplotlib.pyplot as plt + +if __name__ == "__main__": + ## plot *solar abundance* CIE cooling curves + + ## Sutherland and Dopita (1993) [NOTE: n_i n_e convention for Lambda_N, where n_t == n_i in their notation] + # Columns: Log(T), n_e, n_H, n_t, log(\Lambda_net), log(\Lambda_N) + sd_LogT, sd_ne, sd_nH, sd_nt, sd_logLambdaNet, sd_logLambdaN = np.loadtxt( + "sutherland_dopita_table_6.txt", unpack=True + ) + # convert to Lambda_hd: + sd_LambdaN = 10.0**sd_logLambdaN + sd_LambdaHD = (sd_ne * sd_nt * sd_LambdaN) / sd_nH**2 + # convert to nH ne Lambda(T): + sd_nHneLambda = (sd_ne * sd_nt * sd_LambdaN) / (sd_nH * sd_ne) + + ## Schure et al. (2009) [NOTE: n_H n_e convention for Lambda_N; n_H^2 convention for Lambda_hd] + # Columns: log T (K), log Λ_N (erg s^−1 cm^3), log Λ_hd (erg s^−1 cm^3), n_e/n_H + # BEWARE: This Lambda_N is NOT the same as the Sutherland and Dopita Lambda_N! + s_LogT, s_logLambdaN, s_logLambdaHD, s_ne_over_nH = np.loadtxt( + "schure_table_2.txt", unpack=True + ) + s_LambdaHD = 10.0**s_logLambdaHD + + ## Gnat and Sternberg (2007) [NOTE: n_H n_e convention for Lambda] + # Columns: Temperature Lambda(Z=1e-3) Lambda(Z=1e-2) Lambda(Z=1e-1) Lambda(Z=1) Lambda(Z=2) + ( + gs_T, + gs_LambdaZem3, + gs_LambdaZem2, + gs_LambdaZem1, + gs_LambdaZ1, + gs_LambdaZ2, + ) = np.loadtxt("gnat_sternberg_cie_table.txt", unpack=True, skiprows=23) + # NOTE: There is not enough information in this table alone to compute n_e! + # (The electron fraction must be computed from datafile2a.txt) + + # plot nH^2-normalized Lambda(T) + plt.figure() + plt.plot( + sd_LogT, + sd_LambdaHD, + label=r"Sutherland & Dopita $\Lambda_{hd}$ for $Z_{\odot}$", + ) + plt.plot(s_LogT, s_LambdaHD, label=r"Schure et al. $\Lambda_{hd}$ for $Z_{\odot}$") + # (Gnat & Sternberg cannot be converted to this convention without the electron fraction, which is missing.) + plt.yscale("log") + plt.ylim(1e-23, 3e-21) + plt.xlabel(r"$\log T$ (K)") + plt.ylabel(r"$\Lambda(T)$ [$n_H^2$ convention]") + plt.legend() + plt.tight_layout() + plt.savefig("cooling_curves_LambdaHD.png") + + # plot nH ne-normalized Lambda(T) + plt.figure() + plt.plot( + sd_LogT, sd_nHneLambda, label=r"Sutherland & Dopita $\Lambda$ for $Z_{\odot}$" + ) + plt.plot( + s_LogT, 10.0**s_logLambdaN, label=r"Schure et al. $\Lambda$ for $Z_{\odot}$" + ) + plt.plot( + np.log10(gs_T), gs_LambdaZ1, label=r"Gnat & Sternberg $\Lambda$ for $Z_{\odot}$" + ) + plt.yscale("log") + plt.ylim(1e-23, 3e-21) + plt.xlabel(r"$\log T$ (K)") + plt.ylabel(r"$\Lambda(T)$ [$n_H n_e$ convention]") + plt.legend() + plt.tight_layout() + plt.savefig("cooling_curves_nHneLambda.png") diff --git a/docs/cooling/schure_table_2.txt b/docs/cooling/schure_table_2.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..a3409335 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling/schure_table_2.txt @@ -0,0 +1,112 @@ +## This is an exact reproduction of "Table 2. Cooling curve for solar metallicity" from Schure et al. (2009). +## log T (K), log Λ_N (erg s^−1 cm^3), log Λ_hd (erg s^−1 cm^3), n_e/n_H +3.8 -25.7331 -30.6104 1.3264e-05 +3.84 -25.0383 -29.4107 4.2428e-05 +3.88 -24.4059 -28.4601 8.8276e-05 +3.92 -23.8288 -27.5743 0.00017967 +3.96 -23.3027 -26.3766 0.00084362 +4.0 -22.8242 -25.289 0.0034295 +4.04 -22.3917 -24.2684 0.013283 +4.08 -22.0067 -23.3834 0.042008 +4.12 -21.6818 -22.5977 0.12138 +4.16 -21.4529 -21.9689 0.30481 +4.2 -21.3246 -21.5972 0.53386 +4.24 -21.3459 -21.4615 0.76622 +4.28 -21.4305 -21.4789 0.89459 +4.32 -21.5293 -21.5497 0.95414 +4.36 -21.6138 -21.6211 0.98342 +4.4 -21.6615 -21.6595 1.0046 +4.44 -21.6551 -21.6426 1.0291 +4.48 -21.5919 -21.5688 1.0547 +4.52 -21.5092 -21.4771 1.0767 +4.56 -21.4124 -21.3755 1.0888 +4.6 -21.3085 -21.2693 1.0945 +4.64 -21.2047 -21.1644 1.0972 +4.68 -21.1067 -21.0658 1.0988 +4.72 -21.0194 -20.9778 1.1004 +4.76 -20.9413 -20.8986 1.1034 +4.8 -20.8735 -20.8281 1.1102 +4.84 -20.8205 -20.77 1.1233 +4.88 -20.7805 -20.7223 1.1433 +4.92 -20.7547 -20.6888 1.1638 +4.96 -20.7455 -20.6739 1.1791 +5.0 -20.7565 -20.6815 1.1885 +5.04 -20.782 -20.7051 1.1937 +5.08 -20.8008 -20.7229 1.1966 +5.12 -20.7994 -20.7208 1.1983 +5.16 -20.7847 -20.7058 1.1993 +5.2 -20.7687 -20.6896 1.1999 +5.24 -20.759 -20.6797 1.2004 +5.28 -20.7544 -20.6749 1.2008 +5.32 -20.7505 -20.6709 1.2012 +5.36 -20.7545 -20.6748 1.2015 +5.4 -20.7888 -20.7089 1.202 +5.44 -20.8832 -20.8031 1.2025 +5.48 -21.045 -20.9647 1.203 +5.52 -21.2286 -21.1482 1.2035 +5.56 -21.3737 -21.2932 1.2037 +5.6 -21.4573 -21.3767 1.2039 +5.64 -21.4935 -21.4129 1.204 +5.68 -21.5098 -21.4291 1.2041 +5.72 -21.5345 -21.4538 1.2042 +5.76 -21.5863 -21.5055 1.2044 +5.8 -21.6548 -21.574 1.2045 +5.84 -21.7108 -21.63 1.2046 +5.88 -21.7424 -21.6615 1.2047 +5.92 -21.7576 -21.6766 1.2049 +5.96 -21.7696 -21.6886 1.205 +6.0 -21.7883 -21.7073 1.2051 +6.04 -21.8115 -21.7304 1.2053 +6.08 -21.8303 -21.7491 1.2055 +6.12 -21.8419 -21.7607 1.2056 +6.16 -21.8514 -21.7701 1.2058 +6.2 -21.869 -21.7877 1.206 +6.24 -21.9057 -21.8243 1.2062 +6.28 -21.969 -21.8875 1.2065 +6.32 -22.0554 -21.9738 1.2067 +6.36 -22.1488 -22.0671 1.207 +6.4 -22.2355 -22.1537 1.2072 +6.44 -22.3084 -22.2265 1.2075 +6.48 -22.3641 -22.2821 1.2077 +6.52 -22.4033 -22.3213 1.2078 +6.56 -22.4282 -22.3462 1.2079 +6.6 -22.4408 -22.3587 1.208 +6.64 -22.4443 -22.3622 1.2081 +6.68 -22.4411 -22.359 1.2082 +6.72 -22.4334 -22.3512 1.2083 +6.76 -22.4242 -22.342 1.2083 +6.8 -22.4164 -22.3342 1.2084 +6.84 -22.4134 -22.3312 1.2084 +6.88 -22.4168 -22.3346 1.2085 +6.92 -22.4267 -22.3445 1.2085 +6.96 -22.4418 -22.3595 1.2086 +7.0 -22.4603 -22.378 1.2086 +7.04 -22.483 -22.4007 1.2087 +7.08 -22.5112 -22.4289 1.2087 +7.12 -22.5449 -22.4625 1.2088 +7.16 -22.5819 -22.4995 1.2088 +7.2 -22.6177 -22.5353 1.2089 +7.24 -22.6483 -22.5659 1.2089 +7.28 -22.6719 -22.5895 1.2089 +7.32 -22.6883 -22.6059 1.2089 +7.36 -22.6985 -22.6161 1.2089 +7.4 -22.7032 -22.6208 1.209 +7.44 -22.7037 -22.6213 1.209 +7.48 -22.7008 -22.6184 1.209 +7.52 -22.695 -22.6126 1.209 +7.56 -22.6869 -22.6045 1.209 +7.6 -22.6769 -22.5945 1.209 +7.64 -22.6655 -22.5831 1.209 +7.68 -22.6531 -22.5707 1.209 +7.72 -22.6397 -22.5573 1.209 +7.76 -22.6258 -22.5434 1.209 +7.8 -22.6111 -22.5287 1.209 +7.84 -22.5964 -22.514 1.209 +7.88 -22.5816 -22.4992 1.209 +7.92 -22.5668 -22.4844 1.209 +7.96 -22.5519 -22.4695 1.209 +8.0 -22.5367 -22.4543 1.209 +8.04 -22.5216 -22.4392 1.209 +8.08 -22.5062 -22.4237 1.2091 +8.12 -22.4912 -22.4087 1.2091 +8.16 -22.4753 -22.3928 1.2091 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/cooling/schure_table_4.txt b/docs/cooling/schure_table_4.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e3c41418 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling/schure_table_4.txt @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +# Table 4 from Schure 2009 https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912495 +# Copied directly from https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2009/47/aa12495-09/table4.html +# First column is Temperature (log K) +# Other columns are Cooling rates (in log cm^3 erg/s ?) +T H He C N O Ne Na Mg Al Si S Ar Ca Fe Ni +4.20 -21.34 -25.79 -23.63 -24.86 -24.94 -26.60 -29.35 -27.47 -24.51 -23.93 -26.58 -28.18 -28.59 -27.37 -28.96 +4.24 -21.37 -25.25 -23.39 -24.63 -24.55 -26.16 -29.35 -27.34 -24.31 -23.60 -26.33 -28.01 -28.56 -27.23 -28.92 +4.28 -21.47 -24.76 -23.16 -24.41 -24.18 -25.77 -29.35 -27.26 -24.13 -23.30 -26.09 -27.95 -28.55 -27.12 -28.86 +4.32 -21.59 -24.31 -22.95 -24.18 -23.84 -25.45 -29.33 -27.24 -23.97 -23.00 -25.85 -27.93 -28.55 -27.06 -28.80 +4.36 -21.71 -23.91 -22.75 -23.95 -23.54 -25.22 -29.23 -27.25 -23.83 -22.74 -25.59 -27.93 -28.55 -27.04 -28.77 +4.40 -21.83 -23.58 -22.56 -23.73 -23.27 -25.00 -28.98 -27.27 -23.71 -22.52 -25.34 -27.95 -28.56 -27.04 -28.75 +4.44 -21.94 -23.34 -22.37 -23.52 -23.02 -25.05 -28.58 -27.28 -23.61 -22.33 -25.11 -27.96 -28.56 -27.04 -28.72 +4.48 -22.05 -23.22 -22.18 -23.32 -22.79 -25.10 -28.12 -27.30 -23.53 -22.17 -24.90 -27.97 -28.57 -27.03 -28.67 +4.52 -22.15 -23.22 -22.00 -23.12 -22.59 -25.03 -27.66 -27.31 -23.49 -22.04 -24.71 -27.98 -28.56 -27.01 -28.57 +4.56 -22.25 -23.26 -21.82 -22.94 -22.40 -24.83 -27.24 -27.30 -23.51 -21.93 -24.53 -27.99 -28.47 -26.97 -28.44 +4.60 -22.34 -23.29 -21.66 -22.75 -22.23 -24.58 -26.85 -27.23 -23.62 -21.83 -24.34 -28.00 -28.14 -26.89 -28.31 +4.64 -22.42 -23.23 -21.51 -22.57 -22.07 -24.32 -26.50 -27.02 -23.81 -21.76 -24.15 -28.01 -27.61 -26.82 -28.22 +4.68 -22.51 -23.06 -21.39 -22.41 -21.93 -24.08 -26.18 -26.68 -24.05 -21.70 -23.94 -28.01 -27.09 -26.76 -28.14 +4.72 -22.59 -22.80 -21.28 -22.27 -21.80 -23.85 -25.89 -26.28 -24.30 -21.65 -23.72 -28.01 -26.64 -26.71 -28.06 +4.76 -22.67 -22.53 -21.20 -22.14 -21.68 -23.66 -25.64 -25.87 -24.54 -21.63 -23.50 -28.00 -26.25 -26.66 -27.99 +4.80 -22.74 -22.27 -21.13 -22.03 -21.58 -23.48 -25.46 -25.49 -24.78 -21.65 -23.29 -27.98 -25.91 -26.61 -27.91 +4.84 -22.81 -22.07 -21.08 -21.95 -21.48 -23.33 -25.32 -25.14 -24.99 -21.75 -23.09 -27.96 -25.60 -26.54 -27.84 +4.88 -22.88 -21.96 -21.05 -21.87 -21.39 -23.19 -25.22 -24.82 -25.19 -21.96 -22.93 -27.92 -25.33 -26.45 -27.76 +4.92 -22.95 -21.93 -21.04 -21.81 -21.31 -23.05 -25.13 -24.53 -25.38 -22.28 -22.79 -27.85 -25.09 -26.33 -27.70 +4.96 -23.01 -21.97 -21.06 -21.76 -21.23 -22.93 -25.06 -24.27 -25.55 -22.63 -22.67 -27.65 -24.88 -26.19 -27.63 +5.00 -23.07 -22.05 -21.15 -21.71 -21.16 -22.80 -24.97 -24.04 -25.70 -22.97 -22.58 -27.24 -24.70 -26.03 -27.58 +5.04 -23.13 -22.14 -21.32 -21.66 -21.09 -22.67 -24.88 -23.85 -25.84 -23.28 -22.50 -26.72 -24.54 -25.89 -27.52 +5.08 -23.18 -22.24 -21.56 -21.63 -21.03 -22.55 -24.78 -23.70 -25.96 -23.55 -22.44 -26.20 -24.42 -25.78 -27.47 +5.12 -23.23 -22.34 -21.85 -21.60 -20.97 -22.44 -24.67 -23.58 -26.07 -23.78 -22.39 -25.73 -24.32 -25.68 -27.43 +5.16 -23.27 -22.43 -22.13 -21.60 -20.93 -22.34 -24.56 -23.49 -26.18 -23.96 -22.36 -25.32 -24.25 -25.59 -27.40 +5.20 -23.32 -22.52 -22.40 -21.64 -20.89 -22.25 -24.46 -23.41 -26.30 -24.06 -22.37 -24.97 -24.20 -25.42 -27.36 +5.24 -23.35 -22.61 -22.65 -21.74 -20.85 -22.18 -24.35 -23.34 -26.35 -24.08 -22.46 -24.68 -24.18 -25.09 -27.33 +5.28 -23.39 -22.69 -22.87 -21.94 -20.82 -22.12 -24.25 -23.26 -26.22 -24.01 -22.66 -24.43 -24.17 -24.64 -27.30 +5.32 -23.42 -22.77 -23.07 -22.21 -20.80 -22.06 -24.15 -23.16 -25.91 -23.89 -22.94 -24.23 -24.17 -24.18 -27.26 +5.36 -23.45 -22.85 -23.26 -22.51 -20.80 -22.01 -24.07 -23.07 -25.55 -23.76 -23.24 -24.06 -24.17 -23.76 -27.20 +5.40 -23.47 -22.92 -23.43 -22.79 -20.84 -21.97 -24.00 -22.97 -25.21 -23.65 -23.51 -23.93 -24.14 -23.40 -27.14 +5.44 -23.49 -22.98 -23.58 -23.05 -20.94 -21.93 -23.93 -22.88 -24.91 -23.56 -23.74 -23.84 -24.09 -23.10 -27.05 +5.48 -23.51 -23.05 -23.73 -23.29 -21.14 -21.89 -23.88 -22.79 -24.66 -23.49 -23.91 -23.78 -24.03 -22.86 -26.97 +5.52 -23.53 -23.11 -23.86 -23.49 -21.41 -21.86 -23.84 -22.72 -24.46 -23.43 -24.00 -23.78 -23.98 -22.67 -26.88 +5.56 -23.54 -23.17 -23.98 -23.68 -21.69 -21.84 -23.80 -22.66 -24.30 -23.38 -24.00 -23.89 -23.94 -22.51 -26.78 +5.60 -23.56 -23.22 -24.07 -23.85 -21.96 -21.81 -23.78 -22.62 -24.17 -23.32 -23.94 -24.09 -23.91 -22.39 -26.64 +5.64 -23.57 -23.27 -24.13 -24.00 -22.20 -21.79 -23.76 -22.58 -24.07 -23.28 -23.85 -24.30 -23.87 -22.30 -26.45 +5.68 -23.57 -23.32 -24.14 -24.14 -22.42 -21.79 -23.76 -22.55 -23.99 -23.23 -23.75 -24.47 -23.81 -22.23 -26.19 +5.72 -23.58 -23.36 -24.10 -24.26 -22.61 -21.83 -23.76 -22.53 -23.93 -23.20 -23.65 -24.57 -23.74 -22.17 -25.89 +5.76 -23.58 -23.40 -24.02 -24.36 -22.77 -21.94 -23.78 -22.51 -23.88 -23.19 -23.58 -24.59 -23.72 -22.12 -25.60 +5.80 -23.58 -23.44 -23.91 -24.43 -22.92 -22.14 -23.82 -22.49 -23.86 -23.18 -23.53 -24.54 -23.83 -22.08 -25.33 +5.84 -23.58 -23.47 -23.81 -24.47 -23.06 -22.38 -23.88 -22.47 -23.85 -23.16 -23.50 -24.46 -24.05 -22.05 -25.08 +5.88 -23.58 -23.51 -23.71 -24.46 -23.17 -22.63 -23.99 -22.45 -23.86 -23.11 -23.48 -24.37 -24.29 -22.03 -24.86 +5.92 -23.58 -23.53 -23.63 -24.41 -23.27 -22.86 -24.17 -22.45 -23.89 -23.04 -23.46 -24.29 -24.45 -22.02 -24.66 +5.96 -23.58 -23.56 -23.56 -24.32 -23.33 -23.07 -24.39 -22.48 -23.94 -22.96 -23.44 -24.22 -24.52 -22.01 -24.48 +6.00 -23.57 -23.58 -23.52 -24.23 -23.37 -23.26 -24.61 -22.57 -24.00 -22.88 -23.42 -24.17 -24.51 -22.01 -24.32 +6.04 -23.57 -23.60 -23.49 -24.14 -23.36 -23.42 -24.82 -22.74 -24.05 -22.82 -23.38 -24.15 -24.46 -22.01 -24.17 +6.08 -23.56 -23.62 -23.50 -24.05 -23.33 -23.56 -25.01 -22.95 -24.11 -22.77 -23.35 -24.14 -24.40 -22.02 -24.04 +6.12 -23.55 -23.64 -23.53 -23.98 -23.26 -23.68 -25.18 -23.17 -24.19 -22.74 -23.32 -24.15 -24.33 -22.02 -23.92 +6.16 -23.54 -23.65 -23.58 -23.93 -23.19 -23.79 -25.33 -23.37 -24.31 -22.73 -23.30 -24.17 -24.28 -22.03 -23.82 +6.20 -23.53 -23.66 -23.64 -23.90 -23.11 -23.86 -25.47 -23.56 -24.47 -22.77 -23.29 -24.20 -24.25 -22.05 -23.74 +6.24 -23.52 -23.67 -23.71 -23.89 -23.04 -23.91 -25.59 -23.72 -24.64 -22.87 -23.29 -24.24 -24.24 -22.09 -23.67 +6.28 -23.51 -23.68 -23.79 -23.91 -22.98 -23.94 -25.68 -23.86 -24.81 -23.02 -23.29 -24.28 -24.23 -22.17 -23.63 +6.32 -23.50 -23.68 -23.86 -23.95 -22.93 -23.93 -25.75 -23.98 -24.96 -23.19 -23.29 -24.31 -24.23 -22.29 -23.61 +6.36 -23.49 -23.68 -23.93 -24.01 -22.91 -23.90 -25.78 -24.08 -25.11 -23.36 -23.32 -24.32 -24.22 -22.44 -23.63 +6.40 -23.47 -23.69 -24.00 -24.07 -22.91 -23.86 -25.78 -24.16 -25.23 -23.52 -23.39 -24.32 -24.19 -22.58 -23.72 +6.44 -23.46 -23.69 -24.06 -24.14 -22.94 -23.80 -25.76 -24.22 -25.33 -23.67 -23.50 -24.31 -24.16 -22.69 -23.87 +6.48 -23.45 -23.68 -24.12 -24.21 -22.98 -23.75 -25.71 -24.25 -25.41 -23.79 -23.63 -24.31 -24.14 -22.76 -23.98 +6.52 -23.43 -23.68 -24.18 -24.28 -23.04 -23.70 -25.65 -24.26 -25.47 -23.90 -23.76 -24.35 -24.12 -22.80 -24.04 +6.56 -23.42 -23.68 -24.23 -24.34 -23.10 -23.66 -25.58 -24.24 -25.49 -23.98 -23.89 -24.43 -24.12 -22.81 -24.05 +6.60 -23.40 -23.67 -24.28 -24.41 -23.17 -23.64 -25.52 -24.22 -25.49 -24.05 -24.00 -24.55 -24.14 -22.80 -24.05 +6.64 -23.39 -23.67 -24.32 -24.46 -23.23 -23.63 -25.47 -24.18 -25.46 -24.09 -24.10 -24.68 -24.20 -22.78 -24.04 +6.68 -23.37 -23.66 -24.36 -24.52 -23.30 -23.64 -25.42 -24.14 -25.42 -24.12 -24.19 -24.81 -24.29 -22.74 -24.02 +6.72 -23.36 -23.65 -24.40 -24.57 -23.36 -23.66 -25.39 -24.10 -25.37 -24.13 -24.26 -24.91 -24.41 -22.71 -24.02 +6.76 -23.34 -23.64 -24.44 -24.61 -23.41 -23.70 -25.38 -24.07 -25.31 -24.12 -24.31 -25.00 -24.55 -22.68 -24.03 +6.80 -23.33 -23.64 -24.47 -24.66 -23.47 -23.75 -25.39 -24.05 -25.26 -24.10 -24.34 -25.06 -24.67 -22.65 -24.06 +6.84 -23.31 -23.63 -24.50 -24.70 -23.52 -23.80 -25.41 -24.03 -25.21 -24.07 -24.36 -25.11 -24.79 -22.64 -24.10 +6.88 -23.29 -23.61 -24.53 -24.73 -23.56 -23.86 -25.44 -24.04 -25.17 -24.05 -24.37 -25.14 -24.89 -22.64 -24.15 +6.92 -23.28 -23.60 -24.55 -24.77 -23.61 -23.92 -25.48 -24.05 -25.15 -24.02 -24.36 -25.15 -24.97 -22.65 -24.20 +6.96 -23.26 -23.59 -24.57 -24.80 -23.65 -23.97 -25.53 -24.08 -25.14 -24.00 -24.35 -25.15 -25.04 -22.67 -24.25 +7.00 -23.24 -23.58 -24.59 -24.82 -23.68 -24.02 -25.58 -24.12 -25.14 -23.98 -24.33 -25.13 -25.09 -22.70 -24.29 +7.04 -23.23 -23.57 -24.61 -24.85 -23.72 -24.07 -25.63 -24.16 -25.15 -23.98 -24.30 -25.11 -25.12 -22.74 -24.32 +7.08 -23.21 -23.55 -24.62 -24.87 -23.75 -24.12 -25.68 -24.21 -25.18 -23.98 -24.28 -25.07 -25.14 -22.79 -24.35 +7.12 -23.19 -23.54 -24.63 -24.89 -23.77 -24.16 -25.73 -24.26 -25.22 -24.00 -24.26 -25.04 -25.15 -22.86 -24.39 +7.16 -23.17 -23.52 -24.64 -24.91 -23.80 -24.20 -25.77 -24.30 -25.26 -24.02 -24.25 -25.00 -25.15 -22.94 -24.45 +7.20 -23.16 -23.51 -24.65 -24.92 -23.82 -24.23 -25.81 -24.35 -25.30 -24.06 -24.24 -24.96 -25.13 -23.03 -24.51 +7.24 -23.14 -23.50 -24.66 -24.94 -23.84 -24.27 -25.85 -24.40 -25.34 -24.09 -24.24 -24.93 -25.11 -23.13 -24.58 +7.28 -23.12 -23.48 -24.66 -24.95 -23.86 -24.30 -25.89 -24.44 -25.39 -24.13 -24.25 -24.90 -25.09 -23.21 -24.64 +7.32 -23.10 -23.46 -24.67 -24.96 -23.87 -24.32 -25.92 -24.47 -25.43 -24.18 -24.27 -24.88 -25.07 -23.29 -24.70 +7.36 -23.08 -23.45 -24.67 -24.97 -23.88 -24.35 -25.95 -24.51 -25.47 -24.22 -24.30 -24.87 -25.05 -23.36 -24.75 +7.40 -23.07 -23.43 -24.67 -24.97 -23.90 -24.37 -25.97 -24.54 -25.50 -24.26 -24.33 -24.86 -25.03 -23.42 -24.80 +7.44 -23.05 -23.42 -24.67 -24.98 -23.90 -24.39 -26.00 -24.57 -25.54 -24.29 -24.36 -24.87 -25.01 -23.46 -24.84 +7.48 -23.03 -23.40 -24.67 -24.98 -23.91 -24.41 -26.02 -24.60 -25.57 -24.33 -24.40 -24.88 -25.00 -23.49 -24.87 +7.52 -23.01 -23.38 -24.66 -24.98 -23.92 -24.42 -26.04 -24.62 -25.60 -24.36 -24.43 -24.90 -25.00 -23.52 -24.90 +7.56 -22.99 -23.37 -24.66 -24.98 -23.92 -24.44 -26.05 -24.64 -25.62 -24.39 -24.47 -24.92 -25.00 -23.53 -24.92 +7.60 -22.97 -23.35 -24.65 -24.98 -23.92 -24.45 -26.07 -24.66 -25.65 -24.42 -24.50 -24.95 -25.01 -23.54 -24.93 +7.64 -22.95 -23.33 -24.65 -24.97 -23.93 -24.45 -26.08 -24.68 -25.67 -24.45 -24.53 -24.98 -25.02 -23.54 -24.94 +7.68 -22.94 -23.32 -24.64 -24.97 -23.92 -24.46 -26.09 -24.70 -25.68 -24.47 -24.56 -25.01 -25.04 -23.54 -24.94 +7.72 -22.92 -23.30 -24.63 -24.97 -23.92 -24.47 -26.10 -24.71 -25.70 -24.49 -24.59 -25.03 -25.06 -23.54 -24.94 +7.76 -22.90 -23.28 -24.62 -24.96 -23.92 -24.47 -26.10 -24.72 -25.71 -24.51 -24.61 -25.06 -25.08 -23.53 -24.93 +7.80 -22.88 -23.26 -24.61 -24.95 -23.92 -24.47 -26.11 -24.73 -25.72 -24.52 -24.64 -25.09 -25.10 -23.53 -24.93 +7.84 -22.86 -23.25 -24.60 -24.95 -23.91 -24.47 -26.11 -24.73 -25.73 -24.53 -24.66 -25.11 -25.12 -23.53 -24.92 +7.88 -22.84 -23.23 -24.59 -24.94 -23.91 -24.47 -26.11 -24.74 -25.74 -24.55 -24.67 -25.13 -25.15 -23.52 -24.91 +7.92 -22.82 -23.21 -24.58 -24.93 -23.90 -24.47 -26.12 -24.74 -25.75 -24.56 -24.69 -25.15 -25.17 -23.52 -24.90 +7.96 -22.80 -23.19 -24.57 -24.92 -23.89 -24.47 -26.11 -24.75 -25.75 -24.56 -24.70 -25.17 -25.19 -23.53 -24.89 +8.00 -22.78 -23.17 -24.56 -24.91 -23.88 -24.46 -26.11 -24.75 -25.76 -24.57 -24.71 -25.19 -25.21 -23.53 -24.89 +8.04 -22.76 -23.16 -24.54 -24.90 -23.87 -24.46 -26.11 -24.75 -25.76 -24.57 -24.72 -25.20 -25.22 -23.54 -24.89 +8.08 -22.74 -23.14 -24.53 -24.88 -23.86 -24.45 -26.10 -24.74 -25.76 -24.57 -24.73 -25.21 -25.24 -23.55 -24.89 +8.12 -22.72 -23.12 -24.52 -24.87 -23.85 -24.45 -26.10 -24.74 -25.75 -24.58 -24.73 -25.22 -25.25 -23.56 -24.89 +8.16 -22.70 -23.10 -24.50 -24.86 -23.84 -24.44 -26.09 -24.74 -25.75 -24.58 -24.74 -25.23 -25.27 -23.57 -24.89 diff --git a/docs/cooling/sutherland_dopita_table_6.txt b/docs/cooling/sutherland_dopita_table_6.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..764ec52d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling/sutherland_dopita_table_6.txt @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +## This is a reproduction of Table 6 of Sutherland and Dopita (1993). +## [NOTE: Only columns 1-6 are reproduced in this file. Log(U), Log(tau_cool), and the "general plasma properties" are not included.] +## [Headings included in the printed table:] +## CIE Cooling Curve : Solar Abundances +## Number Densities; Cooling Properties; General Plasma Properties +## Log(T), n_e, n_H, n_t, log(\Lambda_net), log(\Lambda_N) +4.0 0.0023 1.0 1.099 -25.65 -23.06 +4.05 0.0142 1.0 1.099 -24.27 -22.46 +4.1 0.0704 1.0 1.099 -23.28 -22.17 +4.15 0.2534 1.0 1.099 -22.47 -21.92 +4.2 0.5678 1.0 1.099 -21.99 -21.79 +4.25 0.8177 1.0 1.099 -21.84 -21.8 +4.3 0.9324 1.0 1.099 -21.85 -21.86 +4.35 0.978 1.0 1.099 -21.87 -21.9 +4.4 1.004 1.0 1.099 -21.84 -21.88 +4.45 1.035 1.0 1.099 -21.77 -21.82 +4.5 1.067 1.0 1.099 -21.66 -21.73 +4.55 1.086 1.0 1.099 -21.56 -21.63 +4.6 1.094 1.0 1.099 -21.45 -21.53 +4.65 1.098 1.0 1.099 -21.34 -21.42 +4.7 1.1 1.0 1.099 -21.24 -21.32 +4.75 1.102 1.0 1.099 -21.14 -21.22 +4.8 1.11 1.0 1.099 -21.05 -21.14 +4.85 1.128 1.0 1.099 -20.97 -21.07 +4.9 1.154 1.0 1.099 -20.91 -21.01 +4.95 1.176 1.0 1.099 -20.87 -20.98 +5.0 1.188 1.0 1.099 -20.87 -20.99 +5.05 1.195 1.0 1.099 -20.9 -21.02 +5.1 1.198 1.0 1.099 -20.91 -21.03 +5.15 1.199 1.0 1.099 -20.89 -21.01 +5.2 1.2 1.0 1.099 -20.86 -20.98 +5.25 1.201 1.0 1.099 -20.85 -20.97 +5.3 1.201 1.0 1.099 -20.84 -20.96 +5.35 1.201 1.0 1.099 -20.84 -20.96 +5.4 1.202 1.0 1.099 -20.87 -20.99 +5.45 1.203 1.0 1.099 -21.01 -21.13 +5.5 1.203 1.0 1.099 -21.23 -21.35 +5.55 1.204 1.0 1.099 -21.43 -21.55 +5.6 1.204 1.0 1.099 -21.54 -21.66 +5.65 1.204 1.0 1.099 -21.58 -21.71 +5.7 1.204 1.0 1.099 -21.59 -21.71 +5.75 1.204 1.0 1.099 -21.59 -21.71 +5.8 1.204 1.0 1.099 -21.64 -21.76 +5.85 1.205 1.0 1.099 -21.74 -21.86 +5.9 1.205 1.0 1.099 -21.81 -21.93 +5.95 1.205 1.0 1.099 -21.83 -21.95 +6.0 1.205 1.0 1.099 -21.84 -21.96 +6.05 1.205 1.0 1.099 -21.84 -21.96 +6.1 1.206 1.0 1.099 -21.83 -21.96 +6.15 1.206 1.0 1.099 -21.82 -21.95 +6.2 1.206 1.0 1.099 -21.82 -21.94 +6.25 1.206 1.0 1.099 -21.85 -21.97 +6.3 1.207 1.0 1.099 -21.95 -22.07 +6.35 1.207 1.0 1.099 -22.08 -22.2 +6.4 1.207 1.0 1.099 -22.19 -22.31 +6.45 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.27 -22.39 +6.5 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.32 -22.44 +6.55 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.35 -22.48 +6.6 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.38 -22.5 +6.65 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.41 -22.53 +6.7 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.44 -22.56 +6.75 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.46 -22.59 +6.8 1.208 1.0 1.099 -22.48 -22.6 +6.85 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.48 -22.6 +6.9 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.46 -22.59 +6.95 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.45 -22.57 +7.0 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.45 -22.57 +7.05 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.46 -22.59 +7.1 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.49 -22.62 +7.15 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.53 -22.65 +7.2 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.56 -22.68 +7.25 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.58 -22.7 +7.3 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.6 -22.72 +7.35 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.61 -22.73 +7.4 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.61 -22.73 +7.45 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.61 -22.73 +7.5 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.6 -22.73 +7.55 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.6 -22.72 +7.6 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.59 -22.71 +7.65 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.37 -22.7 +7.7 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.36 -22.68 +7.75 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.34 -22.67 +7.8 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.33 -22.65 +7.85 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.51 -22.64 +7.9 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.49 -22.62 +7.95 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.48 -22.6 +8.0 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.46 -22.58 +8.05 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.44 -22.36 +8.1 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.42 -22.34 +8.15 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.4 -22.33 +8.2 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.38 -22.51 +8.25 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.36 -22.49 +8.3 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.34 -22.47 +8.35 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.32 -22.45 +8.4 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.3 -22.43 +8.45 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.28 -22.4 +8.5 1.209 1.0 1.099 -22.26 -22.38 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/cooling_notes.md b/docs/cooling_notes.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..34fb1866 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cooling_notes.md @@ -0,0 +1,116 @@ +--- +title: Cooling function conventions +author: Ben Wibking +date: February 12, 2024 +--- + +# Summary + +Several different conventions exist for the definition of a collisional ionization equilibrium (CIE) cooling curve. They are explained in detail below, with references. + +# Conventions + +## $n^2 \Lambda$ convention + +This convention uses the *total number density* $n$ to define the volumetric cooling rate. The total particle number density is defined as the sum of the number of ions, neutrals, and electrons divided by the volume. + +The total number density $n$ is related to the dimensionless mean molecular weight $\mu$ by: + +$$n = \frac{\rho}{\mu m_H} \, ,$$ {#eq:number_density} + +where $\rho$ is the mass density of the fluid, $m_H$ is the mass of the hydrogen atom, and $\mu$ is the dimensionless mean molecular weight. This may be taken as the definition of $\mu$. + +In this convention, the volumetric cooling rate is given by + +$$S_{cool} = n^2 \Lambda(T) \, ,$$ {#eq:cooling_rate_nsqLambda} + +where $S_{cool}$ is the volumetric cooling source term, $n$ is the total number density and $\Lambda(T)$ is the CIE cooling curve in this convention. + +This convention is used by the PLUTO code (see the [PLUTO User Guide](http://plutocode.ph.unito.it/userguide.pdf), section 9.2, equation 9.5). + +## $n_i n_e \Lambda$ convention + +In this convention, the volumetric cooling rate is given by + +$$S_{cool} = n_i n_e \Lambda(T) \, ,$$ {#eq:cooling_rate_nineLambda} + +where $S_{cool}$ is the volumetric cooling source term, $n_i$ is the number density of ions (*usually* including neutrals by convention, but this difference should be negligible when CIE is valid), $n_e$ is the number density of electrons, and $\Lambda(T)$ is the CIE cooling curve in this convention. + +This convention is adopted by Sutherland and Dopita (1993) in their tabulation of CIE cooling curves (their section 5.2; see also their equations 51-58). + +Sutherland and Dopita additionally comment: *"The normalization factor for the cooling function $\Lambda_N$ is taken as $n_t n_e$ where $n_t$ is the total number density of ions and $n_e$ is the total number density of electrons. This definition is generally valid and independent of composition. It differs from the commonly used factor $n_H n_e$ or even $n_e^2$ commonly used in hydrogen-rich plasmas."* + + +## $n_H n_e \Lambda$ convention + +In this convention, the volumetric cooling rate is given by + +$$S_{cool} = n_H n_e \Lambda(T) \, ,$$ {#eq:cooling_rate_nHneLambda} + +where $S_{cool}$ is the volumetric cooling source term, $n_H$ is the number density of hydrogen *nuclei* (not ions), $n_e$ is the number density of electrons, and $\Lambda(T)$ is the CIE cooling curve in this convention. + +This convention is adopted by Schure et al. (2009) in their definition of $\Lambda_N$. However, this is **not** the same $\Lambda_N$ as used by Sutherland and Dopita (1993)! + +This convention is adopted by Gnat and Sternberg (2007) in their definition of $\Lambda$. + +The following image illustrates a comparison between different cooling curves in this notation: +![nHne cooling](./cooling/cooling_curves_nHneLambda.png) + +## $n_H^2 \Lambda$ convention + +In this convention, the volumetric cooling rate is given by + +$$S_{cool} = n_H^2 \Lambda(T) \, ,$$ {#eq:cooling_rate_nHsqLambda} + +where $S_{cool}$ is the volumetric cooling source term, $n_H$ is the number density of hydrogen *nuclei* (not ions), and $\Lambda(T)$ is the CIE cooling curve in this convention. + +This convention is adopted by Dalgarno and McCray (1972) (their equation 24), and Schure et al. (2009) in their definition of $\Lambda_{hd}$ (their equation 2). + +### AthenaPK implementation + +This is the convention adopted by AthenaPK, except $n_H$ is computed assuming zero metals in the mass budget: + +$$ x_H = 1 - Y \, , $$ + +$$ n_H = X_H \rho / m_H = (1 - Y) \rho / m_H \, .$$ + +The difference in neglecting metals in the mass budget in computing $n_H$ is only a $\sim 2$ percent effect on $n_H$ (since metals are 2 percent by mass for solar metallicity) and a $\sim 4$ percent effect on the source term. + +The Schure table in the GitHub repository uses the $n_H n_e$ convention, rather than the $n_H^2$ convention. This causes an error in the cooling rate of $n_e / n_H$, or about 20 percent for temperatures above $10^{5.5}$ K. + +Above $\sim 10^4$ K, there is a percent-level error in the mean molecular weight due to neglecting the metal contribution to the electron fraction. *Users should be aware that at low absolute electron fraction, metals contribute a substantial proportion of the electrons, so this approximation is no longer valid below $\sim 10^4$ K.* The temperature is computed as: + +$$ T = \left( \frac{\rho}{\mu m_H} \right)^{-1} \left( \frac{P}{k_B} \right) \, ,$$ +where the dimensionless mean molecular weight $\mu$ is computed assuming a zero metallicity gas: + +$$ \mu = \left( \frac{3}{4} Y + 2(1 - Y) \right)^{-1} = \left( 2 - \frac{5}{4} Y \right)^{-1} \, ,$$ + +where $Y$ is the Helium mass fraction. + +For a more precise calculation of $\mu$ assuming a scaled-solar composition of metals, we have: + +$$ \mu = \left( 1 - x_e \right) \left( X + \frac{Y}{4} + \frac{Z}{\bar A} \right)^{-1} \, , $$ + +where $\bar A$ is the mass-weighted mean atomic weight of metals: + +$$ \bar A = 16 \, .$$ + +Additionally, for full ionization for all species, we have: + +$$ x_e = \frac{X + 2 Y (m_H/m_{He}) + (\bar A/2) Z (m_H/m_{\bar Z})}{2 X + 3 Y (m_H/m_{He}) + (1 + \bar A/2) +Z (m_H/m_{\bar Z})} \approx \frac{X + Y/2 + Z/2}{2 X + 3 Y/4 + (1/{\bar A} + 1/2) Z}$$ + + +For $Y = 0.24$ and $Z = 0.02$, the mean molecular weight for complete ionization is $\mu \approx 0.60$ (if $Z = 0$, then this yields $\mu \approx 0.59$). + +## $n_e^2 \Lambda$ convention + +In this convention, the volumetric cooling rate is given by + +$$S_{cool} = n_e^2 \Lambda(T) \, ,$$ {#eq:cooling_rate_nHsqLambda} + +where $S_{cool}$ is the volumetric cooling source term, $n_e$ is the number density of electrons, and $\Lambda(T)$ is the CIE cooling curve in this convention. + +For the case of a hydrogen-only fully-ionized plasma *only*, this is equivalent to the $n_H^2 \Lambda$ convention, since each hydrogen atom contributes exactly one electron and there are no other sources of electrons. + +I am not aware of any common tables that use this convention. However, it is noted as one of the possible conventions by Sutherland and Dopita (1993). diff --git a/docs/input.md b/docs/input.md index 11dae8c5..c51aa8e7 100644 --- a/docs/input.md +++ b/docs/input.md @@ -216,15 +216,17 @@ than any other timestep constraint (e.g., the hyperbolic one). ### Cooling Tabular cooling (e.g., for optically thin cooling) is enabled through the `cooling` block in the input file. +The tabulated table itself is a text file containing (apart from comments) only two columns (two floating +point numbers per line with the first one being the log10 temperature and the second one the +log10 cooling rate scaled to a source function with $S_{cool} = n_H^2 \Lambda(T)$). + A possible block might look like: ``` -enable_cooling = tabular # To disable, set to `none` -table_filename = schure.cooling # Path to the cooling table (in a text file) -log_temp_col = 0 # Column in the file that contains the log10 temperatures -log_lambda_col = 1 # Column in the file that contains the cooling rates -lambda_units_cgs = 1 # Conversion factor of the cooling rate relative to CGS units +enable_cooling = tabular # To disable, set to `none` +table_filename = schure.cooling_1.0Z # Path to the cooling table (in a text file) +lambda_units_cgs = 1 # Conversion factor of the cooling rate relative to CGS units integrator = townsend # Other possible options are `rk12` and `rk45` for error bound subcycling #max_iter = 100 # Max number of iteration for subcycling. Unsued for Townsend integrator @@ -237,3 +239,7 @@ d_log_temp_tol = 1e-8 # Tolerance in cooling table between subseque - Cooling is turned off once the temperature reaches the lower end of the cooling table. Within the cooling function, gas does not cool past the cooling table. - If the global temperature floor `` is higher than the lower end of the cooling table, then the global temperature floor takes precedence. - The pressure floor if present is not considered in the cooling function, only the temperature floor `` + +Finally, a more comprehensive descriptions of various conventions used for cooling +functions (and the chosen implementation in AthenaPK) can be found in [Cooling Notes](cooling_notes.md) +and a notebook comparing various cooling tables (and their conversion) in [cooling/cooling.ipynb](cooling/cooling.ipynb). diff --git a/inputs/cloud.in b/inputs/cloud.in index 05f71e25..002febd0 100644 --- a/inputs/cloud.in +++ b/inputs/cloud.in @@ -62,9 +62,7 @@ He_mass_fraction = 0.24 enable_cooling = none # turn on with "tabular" -table_filename = schure.cooling -log_temp_col = 0 -log_lambda_col = 1 +table_filename = schure.cooling_1.0Z lambda_units_cgs = 1 integrator = rk12 diff --git a/inputs/cluster/cluster.in b/inputs/cluster/cluster.in index e3192524..62d15ac1 100644 --- a/inputs/cluster/cluster.in +++ b/inputs/cluster/cluster.in @@ -86,9 +86,7 @@ code_time_cgs = 3.15576e+16 # 1 Gyr in s enable_cooling=tabular -table_filename=schure.cooling -log_temp_col=0 -log_lambda_col=1 +table_filename=schure.cooling_1.0Z lambda_units_cgs=1.0 integrator=rk45 diff --git a/inputs/cluster/cooling.in b/inputs/cluster/cooling.in index 63f8dd20..0aeb783b 100644 --- a/inputs/cluster/cooling.in +++ b/inputs/cluster/cooling.in @@ -70,9 +70,7 @@ code_time_cgs = 3.15576e+16 # 1 Gyr in s enable_cooling = tabular -table_filename = schure.cooling -log_temp_col = 0 -log_lambda_col = 1 +table_filename = schure.cooling_1.0Z lambda_units_cgs = 1 #erg cm^3/s in cgs, as used in schure.cooling integrator = rk12 diff --git a/inputs/cluster/my_cluster.input b/inputs/cluster/my_cluster.input index 3823f7b8..bbf8e1e4 100644 --- a/inputs/cluster/my_cluster.input +++ b/inputs/cluster/my_cluster.input @@ -90,7 +90,7 @@ code_time_cgs = 3.15576e+16 enable_cooling = tabular -table_filename = schure.cooling +table_filename = updated_schure.cooling log_temp_col = 0 # Column to read temperature in cooling table log_lambda_col = 1 # Column to read lambda in cooling table lambda_units_cgs = 1 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling deleted file mode 100644 index bd1233a2..00000000 --- a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling +++ /dev/null @@ -1,208 +0,0 @@ -# Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas -# Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg -# Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies -# Converted (i.e., log10) from http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt -# -# cooling rates log10(Lambda) in (erg cm^3/s) for various metallicities -# logT Z=1e-3 Z=1e-2 Z=1e-1 Z=1 Z=2 -4.0000 -23.3279 -23.3028 -23.1090 -22.2526 -21.4237 -4.0199 -23.1180 -23.1085 -23.0200 -22.5100 -22.1574 -4.0402 -22.9101 -22.9031 -22.8570 -22.5436 -22.3224 -4.0603 -22.7055 -22.7033 -22.6757 -22.4672 -22.3072 -4.0803 -22.5114 -22.5100 -22.4921 -22.3458 -22.2233 -4.1004 -22.3316 -22.3307 -22.3179 -22.2104 -22.1146 -4.1206 -22.1688 -22.1675 -22.1593 -22.0762 -22.0000 -4.1408 -22.0269 -22.0264 -22.0186 -21.9547 -21.8928 -4.1608 -21.9136 -21.9136 -21.9066 -21.8508 -21.7959 -4.1810 -21.8327 -21.8327 -21.8268 -21.7773 -21.7258 -4.2011 -21.7825 -21.7825 -21.7773 -21.7305 -21.6799 -4.2212 -21.7670 -21.7670 -21.7620 -21.7122 -21.6635 -4.2413 -21.7721 -21.7721 -21.7670 -21.7167 -21.6676 -4.2613 -21.7986 -21.7986 -21.7932 -21.7399 -21.6861 -4.2815 -21.8356 -21.8327 -21.8268 -21.7696 -21.7144 -4.3015 -21.8794 -21.8794 -21.8729 -21.8097 -21.7471 -4.3216 -21.9281 -21.9281 -21.9172 -21.8447 -21.7773 -4.3416 -21.9788 -21.9788 -21.9666 -21.8827 -21.8041 -4.3617 -22.0269 -22.0259 -22.0146 -21.9172 -21.8268 -4.3818 -22.0737 -22.0726 -22.0595 -21.9431 -21.8447 -4.4021 -22.1192 -22.1175 -22.1018 -21.9666 -21.8570 -4.4221 -22.1624 -22.1605 -22.1421 -21.9872 -21.8601 -4.4422 -22.2041 -22.2013 -22.1785 -22.0000 -21.8601 -4.4622 -22.2434 -22.2403 -22.2125 -22.0066 -21.8539 -4.4824 -22.2815 -22.2782 -22.2464 -22.0101 -21.8447 -4.5026 -22.3215 -22.3170 -22.2782 -22.0101 -21.8297 -4.5226 -22.3615 -22.3565 -22.3089 -22.0052 -21.8125 -4.5427 -22.4001 -22.3936 -22.3391 -21.9957 -21.7905 -4.5628 -22.4377 -22.4306 -22.3645 -21.9830 -21.7645 -4.5830 -22.4750 -22.4660 -22.3883 -21.9666 -21.7352 -4.6030 -22.5100 -22.5003 -22.4067 -21.9431 -21.7055 -4.6231 -22.5406 -22.5287 -22.4214 -21.9172 -21.6716 -4.6433 -22.5654 -22.5513 -22.4295 -21.8894 -21.6383 -4.6633 -22.5834 -22.5670 -22.4295 -21.8601 -21.6021 -4.6834 -22.5901 -22.5719 -22.4214 -21.8268 -21.5638 -4.7035 -22.5850 -22.5654 -22.4034 -21.7905 -21.5258 -4.7236 -22.5622 -22.5421 -22.3757 -21.7520 -21.4855 -4.7437 -22.5229 -22.5017 -22.3354 -21.7122 -21.4461 -4.7638 -22.4672 -22.4473 -22.2857 -21.6716 -21.4056 -4.7839 -22.3990 -22.3799 -22.2277 -21.6289 -21.3655 -4.8040 -22.3242 -22.3072 -22.1656 -21.5867 -21.3261 -4.8241 -22.2495 -22.2343 -22.1029 -21.5452 -21.2882 -4.8442 -22.1831 -22.1688 -22.0458 -21.5058 -21.2526 -4.8643 -22.1290 -22.1152 -22.0000 -21.4724 -21.2204 -4.8844 -22.0910 -22.0778 -21.9626 -21.4425 -21.1925 -4.9045 -22.0711 -22.0580 -21.9431 -21.4202 -21.1694 -4.9246 -22.0680 -22.0535 -21.9355 -21.4012 -21.1494 -4.9447 -22.0783 -22.0635 -21.9355 -21.3872 -21.1319 -4.9648 -22.0996 -22.0830 -21.9469 -21.3768 -21.1175 -4.9849 -22.1296 -22.1113 -21.9626 -21.3686 -21.1062 -5.0052 -22.1637 -22.1433 -21.9788 -21.3645 -21.0980 -5.0253 -22.2013 -22.1791 -22.0026 -21.3645 -21.0953 -5.0453 -22.2411 -22.2168 -22.0273 -21.3696 -21.0975 -5.0652 -22.2823 -22.2557 -22.0526 -21.3768 -21.1035 -5.0853 -22.3224 -22.2941 -22.0783 -21.3862 -21.1101 -5.1055 -22.3635 -22.3316 -22.1029 -21.3947 -21.1158 -5.1255 -22.4034 -22.3686 -22.1238 -21.3990 -21.1180 -5.1458 -22.4425 -22.4045 -22.1421 -21.3990 -21.1163 -5.1658 -22.4802 -22.4389 -22.1574 -21.3958 -21.1113 -5.1858 -22.5171 -22.4711 -22.1694 -21.3893 -21.1035 -5.2060 -22.5528 -22.5017 -22.1791 -21.3820 -21.0942 -5.2261 -22.5884 -22.5317 -22.1878 -21.3747 -21.0857 -5.2463 -22.6216 -22.5607 -22.1945 -21.3675 -21.0773 -5.2662 -22.6536 -22.5867 -22.2013 -21.3615 -21.0706 -5.2865 -22.6861 -22.6126 -22.2069 -21.3556 -21.0635 -5.3066 -22.7167 -22.6364 -22.2111 -21.3497 -21.0560 -5.3265 -22.7447 -22.6596 -22.2140 -21.3429 -21.0487 -5.3467 -22.7747 -22.6819 -22.2175 -21.3372 -21.0419 -5.3668 -22.8013 -22.7033 -22.2218 -21.3335 -21.0381 -5.3869 -22.8268 -22.7235 -22.2291 -21.3354 -21.0395 -5.4071 -22.8539 -22.7471 -22.2418 -21.3449 -21.0482 -5.4272 -22.8794 -22.7696 -22.2628 -21.3635 -21.0675 -5.4472 -22.9031 -22.7959 -22.2924 -21.3947 -21.0985 -5.4673 -22.9547 -22.8447 -22.3354 -21.4353 -21.1397 -5.4874 -22.9788 -22.8729 -22.3757 -21.4802 -21.1838 -5.5076 -23.0022 -22.9031 -22.4134 -21.5229 -21.2269 -5.5276 -23.0241 -22.9245 -22.4461 -21.5591 -21.2628 -5.5478 -23.0453 -22.9469 -22.4724 -21.5867 -21.2907 -5.5678 -23.0650 -22.9666 -22.4908 -21.6055 -21.3089 -5.5879 -23.0835 -22.9872 -22.5058 -21.6180 -21.3215 -5.6081 -23.1013 -23.0009 -22.5143 -21.6234 -21.3279 -5.6282 -23.1175 -23.0146 -22.5214 -21.6271 -21.3316 -5.6483 -23.1331 -23.0273 -22.5272 -21.6308 -21.3335 -5.6684 -23.1487 -23.0395 -22.5331 -21.6326 -21.3372 -5.6884 -23.1630 -23.0521 -22.5391 -21.6383 -21.3410 -5.7085 -23.1772 -23.0645 -22.5482 -21.6459 -21.3487 -5.7287 -23.1911 -23.0783 -22.5607 -21.6576 -21.3615 -5.7487 -23.2048 -23.0937 -22.5800 -21.6778 -21.3820 -5.7689 -23.2182 -23.1096 -22.6021 -21.7033 -21.4067 -5.7889 -23.2306 -23.1255 -22.6271 -21.7305 -21.4342 -5.8090 -23.2426 -23.1415 -22.6536 -21.7620 -21.4660 -5.8292 -23.2526 -23.1549 -22.6737 -21.7852 -21.4895 -5.8492 -23.2620 -23.1669 -22.6946 -21.8097 -21.5129 -5.8693 -23.2708 -23.1765 -22.7055 -21.8210 -21.5258 -5.8895 -23.2790 -23.1844 -22.7144 -21.8327 -21.5361 -5.9096 -23.2857 -23.1918 -22.7212 -21.8356 -21.5406 -5.9296 -23.2924 -23.1972 -22.7258 -21.8416 -21.5452 -5.9497 -23.2976 -23.2020 -22.7282 -21.8416 -21.5467 -5.9698 -23.3028 -23.2062 -22.7305 -21.8447 -21.5482 -5.9899 -23.3072 -23.2111 -22.7375 -21.8508 -21.5544 -6.0000 -23.3098 -23.2132 -22.7375 -21.8508 -21.5560 -6.0199 -23.3125 -23.2168 -22.7447 -21.8601 -21.5622 -6.0398 -23.3143 -23.2204 -22.7520 -21.8665 -21.5719 -6.0599 -23.3161 -23.2240 -22.7595 -21.8761 -21.5817 -6.0799 -23.3170 -23.2262 -22.7645 -21.8861 -21.5901 -6.1000 -23.3179 -23.2284 -22.7696 -21.8928 -21.5969 -6.1199 -23.3179 -23.2306 -22.7799 -21.9031 -21.6073 -6.1399 -23.3179 -23.2321 -22.7852 -21.9101 -21.6162 -6.1599 -23.3179 -23.2328 -22.7905 -21.9208 -21.6253 -6.1801 -23.3170 -23.2343 -22.7986 -21.9318 -21.6364 -6.2000 -23.3152 -23.2358 -22.8097 -21.9469 -21.6517 -6.2201 -23.3143 -23.2381 -22.8210 -21.9626 -21.6696 -6.2400 -23.3125 -23.2403 -22.8356 -21.9830 -21.6904 -6.2601 -23.3107 -23.2426 -22.8508 -22.0088 -21.7167 -6.2801 -23.3089 -23.2441 -22.8697 -22.0348 -21.7423 -6.2999 -23.3063 -23.2464 -22.8861 -22.0635 -21.7721 -6.3199 -23.3116 -23.2549 -22.9101 -22.0942 -21.8041 -6.3400 -23.3080 -23.2557 -22.9281 -22.1232 -21.8327 -6.3600 -23.3045 -23.2565 -22.9431 -22.1518 -21.8633 -6.3800 -23.3010 -23.2557 -22.9586 -22.1798 -21.8928 -6.4000 -23.2967 -23.2549 -22.9706 -22.2069 -21.9208 -6.4200 -23.2933 -23.2541 -22.9872 -22.2351 -21.9508 -6.4400 -23.2890 -23.2526 -23.0000 -22.2612 -21.9788 -6.4600 -23.2840 -23.2510 -23.0110 -22.2882 -22.0070 -6.4800 -23.2798 -23.2487 -23.0218 -22.3143 -22.0348 -6.5000 -23.2749 -23.2464 -23.0320 -22.3391 -22.0615 -6.5200 -23.2684 -23.2418 -23.0395 -22.3625 -22.0862 -6.5400 -23.2620 -23.2373 -23.0462 -22.3840 -22.1101 -6.5600 -23.2557 -23.2321 -23.0501 -22.4023 -22.1296 -6.5800 -23.2487 -23.2269 -23.0535 -22.4191 -22.1481 -6.6000 -23.2418 -23.2211 -23.0560 -22.4330 -22.1643 -6.6200 -23.2351 -23.2154 -23.0570 -22.4461 -22.1798 -6.6400 -23.2277 -23.2090 -23.0575 -22.4584 -22.1931 -6.6600 -23.2211 -23.2034 -23.0570 -22.4685 -22.2048 -6.6800 -23.2140 -23.1965 -23.0560 -22.4789 -22.2168 -6.7000 -23.2062 -23.1904 -23.0550 -22.4868 -22.2269 -6.7200 -23.1993 -23.1838 -23.0531 -22.4962 -22.2373 -6.7400 -23.1918 -23.1772 -23.0511 -22.5031 -22.2457 -6.7600 -23.1851 -23.1707 -23.0487 -22.5100 -22.2541 -6.7800 -23.1778 -23.1637 -23.0458 -22.5143 -22.2604 -6.8000 -23.1701 -23.1568 -23.0419 -22.5186 -22.2660 -6.8200 -23.1630 -23.1500 -23.0386 -22.5214 -22.2708 -6.8400 -23.1555 -23.1433 -23.0343 -22.5243 -22.2749 -6.8600 -23.1481 -23.1361 -23.0292 -22.5243 -22.2749 -6.8800 -23.1409 -23.1290 -23.0246 -22.5258 -22.2782 -6.9000 -23.1337 -23.1221 -23.0195 -22.5258 -22.2790 -6.9200 -23.1261 -23.1146 -23.0150 -22.5272 -22.2815 -6.9400 -23.1192 -23.1079 -23.0101 -22.5287 -22.2840 -6.9600 -23.1118 -23.1007 -23.0057 -22.5302 -22.2874 -6.9800 -23.1046 -23.0937 -23.0009 -22.5317 -22.2899 -7.0000 -23.0969 -23.0867 -22.9957 -22.5346 -22.2941 -7.0199 -23.0883 -23.0783 -22.9914 -22.5391 -22.3010 -7.0398 -23.0794 -23.0696 -22.9872 -22.5436 -22.3080 -7.0599 -23.0701 -23.0615 -22.9830 -22.5498 -22.3170 -7.0799 -23.0615 -23.0531 -22.9788 -22.5607 -22.3316 -7.1000 -23.0521 -23.0443 -22.9747 -22.5702 -22.3449 -7.1199 -23.0434 -23.0357 -22.9706 -22.5817 -22.3605 -7.1399 -23.0357 -23.0292 -22.9666 -22.5952 -22.3788 -7.1599 -23.0273 -23.0209 -22.9626 -22.6091 -22.3979 -7.1801 -23.0182 -23.0123 -22.9586 -22.6253 -22.4191 -7.2000 -23.0088 -23.0039 -22.9547 -22.6383 -22.4389 -7.2201 -23.0004 -22.9957 -22.9508 -22.6536 -22.4597 -7.2400 -22.9914 -22.9872 -22.9469 -22.6676 -22.4815 -7.2601 -22.9830 -22.9788 -22.9431 -22.6799 -22.5003 -7.2801 -22.9747 -22.9706 -22.9355 -22.6904 -22.5186 -7.2999 -22.9666 -22.9626 -22.9318 -22.6990 -22.5346 -7.3199 -22.9547 -22.9547 -22.9245 -22.7077 -22.5482 -7.3400 -22.9469 -22.9431 -22.9172 -22.7144 -22.5607 -7.3600 -22.9393 -22.9355 -22.9136 -22.7190 -22.5702 -7.3800 -22.9318 -22.9281 -22.9066 -22.7212 -22.5784 -7.4000 -22.9208 -22.9208 -22.8996 -22.7235 -22.5850 -7.4200 -22.9136 -22.9101 -22.8928 -22.7235 -22.5901 -7.4400 -22.9066 -22.9031 -22.8827 -22.7235 -22.5935 -7.4600 -22.8962 -22.8962 -22.8761 -22.7212 -22.5952 -7.4800 -22.8894 -22.8861 -22.8697 -22.7190 -22.5969 -7.5000 -22.8827 -22.8794 -22.8633 -22.7167 -22.5952 -7.5200 -22.8729 -22.8697 -22.8539 -22.7122 -22.5918 -7.5400 -22.8633 -22.8601 -22.8447 -22.7055 -22.5884 -7.5600 -22.8539 -22.8508 -22.8356 -22.6990 -22.5850 -7.5800 -22.8447 -22.8416 -22.8268 -22.6925 -22.5800 -7.6000 -22.8356 -22.8327 -22.8182 -22.6861 -22.5735 -7.6200 -22.8268 -22.8239 -22.8097 -22.6799 -22.5686 -7.6400 -22.8182 -22.8182 -22.8013 -22.6737 -22.5622 -7.6600 -22.8097 -22.8097 -22.7932 -22.6655 -22.5544 -7.6800 -22.8013 -22.8013 -22.7852 -22.6576 -22.5482 -7.7000 -22.7932 -22.7932 -22.7773 -22.6498 -22.5406 -7.7200 -22.7852 -22.7852 -22.7696 -22.6440 -22.5361 -7.7400 -22.7799 -22.7773 -22.7620 -22.6364 -22.5287 -7.7600 -22.7721 -22.7696 -22.7570 -22.6308 -22.5229 -7.7800 -22.7645 -22.7645 -22.7496 -22.6234 -22.5157 -7.8000 -22.7595 -22.7570 -22.7423 -22.6180 -22.5114 -7.8200 -22.7520 -22.7496 -22.7375 -22.6126 -22.5058 -7.8400 -22.7471 -22.7447 -22.7305 -22.6073 -22.5017 -7.8600 -22.7399 -22.7399 -22.7258 -22.6021 -22.4962 -7.8800 -22.7352 -22.7328 -22.7190 -22.5986 -22.4935 -7.9000 -22.7305 -22.7282 -22.7144 -22.5935 -22.4895 -7.9200 -22.7258 -22.7235 -22.7100 -22.5918 -22.4881 -7.9400 -22.7190 -22.7190 -22.7055 -22.5884 -22.4868 -7.9600 -22.7167 -22.7144 -22.7011 -22.5867 -22.4855 -7.9800 -22.7122 -22.7100 -22.6990 -22.5850 -22.4868 -8.0000 -22.7077 -22.7077 -22.6946 -22.5834 -22.4855 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.001Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.001Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..13fb61d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.001Z @@ -0,0 +1,209 @@ +# Adapted from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt +# Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas +# Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg +# Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1. +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=0.001 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.00 -23.3279 +4.02 -23.1180 +4.04 -22.9101 +4.06 -22.7055 +4.08 -22.5114 +4.10 -22.3316 +4.12 -22.1688 +4.14 -22.0269 +4.16 -21.9136 +4.18 -21.8327 +4.20 -21.7825 +4.22 -21.7670 +4.24 -21.7721 +4.26 -21.7986 +4.28 -21.8356 +4.30 -21.8794 +4.32 -21.9281 +4.34 -21.9788 +4.36 -22.0269 +4.38 -22.0737 +4.40 -22.1192 +4.42 -22.1624 +4.44 -22.2041 +4.46 -22.2434 +4.48 -22.2815 +4.50 -22.3215 +4.52 -22.3615 +4.54 -22.4001 +4.56 -22.4377 +4.58 -22.4750 +4.60 -22.5100 +4.62 -22.5406 +4.64 -22.5654 +4.66 -22.5834 +4.68 -22.5901 +4.70 -22.5850 +4.72 -22.5622 +4.74 -22.5229 +4.76 -22.4672 +4.78 -22.3990 +4.80 -22.3242 +4.82 -22.2495 +4.84 -22.1831 +4.86 -22.1290 +4.88 -22.0910 +4.90 -22.0711 +4.92 -22.0680 +4.94 -22.0783 +4.96 -22.0996 +4.98 -22.1296 +5.01 -22.1637 +5.03 -22.2013 +5.05 -22.2411 +5.07 -22.2823 +5.09 -22.3224 +5.11 -22.3635 +5.13 -22.4034 +5.15 -22.4425 +5.17 -22.4802 +5.19 -22.5171 +5.21 -22.5528 +5.23 -22.5884 +5.25 -22.6216 +5.27 -22.6536 +5.29 -22.6861 +5.31 -22.7167 +5.33 -22.7447 +5.35 -22.7747 +5.37 -22.8013 +5.39 -22.8268 +5.41 -22.8539 +5.43 -22.8794 +5.45 -22.9031 +5.47 -22.9547 +5.49 -22.9788 +5.51 -23.0022 +5.53 -23.0241 +5.55 -23.0453 +5.57 -23.0650 +5.59 -23.0835 +5.61 -23.1013 +5.63 -23.1175 +5.65 -23.1331 +5.67 -23.1487 +5.69 -23.1630 +5.71 -23.1772 +5.73 -23.1911 +5.75 -23.2048 +5.77 -23.2182 +5.79 -23.2306 +5.81 -23.2426 +5.83 -23.2526 +5.85 -23.2620 +5.87 -23.2708 +5.89 -23.2790 +5.91 -23.2857 +5.93 -23.2924 +5.95 -23.2976 +5.97 -23.3028 +5.99 -23.3072 +6.00 -23.3098 +6.02 -23.3125 +6.04 -23.3143 +6.06 -23.3161 +6.08 -23.3170 +6.10 -23.3179 +6.12 -23.3179 +6.14 -23.3179 +6.16 -23.3179 +6.18 -23.3170 +6.20 -23.3152 +6.22 -23.3143 +6.24 -23.3125 +6.26 -23.3107 +6.28 -23.3089 +6.30 -23.3063 +6.32 -23.3116 +6.34 -23.3080 +6.36 -23.3045 +6.38 -23.3010 +6.40 -23.2967 +6.42 -23.2933 +6.44 -23.2890 +6.46 -23.2840 +6.48 -23.2798 +6.50 -23.2749 +6.52 -23.2684 +6.54 -23.2620 +6.56 -23.2557 +6.58 -23.2487 +6.60 -23.2418 +6.62 -23.2351 +6.64 -23.2277 +6.66 -23.2211 +6.68 -23.2140 +6.70 -23.2062 +6.72 -23.1993 +6.74 -23.1918 +6.76 -23.1851 +6.78 -23.1778 +6.80 -23.1701 +6.82 -23.1630 +6.84 -23.1555 +6.86 -23.1481 +6.88 -23.1409 +6.90 -23.1337 +6.92 -23.1261 +6.94 -23.1192 +6.96 -23.1118 +6.98 -23.1046 +7.00 -23.0969 +7.02 -23.0883 +7.04 -23.0794 +7.06 -23.0701 +7.08 -23.0615 +7.10 -23.0521 +7.12 -23.0434 +7.14 -23.0357 +7.16 -23.0273 +7.18 -23.0182 +7.20 -23.0088 +7.22 -23.0004 +7.24 -22.9914 +7.26 -22.9830 +7.28 -22.9747 +7.30 -22.9666 +7.32 -22.9547 +7.34 -22.9469 +7.36 -22.9393 +7.38 -22.9318 +7.40 -22.9208 +7.42 -22.9136 +7.44 -22.9066 +7.46 -22.8962 +7.48 -22.8894 +7.50 -22.8827 +7.52 -22.8729 +7.54 -22.8633 +7.56 -22.8539 +7.58 -22.8447 +7.60 -22.8356 +7.62 -22.8268 +7.64 -22.8182 +7.66 -22.8097 +7.68 -22.8013 +7.70 -22.7932 +7.72 -22.7852 +7.74 -22.7799 +7.76 -22.7721 +7.78 -22.7645 +7.80 -22.7595 +7.82 -22.7520 +7.84 -22.7471 +7.86 -22.7399 +7.88 -22.7352 +7.90 -22.7305 +7.92 -22.7258 +7.94 -22.7190 +7.96 -22.7167 +7.98 -22.7122 +8.00 -22.7077 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.01Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.01Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ca4cf0c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.01Z @@ -0,0 +1,209 @@ +# Adapted from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt +# Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas +# Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg +# Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1. +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=0.01 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.00 -23.3028 +4.02 -23.1085 +4.04 -22.9031 +4.06 -22.7033 +4.08 -22.5100 +4.10 -22.3307 +4.12 -22.1675 +4.14 -22.0264 +4.16 -21.9136 +4.18 -21.8327 +4.20 -21.7825 +4.22 -21.7670 +4.24 -21.7721 +4.26 -21.7986 +4.28 -21.8327 +4.30 -21.8794 +4.32 -21.9281 +4.34 -21.9788 +4.36 -22.0259 +4.38 -22.0726 +4.40 -22.1175 +4.42 -22.1605 +4.44 -22.2013 +4.46 -22.2403 +4.48 -22.2782 +4.50 -22.3170 +4.52 -22.3565 +4.54 -22.3936 +4.56 -22.4306 +4.58 -22.4660 +4.60 -22.5003 +4.62 -22.5287 +4.64 -22.5513 +4.66 -22.5670 +4.68 -22.5719 +4.70 -22.5654 +4.72 -22.5421 +4.74 -22.5017 +4.76 -22.4473 +4.78 -22.3799 +4.80 -22.3072 +4.82 -22.2343 +4.84 -22.1688 +4.86 -22.1152 +4.88 -22.0778 +4.90 -22.0580 +4.92 -22.0535 +4.94 -22.0635 +4.96 -22.0830 +4.98 -22.1113 +5.01 -22.1433 +5.03 -22.1791 +5.05 -22.2168 +5.07 -22.2557 +5.09 -22.2941 +5.11 -22.3316 +5.13 -22.3686 +5.15 -22.4045 +5.17 -22.4389 +5.19 -22.4711 +5.21 -22.5017 +5.23 -22.5317 +5.25 -22.5607 +5.27 -22.5867 +5.29 -22.6126 +5.31 -22.6364 +5.33 -22.6596 +5.35 -22.6819 +5.37 -22.7033 +5.39 -22.7235 +5.41 -22.7471 +5.43 -22.7696 +5.45 -22.7959 +5.47 -22.8447 +5.49 -22.8729 +5.51 -22.9031 +5.53 -22.9245 +5.55 -22.9469 +5.57 -22.9666 +5.59 -22.9872 +5.61 -23.0009 +5.63 -23.0146 +5.65 -23.0273 +5.67 -23.0395 +5.69 -23.0521 +5.71 -23.0645 +5.73 -23.0783 +5.75 -23.0937 +5.77 -23.1096 +5.79 -23.1255 +5.81 -23.1415 +5.83 -23.1549 +5.85 -23.1669 +5.87 -23.1765 +5.89 -23.1844 +5.91 -23.1918 +5.93 -23.1972 +5.95 -23.2020 +5.97 -23.2062 +5.99 -23.2111 +6.00 -23.2132 +6.02 -23.2168 +6.04 -23.2204 +6.06 -23.2240 +6.08 -23.2262 +6.10 -23.2284 +6.12 -23.2306 +6.14 -23.2321 +6.16 -23.2328 +6.18 -23.2343 +6.20 -23.2358 +6.22 -23.2381 +6.24 -23.2403 +6.26 -23.2426 +6.28 -23.2441 +6.30 -23.2464 +6.32 -23.2549 +6.34 -23.2557 +6.36 -23.2565 +6.38 -23.2557 +6.40 -23.2549 +6.42 -23.2541 +6.44 -23.2526 +6.46 -23.2510 +6.48 -23.2487 +6.50 -23.2464 +6.52 -23.2418 +6.54 -23.2373 +6.56 -23.2321 +6.58 -23.2269 +6.60 -23.2211 +6.62 -23.2154 +6.64 -23.2090 +6.66 -23.2034 +6.68 -23.1965 +6.70 -23.1904 +6.72 -23.1838 +6.74 -23.1772 +6.76 -23.1707 +6.78 -23.1637 +6.80 -23.1568 +6.82 -23.1500 +6.84 -23.1433 +6.86 -23.1361 +6.88 -23.1290 +6.90 -23.1221 +6.92 -23.1146 +6.94 -23.1079 +6.96 -23.1007 +6.98 -23.0937 +7.00 -23.0867 +7.02 -23.0783 +7.04 -23.0696 +7.06 -23.0615 +7.08 -23.0531 +7.10 -23.0443 +7.12 -23.0357 +7.14 -23.0292 +7.16 -23.0209 +7.18 -23.0123 +7.20 -23.0039 +7.22 -22.9957 +7.24 -22.9872 +7.26 -22.9788 +7.28 -22.9706 +7.30 -22.9626 +7.32 -22.9547 +7.34 -22.9431 +7.36 -22.9355 +7.38 -22.9281 +7.40 -22.9208 +7.42 -22.9101 +7.44 -22.9031 +7.46 -22.8962 +7.48 -22.8861 +7.50 -22.8794 +7.52 -22.8697 +7.54 -22.8601 +7.56 -22.8508 +7.58 -22.8416 +7.60 -22.8327 +7.62 -22.8239 +7.64 -22.8182 +7.66 -22.8097 +7.68 -22.8013 +7.70 -22.7932 +7.72 -22.7852 +7.74 -22.7773 +7.76 -22.7696 +7.78 -22.7645 +7.80 -22.7570 +7.82 -22.7496 +7.84 -22.7447 +7.86 -22.7399 +7.88 -22.7328 +7.90 -22.7282 +7.92 -22.7235 +7.94 -22.7190 +7.96 -22.7144 +7.98 -22.7100 +8.00 -22.7077 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.1Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.1Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..53f1ceb3 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_0.1Z @@ -0,0 +1,209 @@ +# Adapted from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt +# Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas +# Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg +# Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1. +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=0.1 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.00 -23.1090 +4.02 -23.0200 +4.04 -22.8570 +4.06 -22.6757 +4.08 -22.4921 +4.10 -22.3179 +4.12 -22.1593 +4.14 -22.0186 +4.16 -21.9066 +4.18 -21.8268 +4.20 -21.7773 +4.22 -21.7620 +4.24 -21.7670 +4.26 -21.7932 +4.28 -21.8268 +4.30 -21.8729 +4.32 -21.9172 +4.34 -21.9666 +4.36 -22.0146 +4.38 -22.0595 +4.40 -22.1018 +4.42 -22.1421 +4.44 -22.1785 +4.46 -22.2125 +4.48 -22.2464 +4.50 -22.2782 +4.52 -22.3089 +4.54 -22.3391 +4.56 -22.3645 +4.58 -22.3883 +4.60 -22.4067 +4.62 -22.4214 +4.64 -22.4295 +4.66 -22.4295 +4.68 -22.4214 +4.70 -22.4034 +4.72 -22.3757 +4.74 -22.3354 +4.76 -22.2857 +4.78 -22.2277 +4.80 -22.1656 +4.82 -22.1029 +4.84 -22.0458 +4.86 -22.0000 +4.88 -21.9626 +4.90 -21.9431 +4.92 -21.9355 +4.94 -21.9355 +4.96 -21.9469 +4.98 -21.9626 +5.01 -21.9788 +5.03 -22.0026 +5.05 -22.0273 +5.07 -22.0526 +5.09 -22.0783 +5.11 -22.1029 +5.13 -22.1238 +5.15 -22.1421 +5.17 -22.1574 +5.19 -22.1694 +5.21 -22.1791 +5.23 -22.1878 +5.25 -22.1945 +5.27 -22.2013 +5.29 -22.2069 +5.31 -22.2111 +5.33 -22.2140 +5.35 -22.2175 +5.37 -22.2218 +5.39 -22.2291 +5.41 -22.2418 +5.43 -22.2628 +5.45 -22.2924 +5.47 -22.3354 +5.49 -22.3757 +5.51 -22.4134 +5.53 -22.4461 +5.55 -22.4724 +5.57 -22.4908 +5.59 -22.5058 +5.61 -22.5143 +5.63 -22.5214 +5.65 -22.5272 +5.67 -22.5331 +5.69 -22.5391 +5.71 -22.5482 +5.73 -22.5607 +5.75 -22.5800 +5.77 -22.6021 +5.79 -22.6271 +5.81 -22.6536 +5.83 -22.6737 +5.85 -22.6946 +5.87 -22.7055 +5.89 -22.7144 +5.91 -22.7212 +5.93 -22.7258 +5.95 -22.7282 +5.97 -22.7305 +5.99 -22.7375 +6.00 -22.7375 +6.02 -22.7447 +6.04 -22.7520 +6.06 -22.7595 +6.08 -22.7645 +6.10 -22.7696 +6.12 -22.7799 +6.14 -22.7852 +6.16 -22.7905 +6.18 -22.7986 +6.20 -22.8097 +6.22 -22.8210 +6.24 -22.8356 +6.26 -22.8508 +6.28 -22.8697 +6.30 -22.8861 +6.32 -22.9101 +6.34 -22.9281 +6.36 -22.9431 +6.38 -22.9586 +6.40 -22.9706 +6.42 -22.9872 +6.44 -23.0000 +6.46 -23.0110 +6.48 -23.0218 +6.50 -23.0320 +6.52 -23.0395 +6.54 -23.0462 +6.56 -23.0501 +6.58 -23.0535 +6.60 -23.0560 +6.62 -23.0570 +6.64 -23.0575 +6.66 -23.0570 +6.68 -23.0560 +6.70 -23.0550 +6.72 -23.0531 +6.74 -23.0511 +6.76 -23.0487 +6.78 -23.0458 +6.80 -23.0419 +6.82 -23.0386 +6.84 -23.0343 +6.86 -23.0292 +6.88 -23.0246 +6.90 -23.0195 +6.92 -23.0150 +6.94 -23.0101 +6.96 -23.0057 +6.98 -23.0009 +7.00 -22.9957 +7.02 -22.9914 +7.04 -22.9872 +7.06 -22.9830 +7.08 -22.9788 +7.10 -22.9747 +7.12 -22.9706 +7.14 -22.9666 +7.16 -22.9626 +7.18 -22.9586 +7.20 -22.9547 +7.22 -22.9508 +7.24 -22.9469 +7.26 -22.9431 +7.28 -22.9355 +7.30 -22.9318 +7.32 -22.9245 +7.34 -22.9172 +7.36 -22.9136 +7.38 -22.9066 +7.40 -22.8996 +7.42 -22.8928 +7.44 -22.8827 +7.46 -22.8761 +7.48 -22.8697 +7.50 -22.8633 +7.52 -22.8539 +7.54 -22.8447 +7.56 -22.8356 +7.58 -22.8268 +7.60 -22.8182 +7.62 -22.8097 +7.64 -22.8013 +7.66 -22.7932 +7.68 -22.7852 +7.70 -22.7773 +7.72 -22.7696 +7.74 -22.7620 +7.76 -22.7570 +7.78 -22.7496 +7.80 -22.7423 +7.82 -22.7375 +7.84 -22.7305 +7.86 -22.7258 +7.88 -22.7190 +7.90 -22.7144 +7.92 -22.7100 +7.94 -22.7055 +7.96 -22.7011 +7.98 -22.6990 +8.00 -22.6946 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_1Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_1Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..9fdcaf94 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_1Z @@ -0,0 +1,209 @@ +# Adapted from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt +# Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas +# Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg +# Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1. +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=1 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.00 -22.2526 +4.02 -22.5100 +4.04 -22.5436 +4.06 -22.4672 +4.08 -22.3458 +4.10 -22.2104 +4.12 -22.0762 +4.14 -21.9547 +4.16 -21.8508 +4.18 -21.7773 +4.20 -21.7305 +4.22 -21.7122 +4.24 -21.7167 +4.26 -21.7399 +4.28 -21.7696 +4.30 -21.8097 +4.32 -21.8447 +4.34 -21.8827 +4.36 -21.9172 +4.38 -21.9431 +4.40 -21.9666 +4.42 -21.9872 +4.44 -22.0000 +4.46 -22.0066 +4.48 -22.0101 +4.50 -22.0101 +4.52 -22.0052 +4.54 -21.9957 +4.56 -21.9830 +4.58 -21.9666 +4.60 -21.9431 +4.62 -21.9172 +4.64 -21.8894 +4.66 -21.8601 +4.68 -21.8268 +4.70 -21.7905 +4.72 -21.7520 +4.74 -21.7122 +4.76 -21.6716 +4.78 -21.6289 +4.80 -21.5867 +4.82 -21.5452 +4.84 -21.5058 +4.86 -21.4724 +4.88 -21.4425 +4.90 -21.4202 +4.92 -21.4012 +4.94 -21.3872 +4.96 -21.3768 +4.98 -21.3686 +5.01 -21.3645 +5.03 -21.3645 +5.05 -21.3696 +5.07 -21.3768 +5.09 -21.3862 +5.11 -21.3947 +5.13 -21.3990 +5.15 -21.3990 +5.17 -21.3958 +5.19 -21.3893 +5.21 -21.3820 +5.23 -21.3747 +5.25 -21.3675 +5.27 -21.3615 +5.29 -21.3556 +5.31 -21.3497 +5.33 -21.3429 +5.35 -21.3372 +5.37 -21.3335 +5.39 -21.3354 +5.41 -21.3449 +5.43 -21.3635 +5.45 -21.3947 +5.47 -21.4353 +5.49 -21.4802 +5.51 -21.5229 +5.53 -21.5591 +5.55 -21.5867 +5.57 -21.6055 +5.59 -21.6180 +5.61 -21.6234 +5.63 -21.6271 +5.65 -21.6308 +5.67 -21.6326 +5.69 -21.6383 +5.71 -21.6459 +5.73 -21.6576 +5.75 -21.6778 +5.77 -21.7033 +5.79 -21.7305 +5.81 -21.7620 +5.83 -21.7852 +5.85 -21.8097 +5.87 -21.8210 +5.89 -21.8327 +5.91 -21.8356 +5.93 -21.8416 +5.95 -21.8416 +5.97 -21.8447 +5.99 -21.8508 +6.00 -21.8508 +6.02 -21.8601 +6.04 -21.8665 +6.06 -21.8761 +6.08 -21.8861 +6.10 -21.8928 +6.12 -21.9031 +6.14 -21.9101 +6.16 -21.9208 +6.18 -21.9318 +6.20 -21.9469 +6.22 -21.9626 +6.24 -21.9830 +6.26 -22.0088 +6.28 -22.0348 +6.30 -22.0635 +6.32 -22.0942 +6.34 -22.1232 +6.36 -22.1518 +6.38 -22.1798 +6.40 -22.2069 +6.42 -22.2351 +6.44 -22.2612 +6.46 -22.2882 +6.48 -22.3143 +6.50 -22.3391 +6.52 -22.3625 +6.54 -22.3840 +6.56 -22.4023 +6.58 -22.4191 +6.60 -22.4330 +6.62 -22.4461 +6.64 -22.4584 +6.66 -22.4685 +6.68 -22.4789 +6.70 -22.4868 +6.72 -22.4962 +6.74 -22.5031 +6.76 -22.5100 +6.78 -22.5143 +6.80 -22.5186 +6.82 -22.5214 +6.84 -22.5243 +6.86 -22.5243 +6.88 -22.5258 +6.90 -22.5258 +6.92 -22.5272 +6.94 -22.5287 +6.96 -22.5302 +6.98 -22.5317 +7.00 -22.5346 +7.02 -22.5391 +7.04 -22.5436 +7.06 -22.5498 +7.08 -22.5607 +7.10 -22.5702 +7.12 -22.5817 +7.14 -22.5952 +7.16 -22.6091 +7.18 -22.6253 +7.20 -22.6383 +7.22 -22.6536 +7.24 -22.6676 +7.26 -22.6799 +7.28 -22.6904 +7.30 -22.6990 +7.32 -22.7077 +7.34 -22.7144 +7.36 -22.7190 +7.38 -22.7212 +7.40 -22.7235 +7.42 -22.7235 +7.44 -22.7235 +7.46 -22.7212 +7.48 -22.7190 +7.50 -22.7167 +7.52 -22.7122 +7.54 -22.7055 +7.56 -22.6990 +7.58 -22.6925 +7.60 -22.6861 +7.62 -22.6799 +7.64 -22.6737 +7.66 -22.6655 +7.68 -22.6576 +7.70 -22.6498 +7.72 -22.6440 +7.74 -22.6364 +7.76 -22.6308 +7.78 -22.6234 +7.80 -22.6180 +7.82 -22.6126 +7.84 -22.6073 +7.86 -22.6021 +7.88 -22.5986 +7.90 -22.5935 +7.92 -22.5918 +7.94 -22.5884 +7.96 -22.5867 +7.98 -22.5850 +8.00 -22.5834 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_2Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_2Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..87995a09 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/gnat-sternberg.cooling_2Z @@ -0,0 +1,209 @@ +# Adapted from: http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/~orlyg/cooling/CIEcool/tab13.txt +# Title: Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas +# Authors: Orly Gnat and Amiel Sternberg +# Table: CIE Cooling Efficiencies +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# Our assumed Z=1 solar abundances are listed in Table 1. +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=2 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.00 -21.4237 +4.02 -22.1574 +4.04 -22.3224 +4.06 -22.3072 +4.08 -22.2233 +4.10 -22.1146 +4.12 -22.0000 +4.14 -21.8928 +4.16 -21.7959 +4.18 -21.7258 +4.20 -21.6799 +4.22 -21.6635 +4.24 -21.6676 +4.26 -21.6861 +4.28 -21.7144 +4.30 -21.7471 +4.32 -21.7773 +4.34 -21.8041 +4.36 -21.8268 +4.38 -21.8447 +4.40 -21.8570 +4.42 -21.8601 +4.44 -21.8601 +4.46 -21.8539 +4.48 -21.8447 +4.50 -21.8297 +4.52 -21.8125 +4.54 -21.7905 +4.56 -21.7645 +4.58 -21.7352 +4.60 -21.7055 +4.62 -21.6716 +4.64 -21.6383 +4.66 -21.6021 +4.68 -21.5638 +4.70 -21.5258 +4.72 -21.4855 +4.74 -21.4461 +4.76 -21.4056 +4.78 -21.3655 +4.80 -21.3261 +4.82 -21.2882 +4.84 -21.2526 +4.86 -21.2204 +4.88 -21.1925 +4.90 -21.1694 +4.92 -21.1494 +4.94 -21.1319 +4.96 -21.1175 +4.98 -21.1062 +5.01 -21.0980 +5.03 -21.0953 +5.05 -21.0975 +5.07 -21.1035 +5.09 -21.1101 +5.11 -21.1158 +5.13 -21.1180 +5.15 -21.1163 +5.17 -21.1113 +5.19 -21.1035 +5.21 -21.0942 +5.23 -21.0857 +5.25 -21.0773 +5.27 -21.0706 +5.29 -21.0635 +5.31 -21.0560 +5.33 -21.0487 +5.35 -21.0419 +5.37 -21.0381 +5.39 -21.0395 +5.41 -21.0482 +5.43 -21.0675 +5.45 -21.0985 +5.47 -21.1397 +5.49 -21.1838 +5.51 -21.2269 +5.53 -21.2628 +5.55 -21.2907 +5.57 -21.3089 +5.59 -21.3215 +5.61 -21.3279 +5.63 -21.3316 +5.65 -21.3335 +5.67 -21.3372 +5.69 -21.3410 +5.71 -21.3487 +5.73 -21.3615 +5.75 -21.3820 +5.77 -21.4067 +5.79 -21.4342 +5.81 -21.4660 +5.83 -21.4895 +5.85 -21.5129 +5.87 -21.5258 +5.89 -21.5361 +5.91 -21.5406 +5.93 -21.5452 +5.95 -21.5467 +5.97 -21.5482 +5.99 -21.5544 +6.00 -21.5560 +6.02 -21.5622 +6.04 -21.5719 +6.06 -21.5817 +6.08 -21.5901 +6.10 -21.5969 +6.12 -21.6073 +6.14 -21.6162 +6.16 -21.6253 +6.18 -21.6364 +6.20 -21.6517 +6.22 -21.6696 +6.24 -21.6904 +6.26 -21.7167 +6.28 -21.7423 +6.30 -21.7721 +6.32 -21.8041 +6.34 -21.8327 +6.36 -21.8633 +6.38 -21.8928 +6.40 -21.9208 +6.42 -21.9508 +6.44 -21.9788 +6.46 -22.0070 +6.48 -22.0348 +6.50 -22.0615 +6.52 -22.0862 +6.54 -22.1101 +6.56 -22.1296 +6.58 -22.1481 +6.60 -22.1643 +6.62 -22.1798 +6.64 -22.1931 +6.66 -22.2048 +6.68 -22.2168 +6.70 -22.2269 +6.72 -22.2373 +6.74 -22.2457 +6.76 -22.2541 +6.78 -22.2604 +6.80 -22.2660 +6.82 -22.2708 +6.84 -22.2749 +6.86 -22.2749 +6.88 -22.2782 +6.90 -22.2790 +6.92 -22.2815 +6.94 -22.2840 +6.96 -22.2874 +6.98 -22.2899 +7.00 -22.2941 +7.02 -22.3010 +7.04 -22.3080 +7.06 -22.3170 +7.08 -22.3316 +7.10 -22.3449 +7.12 -22.3605 +7.14 -22.3788 +7.16 -22.3979 +7.18 -22.4191 +7.20 -22.4389 +7.22 -22.4597 +7.24 -22.4815 +7.26 -22.5003 +7.28 -22.5186 +7.30 -22.5346 +7.32 -22.5482 +7.34 -22.5607 +7.36 -22.5702 +7.38 -22.5784 +7.40 -22.5850 +7.42 -22.5901 +7.44 -22.5935 +7.46 -22.5952 +7.48 -22.5969 +7.50 -22.5952 +7.52 -22.5918 +7.54 -22.5884 +7.56 -22.5850 +7.58 -22.5800 +7.60 -22.5735 +7.62 -22.5686 +7.64 -22.5622 +7.66 -22.5544 +7.68 -22.5482 +7.70 -22.5406 +7.72 -22.5361 +7.74 -22.5287 +7.76 -22.5229 +7.78 -22.5157 +7.80 -22.5114 +7.82 -22.5058 +7.84 -22.5017 +7.86 -22.4962 +7.88 -22.4935 +7.90 -22.4895 +7.92 -22.4881 +7.94 -22.4868 +7.96 -22.4855 +7.98 -22.4868 +8.00 -22.4855 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling index e5c054f8..2237d75c 100644 --- a/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling @@ -1,105 +1,5 @@ -# Cooling table for solar metallicity, 1/2 solar metallicity -# (from Chris Loken, computed with Sarazin & White's analytic expression) -# temperature if log(K), cooling rate/ne^3 (erg cm^3/s) -# This is the new cooling table based on http://arxiv.org/pdf/0909.5204v2 -# logT solar 1/2 solar - 4.20000 -21.3361 -21.3381 - 4.24000 -21.3623 -21.3661 - 4.28000 -21.4525 -21.4612 - 4.32000 -21.5498 -21.5694 - 4.36000 -21.6238 -21.6648 - 4.40000 -21.6623 -21.7381 - 4.44000 -21.6497 -21.7711 - 4.48000 -21.5969 -21.7669 - 4.52000 -21.5159 -21.7263 - 4.56000 -21.4141 -21.6560 - 4.60000 -21.3034 -21.5662 - 4.64000 -21.1928 -21.4688 - 4.68000 -21.0938 -21.3785 - 4.72000 -20.9973 -21.2874 - 4.76000 -20.9196 -21.2130 - 4.80000 -20.8532 -21.1486 - 4.84000 -20.8050 -21.1018 - 4.88000 -20.7735 -21.0712 - 4.92000 -20.7536 -21.0519 - 4.96000 -20.7428 -21.0415 - 5.00000 -20.7578 -21.0567 - 5.04000 -20.7825 -21.0815 - 5.08000 -20.8021 -21.1013 - 5.12000 -20.7965 -21.0960 - 5.16000 -20.7859 -21.0855 - 5.20000 -20.7703 -21.0701 - 5.24000 -20.7561 -21.0560 - 5.28000 -20.7514 -21.0515 - 5.32000 -20.7483 -21.0484 - 5.36000 -20.7553 -21.0554 - 5.40000 -20.7929 -21.0930 - 5.44000 -20.8794 -21.1793 - 5.48000 -21.0405 -21.3401 - 5.52000 -21.2276 -21.5265 - 5.56000 -21.3727 -21.6707 - 5.60000 -21.4552 -21.7528 - 5.64000 -21.4913 -21.7888 - 5.68000 -21.5107 -21.8080 - 5.72000 -21.5354 -21.8325 - 5.76000 -21.5837 -21.8803 - 5.80000 -21.6534 -21.9493 - 5.84000 -21.7090 -22.0042 - 5.88000 -21.7409 -22.0357 - 5.92000 -21.7592 -22.0537 - 5.96000 -21.7695 -22.0638 - 6.00000 -21.7877 -22.0817 - 6.04000 -21.8087 -22.1023 - 6.08000 -21.8306 -22.1236 - 6.12000 -21.8386 -22.1312 - 6.16000 -21.8493 -22.1416 - 6.20000 -21.8690 -22.1607 - 6.24000 -21.9062 -22.1968 - 6.28000 -21.9708 -22.2595 - 6.32000 -22.0543 -22.3400 - 6.36000 -22.1497 -22.4313 - 6.40000 -22.2354 -22.5118 - 6.44000 -22.3090 -22.5804 - 6.48000 -22.3616 -22.6286 - 6.52000 -22.4015 -22.6636 - 6.56000 -22.4254 -22.6846 - 6.60000 -22.4390 -22.6950 - 6.64000 -22.4443 -22.6987 - 6.68000 -22.4375 -22.6905 - 6.72000 -22.4323 -22.6848 - 6.76000 -22.4230 -22.6744 - 6.80000 -22.4147 -22.6659 - 6.84000 -22.4131 -22.6623 - 6.88000 -22.4162 -22.6627 - 6.92000 -22.4265 -22.6706 - 6.96000 -22.4402 -22.6800 - 7.00000 -22.4580 -22.6927 - 7.04000 -22.4830 -22.7125 - 7.08000 -22.5087 -22.7310 - 7.12000 -22.5429 -22.7557 - 7.16000 -22.5776 -22.7798 - 7.20000 -22.6155 -22.8075 - 7.24000 -22.6490 -22.8285 - 7.28000 -22.6689 -22.8384 - 7.32000 -22.6842 -22.8441 - 7.36000 -22.6952 -22.8463 - 7.40000 -22.7039 -22.8495 - 7.44000 -22.7033 -22.8429 - 7.48000 -22.6988 -22.8336 - 7.52000 -22.6925 -22.8228 - 7.56000 -22.6843 -22.8108 - 7.60000 -22.6731 -22.7967 - 7.64000 -22.6606 -22.7816 - 7.68000 -22.6540 -22.7738 - 7.72000 -22.6402 -22.7579 - 7.76000 -22.6245 -22.7408 - 7.80000 -22.6099 -22.7243 - 7.84000 -22.5967 -22.7087 - 7.88000 -22.5805 -22.6911 - 7.92000 -22.5646 -22.6738 - 7.96000 -22.5496 -22.6570 - 8.00000 -22.5332 -22.6393 - 8.04000 -22.5199 -22.6236 - 8.08000 -22.5040 -22.6062 - 8.12000 -22.4881 -22.5888 - 8.16000 -22.4718 -22.5711 +# The original cooling curve in this file was from unknown origin/using unknown conventions +# and has thus been removed. +# This file is kept empty to make runs crash loud that assume/use this table. +# The updated_schure.cooling table contains Lambda for 1, 0.5 and 0.3 solar +# metallicity calculated with the notebook in docs/cooling/cooling.ipynb diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_0.3Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_0.3Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..a3e8cfc6 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_0.3Z @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +# Cooling rates generated from Schure 2009 (doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912495) +# containing temperatures in the first column (in log10 K) and collisional ionisation +# equilibrium (CIE) cooling rates (in log10 erg cm^3/s). +# Cooling rates are in the convention Lambda_hd from eq. 1, +# where the proton ratio n_e/n_H is taken from table 2. +# Lambda_N is computed from eq. 3. The cooling rate Lambda_N(X_i,T) from eq. 3 is contained +# in table 4. n_i/n_i(solar) is taken to be 1.0 for all elements for Z=1 while for Z=0.5 +# and Z=0.3 n_i/n_i(solar) is set to 1 for H and He and set to 0.5 and 0.3 respectively for +# all other elements. Made by Forrest Glines (forrestglines@gmail.com) +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=0.3 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.20 -21.6114 +4.24 -21.4833 +4.28 -21.5129 +4.32 -21.5974 +4.36 -21.6878 +4.40 -21.7659 +4.44 -21.8092 +4.48 -21.8230 +4.52 -21.8059 +4.56 -21.7621 +4.60 -21.6941 +4.64 -21.6111 +4.68 -21.5286 +4.72 -21.4387 +4.76 -21.3589 +4.80 -21.2816 +4.84 -21.2168 +4.88 -21.1700 +4.92 -21.1423 +4.96 -21.1331 +5.00 -21.1525 +5.04 -21.1820 +5.08 -21.2077 +5.12 -21.2093 +5.16 -21.2043 +5.20 -21.1937 +5.24 -21.1832 +5.28 -21.1811 +5.32 -21.1799 +5.36 -21.1883 +5.40 -21.2263 +5.44 -21.3118 +5.48 -21.4700 +5.52 -21.6521 +5.56 -21.7926 +5.60 -21.8728 +5.64 -21.9090 +5.68 -21.9290 +5.72 -21.9539 +5.76 -22.0008 +5.80 -22.0678 +5.84 -22.1209 +5.88 -22.1521 +5.92 -22.1698 +5.96 -22.1804 +6.00 -22.1977 +6.04 -22.2178 +6.08 -22.2383 +6.12 -22.2459 +6.16 -22.2557 +6.20 -22.2736 +6.24 -22.3075 +6.28 -22.3657 +6.32 -22.4391 +6.36 -22.5207 +6.40 -22.5909 +6.44 -22.6490 +6.48 -22.6878 +6.52 -22.7148 +6.56 -22.7308 +6.60 -22.7361 +6.64 -22.7379 +6.68 -22.7283 +6.72 -22.7216 +6.76 -22.7102 +6.80 -22.7023 +6.84 -22.6962 +6.88 -22.6921 +6.92 -22.6959 +6.96 -22.6994 +7.00 -22.7050 +7.04 -22.7170 +7.08 -22.7249 +7.12 -22.7378 +7.16 -22.7480 +7.20 -22.7629 +7.24 -22.7710 +7.28 -22.7697 +7.32 -22.7655 +7.36 -22.7605 +7.40 -22.7565 +7.44 -22.7461 +7.48 -22.7323 +7.52 -22.7176 +7.56 -22.7039 +7.60 -22.6873 +7.64 -22.6700 +7.68 -22.6613 +7.72 -22.6436 +7.76 -22.6251 +7.80 -22.6071 +7.84 -22.5914 +7.88 -22.5727 +7.92 -22.5542 +7.96 -22.5360 +8.00 -22.5172 +8.04 -22.5014 +8.08 -22.4828 +8.12 -22.4642 +8.16 -22.4455 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_0.5Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_0.5Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8f23fbce --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_0.5Z @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +# Cooling rates generated from Schure 2009 (doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912495) +# containing temperatures in the first column (in log10 K) and collisional ionisation +# equilibrium (CIE) cooling rates (in log10 erg cm^3/s). +# Cooling rates are in the convention Lambda_hd from eq. 1, +# where the proton ratio n_e/n_H is taken from table 2. +# Lambda_N is computed from eq. 3. The cooling rate Lambda_N(X_i,T) from eq. 3 is contained +# in table 4. n_i/n_i(solar) is taken to be 1.0 for all elements for Z=1 while for Z=0.5 +# and Z=0.3 n_i/n_i(solar) is set to 1 for H and He and set to 0.5 and 0.3 respectively for +# all other elements. Made by Forrest Glines (forrestglines@gmail.com) +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=0.5 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.20 -21.6106 +4.24 -21.4817 +4.28 -21.5094 +4.32 -21.5894 +4.36 -21.6708 +4.40 -21.7330 +4.44 -21.7528 +4.48 -21.7361 +4.52 -21.6873 +4.56 -21.6136 +4.60 -21.5229 +4.64 -21.4248 +4.68 -21.3330 +4.72 -21.2392 +4.76 -21.1599 +4.80 -21.0871 +4.84 -21.0286 +4.88 -20.9858 +4.92 -20.9582 +4.96 -20.9451 +5.00 -20.9602 +5.04 -20.9861 +5.08 -21.0079 +5.12 -21.0052 +5.16 -20.9968 +5.20 -20.9834 +5.24 -20.9707 +5.28 -20.9670 +5.32 -20.9647 +5.36 -20.9722 +5.40 -21.0099 +5.44 -21.0958 +5.48 -21.2556 +5.52 -21.4404 +5.56 -21.5834 +5.60 -21.6649 +5.64 -21.7010 +5.68 -21.7207 +5.72 -21.7454 +5.76 -21.7931 +5.80 -21.8615 +5.84 -21.9160 +5.88 -21.9476 +5.92 -21.9656 +5.96 -21.9760 +6.00 -21.9938 +6.04 -22.0144 +6.08 -22.0355 +6.12 -22.0433 +6.16 -22.0536 +6.20 -22.0725 +6.24 -22.1082 +6.28 -22.1698 +6.32 -22.2486 +6.36 -22.3375 +6.40 -22.4159 +6.44 -22.4820 +6.48 -22.5278 +6.52 -22.5612 +6.56 -22.5811 +6.60 -22.5905 +6.64 -22.5940 +6.68 -22.5857 +6.72 -22.5797 +6.76 -22.5694 +6.80 -22.5612 +6.84 -22.5573 +6.88 -22.5566 +6.92 -22.5635 +6.96 -22.5718 +7.00 -22.5831 +7.04 -22.6010 +7.08 -22.6169 +7.12 -22.6391 +7.16 -22.6596 +7.20 -22.6840 +7.24 -22.7021 +7.28 -22.7090 +7.32 -22.7121 +7.36 -22.7129 +7.40 -22.7135 +7.44 -22.7065 +7.48 -22.6959 +7.52 -22.6840 +7.56 -22.6722 +7.60 -22.6574 +7.64 -22.6418 +7.68 -22.6337 +7.72 -22.6173 +7.76 -22.5998 +7.80 -22.5828 +7.84 -22.5679 +7.88 -22.5500 +7.92 -22.5324 +7.96 -22.5152 +8.00 -22.4972 +8.04 -22.4822 +8.08 -22.4644 +8.12 -22.4467 +8.16 -22.4287 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_1.0Z b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_1.0Z new file mode 100644 index 00000000..93aac5e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/inputs/cooling_tables/schure.cooling_1.0Z @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +# Cooling rates generated from Schure 2009 (doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912495) +# containing temperatures in the first column (in log10 K) and collisional ionisation +# equilibrium (CIE) cooling rates (in log10 erg cm^3/s). +# Cooling rates are in the convention Lambda_hd from eq. 1, +# where the proton ratio n_e/n_H is taken from table 2. +# Lambda_N is computed from eq. 3. The cooling rate Lambda_N(X_i,T) from eq. 3 is contained +# in table 4. n_i/n_i(solar) is taken to be 1.0 for all elements for Z=1 while for Z=0.5 +# and Z=0.3 n_i/n_i(solar) is set to 1 for H and He and set to 0.5 and 0.3 respectively for +# all other elements. Made by Forrest Glines (forrestglines@gmail.com) +# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +# log10 T [K] Z=1.0 log10 Lambda_N [erg cm^3/s] +4.20 -21.6087 +4.24 -21.4779 +4.28 -21.5009 +4.32 -21.5702 +4.36 -21.6311 +4.40 -21.6603 +4.44 -21.6373 +4.48 -21.5738 +4.52 -21.4838 +4.56 -21.3771 +4.60 -21.2642 +4.64 -21.1525 +4.68 -21.0529 +4.72 -20.9557 +4.76 -20.8769 +4.80 -20.8078 +4.84 -20.7546 +4.88 -20.7154 +4.92 -20.6877 +4.96 -20.6713 +5.00 -20.6828 +5.04 -20.7056 +5.08 -20.7242 +5.12 -20.7180 +5.16 -20.7069 +5.20 -20.6912 +5.24 -20.6768 +5.28 -20.6720 +5.32 -20.6687 +5.36 -20.6755 +5.40 -20.7130 +5.44 -20.7993 +5.48 -20.9603 +5.52 -21.1472 +5.56 -21.2921 +5.60 -21.3746 +5.64 -21.4107 +5.68 -21.4301 +5.72 -21.4547 +5.76 -21.5029 +5.80 -21.5726 +5.84 -21.6281 +5.88 -21.6600 +5.92 -21.6782 +5.96 -21.6885 +6.00 -21.7067 +6.04 -21.7277 +6.08 -21.7494 +6.12 -21.7574 +6.16 -21.7680 +6.20 -21.7877 +6.24 -21.8248 +6.28 -21.8893 +6.32 -21.9727 +6.36 -22.0680 +6.40 -22.1536 +6.44 -22.2272 +6.48 -22.2797 +6.52 -22.3195 +6.56 -22.3434 +6.60 -22.3570 +6.64 -22.3622 +6.68 -22.3553 +6.72 -22.3501 +6.76 -22.3409 +6.80 -22.3324 +6.84 -22.3309 +6.88 -22.3340 +6.92 -22.3443 +6.96 -22.3580 +7.00 -22.3758 +7.04 -22.4007 +7.08 -22.4264 +7.12 -22.4606 +7.16 -22.4953 +7.20 -22.5331 +7.24 -22.5666 +7.28 -22.5865 +7.32 -22.6018 +7.36 -22.6128 +7.40 -22.6215 +7.44 -22.6209 +7.48 -22.6164 +7.52 -22.6101 +7.56 -22.6019 +7.60 -22.5907 +7.64 -22.5782 +7.68 -22.5715 +7.72 -22.5577 +7.76 -22.5421 +7.80 -22.5275 +7.84 -22.5143 +7.88 -22.4980 +7.92 -22.4822 +7.96 -22.4671 +8.00 -22.4508 +8.04 -22.4375 +8.08 -22.4215 +8.12 -22.4056 +8.16 -22.3893 diff --git a/inputs/cooling_tables/sutherland_dopita.cooling b/inputs/cooling_tables/sutherland_dopita.cooling deleted file mode 100644 index 5e329103..00000000 --- a/inputs/cooling_tables/sutherland_dopita.cooling +++ /dev/null @@ -1,782 +0,0 @@ -# Cooling table for solar metallicity, 1/3 solar metallicity -# (adapted from PLUTO code by Deovrat Prasad) -# temperature log(K), cooling rate/ne^3 (erg cm^3/s) -# This is the cooling table based on Sutherland & Dopita (1993), ApJ, 88, 253 -# logT 1/3 solar 1 solar -3.0064233e+00 -2.4478679e+01 -2.4024876e+01 -3.0154017e+00 -2.4475474e+01 -2.4022199e+01 -3.0244036e+00 -2.4472293e+01 -2.4019538e+01 -3.0333835e+00 -2.4469109e+01 -2.4016884e+01 -3.0424180e+00 -2.4465936e+01 -2.4014241e+01 -3.0513841e+00 -2.4462760e+01 -2.4011606e+01 -3.0603956e+00 -2.4459595e+01 -2.4008978e+01 -3.0694091e+00 -2.4456416e+01 -2.4006361e+01 -3.0783843e+00 -2.4453248e+01 -2.4003747e+01 -3.0873909e+00 -2.4450078e+01 -2.4001139e+01 -3.0963885e+00 -2.4446918e+01 -2.3998526e+01 -3.1053739e+00 -2.4443746e+01 -2.3995937e+01 -3.1143774e+00 -2.4440572e+01 -2.3993363e+01 -3.1233616e+00 -2.4437398e+01 -2.3990762e+01 -3.1323878e+00 -2.4434223e+01 -2.3988176e+01 -3.1413557e+00 -2.4431036e+01 -2.3985563e+01 -3.1503573e+00 -2.4427861e+01 -2.3983008e+01 -3.1593566e+00 -2.4424662e+01 -2.3980427e+01 -3.1683501e+00 -2.4421464e+01 -2.3977819e+01 -3.1773633e+00 -2.4418266e+01 -2.3975227e+01 -3.1863629e+00 -2.4415036e+01 -2.3972610e+01 -3.1953461e+00 -2.4411818e+01 -2.3970008e+01 -3.2043642e+00 -2.4408568e+01 -2.3967381e+01 -3.2133584e+00 -2.4405320e+01 -2.3964770e+01 -3.2223522e+00 -2.4402053e+01 -2.3962135e+01 -3.2313421e+00 -2.4398766e+01 -2.3959516e+01 -3.2403495e+00 -2.4395472e+01 -2.3956834e+01 -3.2493451e+00 -2.4392395e+01 -2.3954403e+01 -3.2583259e+00 -2.4388999e+01 -2.3951636e+01 -3.2673360e+00 -2.4385662e+01 -2.3948963e+01 -3.2763239e+00 -2.4382266e+01 -2.3946192e+01 -3.2853322e+00 -2.4378876e+01 -2.3943476e+01 -3.2943339e+00 -2.4375439e+01 -2.3940664e+01 -3.3033257e+00 -2.4371989e+01 -2.3937869e+01 -3.3123255e+00 -2.4368516e+01 -2.3935056e+01 -3.3213084e+00 -2.4365009e+01 -2.3932185e+01 -3.3303123e+00 -2.4361481e+01 -2.3929297e+01 -3.3393123e+00 -2.4357921e+01 -2.3926355e+01 -3.3483049e+00 -2.4354332e+01 -2.3923396e+01 -3.3573058e+00 -2.4350714e+01 -2.3920385e+01 -3.3663109e+00 -2.4347038e+01 -2.3917286e+01 -3.3752977e+00 -2.4343308e+01 -2.3914174e+01 -3.3842996e+00 -2.4339533e+01 -2.3910978e+01 -3.3932944e+00 -2.4335697e+01 -2.3907771e+01 -3.4022958e+00 -2.4331810e+01 -2.3904447e+01 -3.4112998e+00 -2.4327856e+01 -2.3901114e+01 -3.4202859e+00 -2.4323846e+01 -2.3897669e+01 -3.4292838e+00 -2.4319764e+01 -2.3894183e+01 -3.4382891e+00 -2.4315621e+01 -2.3890590e+01 -3.4472821e+00 -2.4311402e+01 -2.3886926e+01 -3.4562749e+00 -2.4307100e+01 -2.3883193e+01 -3.4652787e+00 -2.4302727e+01 -2.3879327e+01 -3.4742746e+00 -2.4298268e+01 -2.3875398e+01 -3.4832734e+00 -2.4293726e+01 -2.3871375e+01 -3.4922714e+00 -2.4289088e+01 -2.3867228e+01 -3.5012647e+00 -2.4284364e+01 -2.3862963e+01 -3.5102634e+00 -2.4279535e+01 -2.3858582e+01 -3.5192634e+00 -2.4274595e+01 -2.3854089e+01 -3.5282609e+00 -2.4269557e+01 -2.3849458e+01 -3.5372523e+00 -2.4264401e+01 -2.3844694e+01 -3.5462465e+00 -2.4259124e+01 -2.3839802e+01 -3.5552517e+00 -2.4253732e+01 -2.3834756e+01 -3.5642517e+00 -2.4248221e+01 -2.3829533e+01 -3.5732430e+00 -2.4242574e+01 -2.3824169e+01 -3.5822452e+00 -2.4236774e+01 -2.3818642e+01 -3.5912427e+00 -2.4230837e+01 -2.3812902e+01 -3.6002321e+00 -2.4224746e+01 -2.3807015e+01 -3.6092315e+00 -2.4218503e+01 -2.3800931e+01 -3.6182260e+00 -2.4212100e+01 -2.3794633e+01 -3.6272327e+00 -2.4205533e+01 -2.3788132e+01 -3.6362270e+00 -2.4198795e+01 -2.3781438e+01 -3.6452257e+00 -2.4190723e+01 -2.3773117e+01 -3.6542247e+00 -2.4183447e+01 -2.3765787e+01 -3.6632202e+00 -2.4175972e+01 -2.3758180e+01 -3.6722180e+00 -2.4168277e+01 -2.3750313e+01 -3.6812141e+00 -2.4160359e+01 -2.3742153e+01 -3.6902049e+00 -2.4152205e+01 -2.3733745e+01 -3.6992045e+00 -2.4143815e+01 -2.3725034e+01 -3.7081999e+00 -2.4135175e+01 -2.3716021e+01 -3.7172043e+00 -2.4126273e+01 -2.3706682e+01 -3.7261973e+00 -2.4117100e+01 -2.3697042e+01 -3.7351995e+00 -2.4107638e+01 -2.3687040e+01 -3.7441912e+00 -2.4097872e+01 -2.3676686e+01 -3.7531922e+00 -2.4087778e+01 -2.3665949e+01 -3.7621907e+00 -2.4077342e+01 -2.3654803e+01 -3.7711831e+00 -2.4066538e+01 -2.3643248e+01 -3.7801804e+00 -2.4055340e+01 -2.3631248e+01 -3.7891787e+00 -2.4043711e+01 -2.3618777e+01 -3.7981809e+00 -2.4031629e+01 -2.3605794e+01 -3.8071764e+00 -2.4019047e+01 -2.3592286e+01 -3.8161750e+00 -2.4005943e+01 -2.3578248e+01 -3.8251729e+00 -2.3992252e+01 -2.3563631e+01 -3.8341663e+00 -2.3977984e+01 -2.3548428e+01 -3.8431642e+00 -2.3963012e+01 -2.3532614e+01 -3.8521627e+00 -2.3947421e+01 -2.3516284e+01 -3.8611579e+00 -2.3930924e+01 -2.3499160e+01 -3.8701580e+00 -2.3913533e+01 -2.3481302e+01 -3.8791532e+00 -2.3895103e+01 -2.3462697e+01 -3.8881514e+00 -2.3875561e+01 -2.3443275e+01 -3.8971486e+00 -2.3854773e+01 -2.3423014e+01 -3.9061464e+00 -2.3832535e+01 -2.3401844e+01 -3.9151412e+00 -2.3808773e+01 -2.3379729e+01 -3.9241397e+00 -2.3783254e+01 -2.3356616e+01 -3.9331379e+00 -2.3755896e+01 -2.3332482e+01 -3.9421371e+00 -2.3726466e+01 -2.3307285e+01 -3.9511334e+00 -2.3694864e+01 -2.3280984e+01 -3.9601282e+00 -2.3660946e+01 -2.3253560e+01 -3.9691269e+00 -2.3626886e+01 -2.3227869e+01 -3.9781257e+00 -2.3587976e+01 -2.3198123e+01 -3.9871208e+00 -2.3546269e+01 -2.3166898e+01 -3.9961175e+00 -2.3501855e+01 -2.3134280e+01 -4.0051376e+00 -2.3455015e+01 -2.3100163e+01 -4.0141003e+00 -2.3405099e+01 -2.3064503e+01 -4.0231289e+00 -2.3352686e+01 -2.3027274e+01 -4.0320947e+00 -2.3297880e+01 -2.2988430e+01 -4.0411162e+00 -2.3240884e+01 -2.2947999e+01 -4.0501090e+00 -2.3181926e+01 -2.2905878e+01 -4.0591088e+00 -2.3121266e+01 -2.2862203e+01 -4.0681116e+00 -2.3059200e+01 -2.2816987e+01 -4.0771134e+00 -2.2996066e+01 -2.2770446e+01 -4.0861106e+00 -2.2932111e+01 -2.2722437e+01 -4.0950996e+00 -2.2867676e+01 -2.2673234e+01 -4.1040772e+00 -2.2803078e+01 -2.2623022e+01 -4.1130739e+00 -2.2738642e+01 -2.2572076e+01 -4.1220848e+00 -2.2674649e+01 -2.2520338e+01 -4.1310730e+00 -2.2611686e+01 -2.2468726e+01 -4.1400679e+00 -2.2550013e+01 -2.2417221e+01 -4.1490651e+00 -2.2490233e+01 -2.2366521e+01 -4.1580608e+00 -2.2432797e+01 -2.2317025e+01 -4.1670809e+00 -2.2378325e+01 -2.2269347e+01 -4.1760623e+00 -2.2327505e+01 -2.2224026e+01 -4.1850603e+00 -2.2281067e+01 -2.2182091e+01 -4.1940701e+00 -2.2239615e+01 -2.2144202e+01 -4.2030601e+00 -2.2167274e+01 -2.2083372e+01 -4.2120544e+00 -2.2127989e+01 -2.2046956e+01 -4.2210489e+00 -2.2094112e+01 -2.2015099e+01 -4.2300400e+00 -2.2065896e+01 -2.1988134e+01 -4.2390491e+00 -2.2043452e+01 -2.1966134e+01 -4.2480469e+00 -2.2026484e+01 -2.1948616e+01 -4.2570543e+00 -2.2015104e+01 -2.1936291e+01 -4.2660434e+00 -2.2008663e+01 -2.1928228e+01 -4.2750348e+00 -2.2006595e+01 -2.1923906e+01 -4.2840245e+00 -2.2008278e+01 -2.1922741e+01 -4.2930309e+00 -2.2013094e+01 -2.1924088e+01 -4.3020277e+00 -2.2020433e+01 -2.1927383e+01 -4.3110330e+00 -2.2029751e+01 -2.1932111e+01 -4.3200216e+00 -2.2040544e+01 -2.1937719e+01 -4.3290316e+00 -2.2052380e+01 -2.1943820e+01 -4.3380180e+00 -2.2064886e+01 -2.1950085e+01 -4.3470176e+00 -2.2077737e+01 -2.1956206e+01 -4.3560067e+00 -2.2090658e+01 -2.1961976e+01 -4.3650197e+00 -2.2103413e+01 -2.1967140e+01 -4.3740147e+00 -2.2115805e+01 -2.1971591e+01 -4.3830070e+00 -2.2127646e+01 -2.1975145e+01 -4.3920107e+00 -2.2138812e+01 -2.1977819e+01 -4.4010040e+00 -2.2149188e+01 -2.1979473e+01 -4.4100007e+00 -2.2158641e+01 -2.1980053e+01 -4.4189969e+00 -2.2167095e+01 -2.1979556e+01 -4.4279889e+00 -2.2174515e+01 -2.1977984e+01 -4.4369891e+00 -2.2180693e+01 -2.1974981e+01 -4.4459932e+00 -2.2185926e+01 -2.1971225e+01 -4.4549820e+00 -2.2190265e+01 -2.1966616e+01 -4.4639825e+00 -2.2193298e+01 -2.1961141e+01 -4.4729757e+00 -2.2194723e+01 -2.1954325e+01 -4.4819726e+00 -2.2195200e+01 -2.1946614e+01 -4.4909693e+00 -2.2195186e+01 -2.1938246e+01 -4.4999756e+00 -2.2194812e+01 -2.1929408e+01 -4.5089739e+00 -2.2193698e+01 -2.1919987e+01 -4.5179608e+00 -2.2192025e+01 -2.1910024e+01 -4.5269593e+00 -2.2190427e+01 -2.1899871e+01 -4.5359647e+00 -2.2188217e+01 -2.1889208e+01 -4.5449605e+00 -2.2185593e+01 -2.1878210e+01 -4.5539558e+00 -2.2182494e+01 -2.1866749e+01 -4.5629587e+00 -2.2179615e+01 -2.1855332e+01 -4.5719533e+00 -2.2175451e+01 -2.1843178e+01 -4.5809478e+00 -2.2171585e+01 -2.1831120e+01 -4.5899496e+00 -2.2166929e+01 -2.1818614e+01 -4.5989436e+00 -2.2161132e+01 -2.1805541e+01 -4.6079373e+00 -2.2155510e+01 -2.1792527e+01 -4.6169374e+00 -2.2148925e+01 -2.1778977e+01 -4.6259295e+00 -2.2141120e+01 -2.1764876e+01 -4.6349305e+00 -2.2133217e+01 -2.1750655e+01 -4.6439262e+00 -2.2123996e+01 -2.1735914e+01 -4.6529229e+00 -2.2114147e+01 -2.1720858e+01 -4.6619262e+00 -2.2103518e+01 -2.1705468e+01 -4.6709228e+00 -2.2092030e+01 -2.1689732e+01 -4.6799182e+00 -2.2079835e+01 -2.1673849e+01 -4.6889179e+00 -2.2066619e+01 -2.1657459e+01 -4.6979090e+00 -2.2052522e+01 -2.1640753e+01 -4.7069140e+00 -2.2034963e+01 -2.1622767e+01 -4.7159115e+00 -2.2018172e+01 -2.1605128e+01 -4.7249064e+00 -2.2001183e+01 -2.1587472e+01 -4.7339031e+00 -2.1983301e+01 -2.1569538e+01 -4.7428979e+00 -2.1964530e+01 -2.1551340e+01 -4.7518947e+00 -2.1944966e+01 -2.1532940e+01 -4.7608972e+00 -2.1924599e+01 -2.1514293e+01 -4.7698940e+00 -2.1903368e+01 -2.1495407e+01 -4.7788889e+00 -2.1881636e+01 -2.1476423e+01 -4.7878854e+00 -2.1859461e+01 -2.1457336e+01 -4.7968864e+00 -2.1836928e+01 -2.1438231e+01 -4.8058813e+00 -2.1814005e+01 -2.1419440e+01 -4.8148799e+00 -2.1791021e+01 -2.1400455e+01 -4.8238783e+00 -2.1768097e+01 -2.1381638e+01 -4.8328728e+00 -2.1745404e+01 -2.1363071e+01 -4.8418723e+00 -2.1723492e+01 -2.1345025e+01 -4.8508667e+00 -2.1702480e+01 -2.1327560e+01 -4.8598645e+00 -2.1682564e+01 -2.1310789e+01 -4.8688618e+00 -2.1664301e+01 -2.1294975e+01 -4.8778607e+00 -2.1646892e+01 -2.1279708e+01 -4.8868572e+00 -2.1630933e+01 -2.1265296e+01 -4.8958533e+00 -2.1616400e+01 -2.1251711e+01 -4.9048507e+00 -2.1603260e+01 -2.1238922e+01 -4.9138509e+00 -2.1591573e+01 -2.1226923e+01 -4.9228448e+00 -2.1581053e+01 -2.1215682e+01 -4.9318442e+00 -2.1571703e+01 -2.1205205e+01 -4.9408401e+00 -2.1563456e+01 -2.1195499e+01 -4.9498387e+00 -2.1556236e+01 -2.1186613e+01 -4.9588361e+00 -2.1550013e+01 -2.1178585e+01 -4.9678334e+00 -2.1544759e+01 -2.1171495e+01 -4.9768312e+00 -2.1540487e+01 -2.1165427e+01 -4.9858305e+00 -2.1537153e+01 -2.1160434e+01 -4.9948273e+00 -2.1534781e+01 -2.1156593e+01 -5.0038051e+00 -2.1533607e+01 -2.1154226e+01 -5.0128372e+00 -2.1533088e+01 -2.1152717e+01 -5.0218093e+00 -2.1534558e+01 -2.1152748e+01 -5.0308020e+00 -2.1535898e+01 -2.1153484e+01 -5.0398106e+00 -2.1537452e+01 -2.1154747e+01 -5.0487913e+00 -2.1539343e+01 -2.1156512e+01 -5.0578182e+00 -2.1541241e+01 -2.1158515e+01 -5.0668103e+00 -2.1543163e+01 -2.1160491e+01 -5.0758024e+00 -2.1544820e+01 -2.1162191e+01 -5.0847907e+00 -2.1546070e+01 -2.1163423e+01 -5.0938068e+00 -2.1546789e+01 -2.1164031e+01 -5.1028109e+00 -2.1546911e+01 -2.1163929e+01 -5.1118000e+00 -2.1546422e+01 -2.1163075e+01 -5.1208042e+00 -2.1545308e+01 -2.1161472e+01 -5.1297865e+00 -2.1543619e+01 -2.1159167e+01 -5.1387762e+00 -2.1541407e+01 -2.1156232e+01 -5.1477690e+00 -2.1538757e+01 -2.1152761e+01 -5.1567914e+00 -2.1535734e+01 -2.1148840e+01 -5.1657783e+00 -2.1532436e+01 -2.1144596e+01 -5.1747864e+00 -2.1528958e+01 -2.1140123e+01 -5.1837822e+00 -2.1525361e+01 -2.1135530e+01 -5.1927625e+00 -2.1521765e+01 -2.1130933e+01 -5.2017521e+00 -2.1518214e+01 -2.1126412e+01 -5.2107732e+00 -2.1514804e+01 -2.1122059e+01 -5.2197678e+00 -2.1511576e+01 -2.1117937e+01 -5.2287596e+00 -2.1508582e+01 -2.1114091e+01 -5.2377448e+00 -2.1505818e+01 -2.1110536e+01 -5.2467447e+00 -2.1503306e+01 -2.1107266e+01 -5.2557548e+00 -2.1501001e+01 -2.1104241e+01 -5.2647470e+00 -2.1498872e+01 -2.1101412e+01 -5.2737418e+00 -2.1496863e+01 -2.1098705e+01 -5.2827354e+00 -2.1498982e+01 -2.1097671e+01 -5.2917461e+00 -2.1496809e+01 -2.1094911e+01 -5.3007259e+00 -2.1494606e+01 -2.1092116e+01 -5.3097366e+00 -2.1492414e+01 -2.1089296e+01 -5.3187310e+00 -2.1490273e+01 -2.1086483e+01 -5.3277267e+00 -2.1488237e+01 -2.1083751e+01 -5.3367198e+00 -2.1486370e+01 -2.1081205e+01 -5.3457265e+00 -2.1484802e+01 -2.1078969e+01 -5.3547229e+00 -2.1483663e+01 -2.1077223e+01 -5.3637248e+00 -2.1483108e+01 -2.1076160e+01 -5.3727095e+00 -2.1483332e+01 -2.1076016e+01 -5.3817106e+00 -2.1484550e+01 -2.1077057e+01 -5.3907055e+00 -2.1486982e+01 -2.1079558e+01 -5.3997083e+00 -2.1490878e+01 -2.1083825e+01 -5.4086978e+00 -2.1496482e+01 -2.1090145e+01 -5.4177041e+00 -2.1503970e+01 -2.1098787e+01 -5.4267064e+00 -2.1513499e+01 -2.1109954e+01 -5.4357011e+00 -2.1525158e+01 -2.1123759e+01 -5.4447004e+00 -2.1538907e+01 -2.1140219e+01 -5.4536852e+00 -2.1554614e+01 -2.1159198e+01 -5.4626824e+00 -2.1572011e+01 -2.1180423e+01 -5.4716877e+00 -2.1590743e+01 -2.1203502e+01 -5.4806823e+00 -2.1610409e+01 -2.1227935e+01 -5.4896773e+00 -2.1630580e+01 -2.1253187e+01 -5.4986826e+00 -2.1650781e+01 -2.1278692e+01 -5.5076805e+00 -2.1670643e+01 -2.1303932e+01 -5.5166676e+00 -2.1689838e+01 -2.1328438e+01 -5.5256666e+00 -2.1708121e+01 -2.1351845e+01 -5.5346733e+00 -2.1725311e+01 -2.1373855e+01 -5.5436708e+00 -2.1741315e+01 -2.1394286e+01 -5.5526682e+00 -2.1756218e+01 -2.1413087e+01 -5.5616618e+00 -2.1769628e+01 -2.1429994e+01 -5.5706597e+00 -2.1782095e+01 -2.1445293e+01 -5.5796579e+00 -2.1793147e+01 -2.1458745e+01 -5.5886526e+00 -2.1803382e+01 -2.1470685e+01 -5.5976513e+00 -2.1812479e+01 -2.1481013e+01 -5.6066500e+00 -2.1820879e+01 -2.1490018e+01 -5.6156450e+00 -2.1828303e+01 -2.1497641e+01 -5.6246430e+00 -2.1835053e+01 -2.1504151e+01 -5.6336401e+00 -2.1841065e+01 -2.1509592e+01 -5.6426327e+00 -2.1846551e+01 -2.1514165e+01 -5.6516365e+00 -2.1851613e+01 -2.1518013e+01 -5.6606284e+00 -2.1856298e+01 -2.1521289e+01 -5.6696237e+00 -2.1860751e+01 -2.1524155e+01 -5.6786276e+00 -2.1865090e+01 -2.1526747e+01 -5.6876181e+00 -2.1869377e+01 -2.1529251e+01 -5.6966185e+00 -2.1873739e+01 -2.1531830e+01 -5.7056157e+00 -2.1879294e+01 -2.1535108e+01 -5.7146147e+00 -2.1885389e+01 -2.1538862e+01 -5.7236116e+00 -2.1891841e+01 -2.1543179e+01 -5.7326109e+00 -2.1898769e+01 -2.1548214e+01 -5.7416085e+00 -2.1906333e+01 -2.1554085e+01 -5.7506010e+00 -2.1914531e+01 -2.1560888e+01 -5.7595999e+00 -2.1923396e+01 -2.1568652e+01 -5.7686011e+00 -2.1932929e+01 -2.1577312e+01 -5.7775935e+00 -2.1943019e+01 -2.1586751e+01 -5.7865953e+00 -2.1953544e+01 -2.1596742e+01 -5.7955881e+00 -2.1964250e+01 -2.1607004e+01 -5.8045892e+00 -2.1974899e+01 -2.1617191e+01 -5.8135877e+00 -2.1985311e+01 -2.1627033e+01 -5.8225799e+00 -2.1995249e+01 -2.1636256e+01 -5.8315819e+00 -2.2004571e+01 -2.1644625e+01 -5.8405765e+00 -2.2013197e+01 -2.1652007e+01 -5.8495730e+00 -2.2021062e+01 -2.1658368e+01 -5.8585733e+00 -2.2028172e+01 -2.1663700e+01 -5.8675677e+00 -2.2034573e+01 -2.1668107e+01 -5.8765642e+00 -2.2040324e+01 -2.1671661e+01 -5.8855647e+00 -2.2045526e+01 -2.1674525e+01 -5.8945597e+00 -2.2050278e+01 -2.1676851e+01 -5.9035566e+00 -2.2054689e+01 -2.1678754e+01 -5.9125568e+00 -2.2058861e+01 -2.1680436e+01 -5.9215512e+00 -2.2062909e+01 -2.1681999e+01 -5.9305517e+00 -2.2066923e+01 -2.1683589e+01 -5.9395492e+00 -2.2071005e+01 -2.1685332e+01 -5.9485450e+00 -2.2075230e+01 -2.1687336e+01 -5.9575450e+00 -2.2079673e+01 -2.1689689e+01 -5.9665406e+00 -2.2084379e+01 -2.1692440e+01 -5.9755375e+00 -2.2089386e+01 -2.1695617e+01 -5.9845363e+00 -2.2094701e+01 -2.1699252e+01 -5.9935332e+00 -2.2100305e+01 -2.1703313e+01 -6.0025116e+00 -2.2106177e+01 -2.1707744e+01 -6.0115282e+00 -2.2112265e+01 -2.1712489e+01 -6.0205270e+00 -2.2118518e+01 -2.1717469e+01 -6.0295055e+00 -2.2124158e+01 -2.1722368e+01 -6.0385009e+00 -2.2131009e+01 -2.1727787e+01 -6.0475085e+00 -2.2137773e+01 -2.1733228e+01 -6.0565237e+00 -2.2144463e+01 -2.1738666e+01 -6.0655050e+00 -2.2151054e+01 -2.1744028e+01 -6.0745239e+00 -2.2157541e+01 -2.1749336e+01 -6.0835026e+00 -2.2163936e+01 -2.1754586e+01 -6.0925101e+00 -2.2170253e+01 -2.1759825e+01 -6.1015065e+00 -2.2176513e+01 -2.1765027e+01 -6.1104887e+00 -2.2182745e+01 -2.1770267e+01 -6.1194868e+00 -2.2188995e+01 -2.1775571e+01 -6.1284962e+00 -2.2195309e+01 -2.1781018e+01 -6.1374807e+00 -2.2201736e+01 -2.1786668e+01 -6.1465001e+00 -2.2208344e+01 -2.1792554e+01 -6.1554879e+00 -2.2215190e+01 -2.1798794e+01 -6.1644718e+00 -2.2222334e+01 -2.1805458e+01 -6.1734776e+00 -2.2229848e+01 -2.1812592e+01 -6.1824717e+00 -2.2237802e+01 -2.1820305e+01 -6.1914790e+00 -2.2246241e+01 -2.1828654e+01 -6.2004674e+00 -2.2255230e+01 -2.1837704e+01 -6.2094614e+00 -2.2264824e+01 -2.1847498e+01 -6.2184567e+00 -2.2275061e+01 -2.1858143e+01 -6.2274753e+00 -2.2285972e+01 -2.1869666e+01 -6.2364617e+00 -2.2297595e+01 -2.1882099e+01 -6.2454633e+00 -2.2309955e+01 -2.1895479e+01 -6.2544514e+00 -2.2323050e+01 -2.1909777e+01 -6.2634467e+00 -2.2336884e+01 -2.1925110e+01 -6.2724450e+00 -2.2351425e+01 -2.1941346e+01 -6.2814425e+00 -2.2366622e+01 -2.1958489e+01 -6.2904353e+00 -2.2382413e+01 -2.1976459e+01 -6.2994419e+00 -2.2398712e+01 -2.1995163e+01 -6.3084363e+00 -2.2415409e+01 -2.2014520e+01 -6.3174365e+00 -2.2432409e+01 -2.2034361e+01 -6.3264383e+00 -2.2449576e+01 -2.2054571e+01 -6.3354378e+00 -2.2466813e+01 -2.2075023e+01 -6.3444316e+00 -2.2484020e+01 -2.2095609e+01 -6.3534353e+00 -2.2501097e+01 -2.2116219e+01 -6.3624259e+00 -2.2518070e+01 -2.2136820e+01 -6.3714189e+00 -2.2534573e+01 -2.2157197e+01 -6.3804102e+00 -2.2551186e+01 -2.2177551e+01 -6.3894142e+00 -2.2567223e+01 -2.2197548e+01 -6.3984088e+00 -2.2582944e+01 -2.2217226e+01 -6.4074079e+00 -2.2598117e+01 -2.2236467e+01 -6.4164075e+00 -2.2612806e+01 -2.2255191e+01 -6.4254038e+00 -2.2626922e+01 -2.2273322e+01 -6.4344092e+00 -2.2640430e+01 -2.2290798e+01 -6.4434038e+00 -2.2653315e+01 -2.2307567e+01 -6.4523998e+00 -2.2665566e+01 -2.2323608e+01 -6.4613935e+00 -2.2677161e+01 -2.2338898e+01 -6.4703958e+00 -2.2688077e+01 -2.2353390e+01 -6.4793881e+00 -2.2698406e+01 -2.2367168e+01 -6.4883815e+00 -2.2708121e+01 -2.2380218e+01 -6.4973858e+00 -2.2717242e+01 -2.2392524e+01 -6.5063833e+00 -2.2725796e+01 -2.2404129e+01 -6.5153837e+00 -2.2733792e+01 -2.2415047e+01 -6.5243831e+00 -2.2741291e+01 -2.2425309e+01 -6.5333780e+00 -2.2748240e+01 -2.2434884e+01 -6.5423772e+00 -2.2754685e+01 -2.2443806e+01 -6.5513646e+00 -2.2760625e+01 -2.2452102e+01 -6.5603610e+00 -2.2766091e+01 -2.2459733e+01 -6.5693622e+00 -2.2770958e+01 -2.2466686e+01 -6.5783641e+00 -2.2775622e+01 -2.2473170e+01 -6.5873629e+00 -2.2779604e+01 -2.2478940e+01 -6.5963551e+00 -2.2783412e+01 -2.2484232e+01 -6.6053482e+00 -2.2786535e+01 -2.2488839e+01 -6.6143487e+00 -2.2789521e+01 -2.2493049e+01 -6.6233527e+00 -2.2791908e+01 -2.2496632e+01 -6.6323459e+00 -2.2794173e+01 -2.2499805e+01 -6.6413452e+00 -2.2795826e+01 -2.2502448e+01 -6.6503367e+00 -2.2797430e+01 -2.2504789e+01 -6.6593361e+00 -2.2798521e+01 -2.2506626e+01 -6.6683300e+00 -2.2799560e+01 -2.2508190e+01 -6.6773332e+00 -2.2800135e+01 -2.2509311e+01 -6.6863323e+00 -2.2800656e+01 -2.2510224e+01 -6.6953240e+00 -2.2800739e+01 -2.2510717e+01 -6.7043221e+00 -2.2800848e+01 -2.2511055e+01 -6.7133225e+00 -2.2800547e+01 -2.2511055e+01 -6.7223212e+00 -2.2800245e+01 -2.2510900e+01 -6.7313147e+00 -2.2799587e+01 -2.2510463e+01 -6.7403153e+00 -2.2798958e+01 -2.2509901e+01 -6.7493111e+00 -2.2798057e+01 -2.2509143e+01 -6.7583062e+00 -2.2797212e+01 -2.2508372e+01 -6.7673043e+00 -2.2796097e+01 -2.2507407e+01 -6.7763016e+00 -2.2795039e+01 -2.2506430e+01 -6.7853014e+00 -2.2793795e+01 -2.2505345e+01 -6.7942998e+00 -2.2792635e+01 -2.2504289e+01 -6.8032932e+00 -2.2791290e+01 -2.2503167e+01 -6.8122915e+00 -2.2790083e+01 -2.2502158e+01 -6.8212908e+00 -2.2788719e+01 -2.2501097e+01 -6.8302871e+00 -2.2787546e+01 -2.2500230e+01 -6.8392832e+00 -2.2786217e+01 -2.2499297e+01 -6.8482815e+00 -2.2785024e+01 -2.2498544e+01 -6.8572782e+00 -2.2783755e+01 -2.2497819e+01 -6.8662755e+00 -2.2782648e+01 -2.2497259e+01 -6.8752755e+00 -2.2781464e+01 -2.2496754e+01 -6.8842685e+00 -2.2780442e+01 -2.2496454e+01 -6.8932678e+00 -2.2779343e+01 -2.2496209e+01 -6.9022640e+00 -2.2778429e+01 -2.2496168e+01 -6.9112642e+00 -2.2777466e+01 -2.2496209e+01 -6.9202590e+00 -2.2776660e+01 -2.2496468e+01 -6.9292554e+00 -2.2775830e+01 -2.2496795e+01 -6.9382545e+00 -2.2775105e+01 -2.2497341e+01 -6.9472523e+00 -2.2774536e+01 -2.2498092e+01 -6.9562501e+00 -2.2773942e+01 -2.2498982e+01 -6.9652488e+00 -2.2773503e+01 -2.2500107e+01 -6.9742445e+00 -2.2773220e+01 -2.2501496e+01 -6.9832428e+00 -2.2772936e+01 -2.2503070e+01 -6.9922397e+00 -2.2772833e+01 -2.2504955e+01 -7.0012576e+00 -2.2772911e+01 -2.2507128e+01 -7.0102151e+00 -2.2773065e+01 -2.2509578e+01 -7.0192410e+00 -2.2773400e+01 -2.2512381e+01 -7.0282458e+00 -2.2773942e+01 -2.2515586e+01 -7.0372272e+00 -2.2774613e+01 -2.2519117e+01 -7.0462219e+00 -2.2775467e+01 -2.2523024e+01 -7.0552254e+00 -2.2776504e+01 -2.2527331e+01 -7.0642333e+00 -2.2777700e+01 -2.2532022e+01 -7.0732050e+00 -2.2779056e+01 -2.2537093e+01 -7.0822107e+00 -2.2780546e+01 -2.2542527e+01 -7.0912096e+00 -2.2782200e+01 -2.2548352e+01 -7.1001982e+00 -2.2783940e+01 -2.2554458e+01 -7.1092072e+00 -2.2785739e+01 -2.2560825e+01 -7.1181986e+00 -2.2787653e+01 -2.2567480e+01 -7.1272020e+00 -2.2789521e+01 -2.2574254e+01 -7.1361813e+00 -2.2791397e+01 -2.2581169e+01 -7.1451964e+00 -2.2793255e+01 -2.2588162e+01 -7.1541804e+00 -2.2795012e+01 -2.2595115e+01 -7.1631912e+00 -2.2796695e+01 -2.2602043e+01 -7.1721941e+00 -2.2798193e+01 -2.2608835e+01 -7.1811859e+00 -2.2799587e+01 -2.2615503e+01 -7.1901916e+00 -2.2800821e+01 -2.2621929e+01 -7.1991790e+00 -2.2801838e+01 -2.2628120e+01 -7.2081725e+00 -2.2802664e+01 -2.2634044e+01 -7.2171680e+00 -2.2803299e+01 -2.2639653e+01 -7.2261615e+00 -2.2803713e+01 -2.2644932e+01 -7.2351748e+00 -2.2803934e+01 -2.2649868e+01 -7.2441534e+00 -2.2803934e+01 -2.2654430e+01 -7.2531683e+00 -2.2803741e+01 -2.2658684e+01 -7.2621662e+00 -2.2803354e+01 -2.2662581e+01 -7.2711676e+00 -2.2802775e+01 -2.2666150e+01 -7.2801457e+00 -2.2802031e+01 -2.2669404e+01 -7.2891428e+00 -2.2800986e+01 -2.2672008e+01 -7.2981542e+00 -2.2799861e+01 -2.2674566e+01 -7.3071536e+00 -2.2798603e+01 -2.2676830e+01 -7.3161382e+00 -2.2796885e+01 -2.2678029e+01 -7.3251461e+00 -2.2795283e+01 -2.2679604e+01 -7.3341319e+00 -2.2793552e+01 -2.2680915e+01 -7.3431328e+00 -2.2791693e+01 -2.2681958e+01 -7.3521246e+00 -2.2789708e+01 -2.2682752e+01 -7.3611232e+00 -2.2787626e+01 -2.2683317e+01 -7.3701243e+00 -2.2785421e+01 -2.2683631e+01 -7.3791241e+00 -2.2783096e+01 -2.2683757e+01 -7.3881190e+00 -2.2780704e+01 -2.2683652e+01 -7.3971228e+00 -2.2778221e+01 -2.2683380e+01 -7.4061142e+00 -2.2775622e+01 -2.2682898e+01 -7.4151070e+00 -2.2772936e+01 -2.2682166e+01 -7.4241136e+00 -2.2770190e+01 -2.2681332e+01 -7.4331135e+00 -2.2767385e+01 -2.2680353e+01 -7.4421033e+00 -2.2764497e+01 -2.2679210e+01 -7.4511107e+00 -2.2761552e+01 -2.2677925e+01 -7.4601007e+00 -2.2758553e+01 -2.2676500e+01 -7.4691000e+00 -2.2755451e+01 -2.2674957e+01 -7.4780901e+00 -2.2752346e+01 -2.2673275e+01 -7.4870959e+00 -2.2749165e+01 -2.2671478e+01 -7.4960851e+00 -2.2745960e+01 -2.2669566e+01 -7.5050821e+00 -2.2742681e+01 -2.2667562e+01 -7.5140827e+00 -2.2739356e+01 -2.2665446e+01 -7.5230828e+00 -2.2736009e+01 -2.2663220e+01 -7.5320789e+00 -2.2732594e+01 -2.2660926e+01 -7.5410798e+00 -2.2729181e+01 -2.2658526e+01 -7.5500815e+00 -2.2725680e+01 -2.2656060e+01 -7.5590683e+00 -2.2722207e+01 -2.2653510e+01 -7.5680726e+00 -2.2718648e+01 -2.2650878e+01 -7.5770665e+00 -2.2715096e+01 -2.2648165e+01 -7.5860694e+00 -2.2711482e+01 -2.2645411e+01 -7.5950661e+00 -2.2707855e+01 -2.2642580e+01 -7.6040640e+00 -2.2704191e+01 -2.2639691e+01 -7.6130592e+00 -2.2700536e+01 -2.2636745e+01 -7.6220585e+00 -2.2696804e+01 -2.2633745e+01 -7.6310479e+00 -2.2693103e+01 -2.2630691e+01 -7.6400539e+00 -2.2689349e+01 -2.2627604e+01 -7.6490426e+00 -2.2685585e+01 -2.2624464e+01 -7.6580400e+00 -2.2681791e+01 -2.2621275e+01 -7.6670418e+00 -2.2678008e+01 -2.2618037e+01 -7.6760348e+00 -2.2674156e+01 -2.2614769e+01 -7.6850338e+00 -2.2670338e+01 -2.2611473e+01 -7.6940345e+00 -2.2666472e+01 -2.2608130e+01 -7.7030333e+00 -2.2662621e+01 -2.2604778e+01 -7.7120264e+00 -2.2658724e+01 -2.2601366e+01 -7.7210270e+00 -2.2654842e+01 -2.2597962e+01 -7.7300228e+00 -2.2650936e+01 -2.2594500e+01 -7.7390182e+00 -2.2647027e+01 -2.2591048e+01 -7.7480174e+00 -2.2643095e+01 -2.2587556e+01 -7.7570162e+00 -2.2639179e+01 -2.2584059e+01 -7.7660111e+00 -2.2635224e+01 -2.2580523e+01 -7.7750130e+00 -2.2631267e+01 -2.2576984e+01 -7.7840036e+00 -2.2627309e+01 -2.2573424e+01 -7.7930007e+00 -2.2623350e+01 -2.2569877e+01 -7.8020002e+00 -2.2619373e+01 -2.2566294e+01 -7.8109982e+00 -2.2615396e+01 -2.2562709e+01 -7.8199977e+00 -2.2611402e+01 -2.2559107e+01 -7.8289948e+00 -2.2607426e+01 -2.2555502e+01 -7.8379922e+00 -2.2603417e+01 -2.2551881e+01 -7.8469862e+00 -2.2599427e+01 -2.2548275e+01 -7.8559853e+00 -2.2595423e+01 -2.2544637e+01 -7.8649855e+00 -2.2591421e+01 -2.2541015e+01 -7.8739829e+00 -2.2587388e+01 -2.2537362e+01 -7.8829797e+00 -2.2583376e+01 -2.2533726e+01 -7.8919777e+00 -2.2579351e+01 -2.2530075e+01 -7.9009731e+00 -2.2575347e+01 -2.2526425e+01 -7.9099677e+00 -2.2571315e+01 -2.2522777e+01 -7.9189682e+00 -2.2567287e+01 -2.2519117e+01 -7.9279654e+00 -2.2563249e+01 -2.2515444e+01 -7.9369609e+00 -2.2559217e+01 -2.2511788e+01 -7.9459607e+00 -2.2555159e+01 -2.2508120e+01 -7.9549561e+00 -2.2551124e+01 -2.2504456e+01 -7.9639530e+00 -2.2547079e+01 -2.2500780e+01 -7.9729523e+00 -2.2543027e+01 -2.2497109e+01 -7.9819499e+00 -2.2538967e+01 -2.2493427e+01 -7.9909468e+00 -2.2534930e+01 -2.2489737e+01 -7.9999435e+00 -2.2530856e+01 -2.2486050e+01 -8.0089407e+00 -2.2526805e+01 -2.2482356e+01 -8.0179511e+00 -2.2522734e+01 -2.2478653e+01 -8.0269416e+00 -2.2518658e+01 -2.2474955e+01 -8.0359498e+00 -2.2514577e+01 -2.2471238e+01 -8.0449315e+00 -2.2510506e+01 -2.2467526e+01 -8.0539232e+00 -2.2506416e+01 -2.2463795e+01 -8.0629203e+00 -2.2502324e+01 -2.2460071e+01 -8.0719188e+00 -2.2498243e+01 -2.2456329e+01 -8.0809150e+00 -2.2494145e+01 -2.2452582e+01 -8.0899051e+00 -2.2490045e+01 -2.2448831e+01 -8.0989205e+00 -2.2485931e+01 -2.2445063e+01 -8.1079219e+00 -2.2481828e+01 -2.2441291e+01 -8.1169065e+00 -2.2477712e+01 -2.2437517e+01 -8.1259040e+00 -2.2473583e+01 -2.2433716e+01 -8.1349099e+00 -2.2469467e+01 -2.2429924e+01 -8.1438888e+00 -2.2465327e+01 -2.2426108e+01 -8.1528996e+00 -2.2461188e+01 -2.2422290e+01 -8.1619068e+00 -2.2457050e+01 -2.2418460e+01 -8.1709068e+00 -2.2452902e+01 -2.2414618e+01 -8.1798963e+00 -2.2448745e+01 -2.2410766e+01 -8.1889004e+00 -2.2444579e+01 -2.2406902e+01 -8.1978868e+00 -2.2440417e+01 -2.2403029e+01 -8.2068798e+00 -2.2436246e+01 -2.2399136e+01 -8.2158754e+00 -2.2432068e+01 -2.2395245e+01 -8.2248696e+00 -2.2427884e+01 -2.2391335e+01 -8.2338841e+00 -2.2423693e+01 -2.2387407e+01 -8.2428643e+00 -2.2419497e+01 -2.2383482e+01 -8.2518571e+00 -2.2415296e+01 -2.2379531e+01 -8.2608581e+00 -2.2411090e+01 -2.2375574e+01 -8.2698630e+00 -2.2406869e+01 -2.2371611e+01 -8.2788679e+00 -2.2402645e+01 -2.2367624e+01 -8.2878689e+00 -2.2398418e+01 -2.2363632e+01 -8.2968626e+00 -2.2394189e+01 -2.2359628e+01 -8.3058456e+00 -2.2389947e+01 -2.2355621e+01 -8.3148570e+00 -2.2385704e+01 -2.2351591e+01 -8.3238500e+00 -2.2381450e+01 -2.2347551e+01 -8.3328423e+00 -2.2377196e+01 -2.2343499e+01 -8.3418498e+00 -2.2372931e+01 -2.2339438e+01 -8.3508486e+00 -2.2368658e+01 -2.2335367e+01 -8.3598355e+00 -2.2364386e+01 -2.2331288e+01 -8.3688259e+00 -2.2360105e+01 -2.2327191e+01 -8.3778342e+00 -2.2355808e+01 -2.2323078e+01 -8.3868377e+00 -2.2351513e+01 -2.2318967e+01 -8.3958329e+00 -2.2347212e+01 -2.2314832e+01 -8.4048166e+00 -2.2342906e+01 -2.2310700e+01 -8.4138193e+00 -2.2338585e+01 -2.2306546e+01 -8.4228196e+00 -2.2334269e+01 -2.2302387e+01 -8.4318139e+00 -2.2329940e+01 -2.2298208e+01 -8.4408147e+00 -2.2325607e+01 -2.2294025e+01 -8.4498177e+00 -2.2321263e+01 -2.2289832e+01 -8.4588040e+00 -2.2316917e+01 -2.2285628e+01 -8.4678004e+00 -2.2312560e+01 -2.2281415e+01 -8.4768027e+00 -2.2308203e+01 -2.2277185e+01 -8.4858066e+00 -2.2303836e+01 -2.2272955e+01 -8.4947944e+00 -2.2299461e+01 -2.2268709e+01 -8.5037907e+00 -2.2295078e+01 -2.2264449e+01 -8.5127911e+00 -2.2290688e+01 -2.2260182e+01 -8.5217916e+00 -2.2286291e+01 -2.2255903e+01 -8.5307886e+00 -2.2281889e+01 -2.2251618e+01 -8.5397784e+00 -2.2277481e+01 -2.2247314e+01 -8.5487824e+00 -2.2273061e+01 -2.2243007e+01 -8.5577838e+00 -2.2268637e+01 -2.2238689e+01 -8.5667791e+00 -2.2264202e+01 -2.2234361e+01 -8.5757765e+00 -2.2259764e+01 -2.2230017e+01 -8.5847721e+00 -2.2255316e+01 -2.2225673e+01 -8.5937733e+00 -2.2250859e+01 -2.2221313e+01 -8.6027651e+00 -2.2246394e+01 -2.2216933e+01 -8.6117658e+00 -2.2241929e+01 -2.2212554e+01 -8.6207605e+00 -2.2237449e+01 -2.2208169e+01 -8.6297561e+00 -2.2232963e+01 -2.2203766e+01 -8.6387587e+00 -2.2228464e+01 -2.2199359e+01 -8.6477545e+00 -2.2223960e+01 -2.2194934e+01 -8.6567496e+00 -2.2219445e+01 -2.2190508e+01 -8.6657498e+00 -2.2214927e+01 -2.2186059e+01 -8.6747418e+00 -2.2210391e+01 -2.2181609e+01 -8.6837403e+00 -2.2205854e+01 -2.2177139e+01 -8.6927412e+00 -2.2201301e+01 -2.2172663e+01 -8.7017406e+00 -2.2196741e+01 -2.2168175e+01 -8.7107349e+00 -2.2192167e+01 -2.2163670e+01 -8.7197289e+00 -2.2187588e+01 -2.2159160e+01 -8.7287270e+00 -2.2182997e+01 -2.2154635e+01 -8.7377252e+00 -2.2178395e+01 -2.2150096e+01 -8.7467276e+00 -2.2173783e+01 -2.2145548e+01 -8.7557224e+00 -2.2169155e+01 -2.2140988e+01 -8.7647215e+00 -2.2164519e+01 -2.2136415e+01 -8.7737133e+00 -2.2159875e+01 -2.2131826e+01 -8.7827162e+00 -2.2155212e+01 -2.2127226e+01 -8.7917117e+00 -2.2150544e+01 -2.2122617e+01 -8.8007102e+00 -2.2145858e+01 -2.2117988e+01 -8.8097078e+00 -2.2141162e+01 -2.2113351e+01 -8.8187008e+00 -2.2136451e+01 -2.2108697e+01 -8.8276987e+00 -2.2131732e+01 -2.2104025e+01 -8.8366975e+00 -2.2126993e+01 -2.2099343e+01 -8.8456932e+00 -2.2122243e+01 -2.2094647e+01 -8.8546946e+00 -2.2117475e+01 -2.2089936e+01 -8.8636916e+00 -2.2112698e+01 -2.2085207e+01 -8.8726864e+00 -2.2107900e+01 -2.2080462e+01 -8.8816870e+00 -2.2103088e+01 -2.2075705e+01 -8.8906836e+00 -2.2098258e+01 -2.2070929e+01 -8.8996783e+00 -2.2093417e+01 -2.2066133e+01 -8.9086780e+00 -2.2088555e+01 -2.2061325e+01 -8.9176735e+00 -2.2083678e+01 -2.2056496e+01 -8.9266716e+00 -2.2078782e+01 -2.2051651e+01 -8.9356685e+00 -2.2073869e+01 -2.2046787e+01 -8.9446652e+00 -2.2068934e+01 -2.2041905e+01 -8.9536631e+00 -2.2063979e+01 -2.2037006e+01 -8.9626581e+00 -2.2059011e+01 -2.2032082e+01 -8.9716562e+00 -2.2054015e+01 -2.2027140e+01 -8.9806532e+00 -2.2049003e+01 -2.2022180e+01 -8.9896545e+00 -2.2043966e+01 -2.2017195e+01 -8.9986516e+00 -2.2038911e+01 -2.2012191e+01 -9.0076624e+00 -2.2033835e+01 -2.2007159e+01 -9.0166573e+00 -2.2028729e+01 -2.2002111e+01 -9.0256335e+00 -2.2023604e+01 -2.1997057e+01 -9.0346285e+00 -2.2018453e+01 -2.1991954e+01 -9.0436373e+00 -2.2013278e+01 -2.1986826e+01 -9.0526170e+00 -2.2008079e+01 -2.1981674e+01 -9.0616409e+00 -2.2002850e+01 -2.1976501e+01 -9.0706288e+00 -2.1997575e+01 -2.1971307e+01 -9.0796153e+00 -2.1992295e+01 -2.1966054e+01 -9.0886321e+00 -2.1986994e+01 -2.1960824e+01 -9.0976043e+00 -2.1981674e+01 -2.1955539e+01 -9.1066328e+00 -2.1976295e+01 -2.1950201e+01 -9.1156105e+00 -2.1970900e+01 -2.1944889e+01 -9.1246020e+00 -2.1965452e+01 -2.1939491e+01 -9.1336028e+00 -2.1959991e+01 -2.1934084e+01 -9.1426084e+00 -2.1954481e+01 -2.1928670e+01 -9.1516150e+00 -2.1948963e+01 -2.1923178e+01 -9.1605886e+00 -2.1943400e+01 -2.1917681e+01 -9.1695863e+00 -2.1937794e+01 -2.1912148e+01 -9.1786029e+00 -2.1932148e+01 -2.1906578e+01 -9.1876053e+00 -2.1926465e+01 -2.1900976e+01 -9.1965907e+00 -2.1920746e+01 -2.1895308e+01 -9.2055833e+00 -2.1914995e+01 -2.1889612e+01 -9.2145790e+00 -2.1909213e+01 -2.1883891e+01 -9.2235738e+00 -2.1903368e+01 -2.1878145e+01 -9.2325896e+00 -2.1897498e+01 -2.1872312e+01 -9.2415714e+00 -2.1891570e+01 -2.1866493e+01 -9.2505664e+00 -2.1885589e+01 -2.1860593e+01 -9.2595700e+00 -2.1879591e+01 -2.1854648e+01 -9.2685780e+00 -2.1873544e+01 -2.1848661e+01 -9.2775634e+00 -2.1867420e+01 -2.1842634e+01 -9.2865687e+00 -2.1861255e+01 -2.1836570e+01 -9.2955671e+00 -2.1855052e+01 -2.1830443e+01 -9.3045552e+00 -2.1848814e+01 -2.1824256e+01 -9.3135509e+00 -2.1842483e+01 -2.1818042e+01 -9.3225501e+00 -2.1836123e+01 -2.1811775e+01 -9.3315488e+00 -2.1829709e+01 -2.1805430e+01 -9.3405433e+00 -2.1823243e+01 -2.1799040e+01 -9.3495495e+00 -2.1816702e+01 -2.1792608e+01 -9.3585440e+00 -2.1810117e+01 -2.1786111e+01 -9.3675423e+00 -2.1803465e+01 -2.1779578e+01 -9.3765405e+00 -2.1796777e+01 -2.1772962e+01 -9.3855348e+00 -2.1790003e+01 -2.1766293e+01 -9.3945392e+00 -2.1783148e+01 -2.1759551e+01 -9.4035323e+00 -2.1776270e+01 -2.1752763e+01 -9.4125277e+00 -2.1769296e+01 -2.1745887e+01 -9.4215217e+00 -2.1762255e+01 -2.1738975e+01 -9.4305265e+00 -2.1755179e+01 -2.1731984e+01 -9.4395222e+00 -2.1747997e+01 -2.1724919e+01 -9.4485208e+00 -2.1740765e+01 -2.1717809e+01 -9.4575186e+00 -2.1733439e+01 -2.1710612e+01 -9.4665117e+00 -2.1726073e+01 -2.1703335e+01 -9.4755114e+00 -2.1718603e+01 -2.1695984e+01 -9.4845134e+00 -2.1711080e+01 -2.1688585e+01 -9.4934999e+00 -2.1703466e+01 -2.1681081e+01 -9.5024954e+00 -2.1695768e+01 -2.1673521e+01 -9.5114957e+00 -2.1687992e+01 -2.1665868e+01 -9.5204966e+00 -2.1680145e+01 -2.1658150e+01 -9.5294945e+00 -2.1672212e+01 -2.1650353e+01 -9.5384858e+00 -2.1664201e+01 -2.1642465e+01 -9.5474916e+00 -2.1656099e+01 -2.1634493e+01 -9.5564834e+00 -2.1647914e+01 -2.1626444e+01 -9.5654818e+00 -2.1639634e+01 -2.1618307e+01 -9.5744827e+00 -2.1631267e+01 -2.1610090e+01 -9.5834822e+00 -2.1622821e+01 -2.1601782e+01 -9.5924766e+00 -2.1614287e+01 -2.1593375e+01 -9.6014733e+00 -2.1605653e+01 -2.1584893e+01 -9.6104685e+00 -2.1596931e+01 -2.1576312e+01 -9.6194690e+00 -2.1588111e+01 -2.1567640e+01 -9.6284605e+00 -2.1579186e+01 -2.1558871e+01 -9.6374597e+00 -2.1570183e+01 -2.1550013e+01 -9.6464625e+00 -2.1561078e+01 -2.1541060e+01 -9.6554554e+00 -2.1551881e+01 -2.1532007e+01 -9.6644539e+00 -2.1542572e+01 -2.1522864e+01 -9.6734541e+00 -2.1533177e+01 -2.1513612e+01 -9.6824520e+00 -2.1523676e+01 -2.1504275e+01 -9.6914440e+00 -2.1514066e+01 -2.1494823e+01 -9.7004441e+00 -2.1504372e+01 -2.1485280e+01 -9.7094396e+00 -2.1494565e+01 -2.1475643e+01 -9.7184353e+00 -2.1484656e+01 -2.1465898e+01 -9.7274355e+00 -2.1474644e+01 -2.1456044e+01 -9.7364363e+00 -2.1464529e+01 -2.1446093e+01 -9.7454340e+00 -2.1454309e+01 -2.1436045e+01 -9.7544248e+00 -2.1443987e+01 -2.1425876e+01 -9.7634280e+00 -2.1433563e+01 -2.1415612e+01 -9.7724244e+00 -2.1423026e+01 -2.1405254e+01 -9.7814179e+00 -2.1412390e+01 -2.1394770e+01 -9.7904189e+00 -2.1401636e+01 -2.1384197e+01 -9.7994164e+00 -2.1390790e+01 -2.1373506e+01 -9.8084136e+00 -2.1379822e+01 -2.1362720e+01 -9.8174067e+00 -2.1368759e+01 -2.1351816e+01 -9.8264053e+00 -2.1357585e+01 -2.1340807e+01 -9.8354052e+00 -2.1346305e+01 -2.1329698e+01 -9.8444026e+00 -2.1334916e+01 -2.1318478e+01 -9.8534001e+00 -2.1323425e+01 -2.1307153e+01 -9.8623938e+00 -2.1311829e+01 -2.1295721e+01 -9.8713919e+00 -2.1300119e+01 -2.1284180e+01 -9.8803905e+00 -2.1288311e+01 -2.1272540e+01 -9.8893858e+00 -2.1276388e+01 -2.1260784e+01 -9.8983851e+00 -2.1264369e+01 -2.1248929e+01 -9.9073845e+00 -2.1252239e+01 -2.1236969e+01 -9.9163802e+00 -2.1240007e+01 -2.1224900e+01 -9.9253791e+00 -2.1227671e+01 -2.1212724e+01 -9.9343772e+00 -2.1215233e+01 -2.1200453e+01 -9.9433708e+00 -2.1202691e+01 -2.1188070e+01 -9.9523710e+00 -2.1190050e+01 -2.1175588e+01 -9.9613689e+00 -2.1177302e+01 -2.1162999e+01 -9.9703655e+00 -2.1164455e+01 -2.1150310e+01 -9.9793617e+00 -2.1151509e+01 -2.1137523e+01 -9.9883583e+00 -2.1138466e+01 -2.1124632e+01 diff --git a/src/hydro/srcterms/tabular_cooling.cpp b/src/hydro/srcterms/tabular_cooling.cpp index 9164f4cc..7143029b 100644 --- a/src/hydro/srcterms/tabular_cooling.cpp +++ b/src/hydro/srcterms/tabular_cooling.cpp @@ -33,8 +33,17 @@ TabularCooling::TabularCooling(ParameterInput *pin, const std::string table_filename = pin->GetString("cooling", "table_filename"); - const int log_temp_col = pin->GetOrAddInteger("cooling", "log_temp_col", 0); - const int log_lambda_col = pin->GetOrAddInteger("cooling", "log_lambda_col", 1); + // It should be fine to just issue a warning here. + // If an original cooling table with two columns was used, the behavior is the same. + // If not, then the test below on the number of columns in the file will fail. + if (Globals::my_rank == 0 && (pin->DoesParameterExist("cooling", "log_temp_col") || + pin->DoesParameterExist("cooling", "log_lambda_col"))) { + PARTHENON_WARN("\"cooling/log_temp_col\" or \"cooling/log_lambda_col\" found in" + "the parameter input.\n" + "These have been deprecated and only cooling tables for a single " + "metallicity containing the log10 temperature and log10 lambdas are " + "supported.\n"); + } const Real lambda_units_cgs = pin->GetReal("cooling", "lambda_units_cgs"); // Convert erg cm^3/s to code units @@ -109,16 +118,16 @@ TabularCooling::TabularCooling(ParameterInput *pin, std::vector line_data{std::istream_iterator{iss}, std::istream_iterator{}}; // Check size - if (line_data.empty() || line_data.size() <= std::max(log_temp_col, log_lambda_col)) { + if (line_data.empty() || line_data.size() != 2) { msg << "### FATAL ERROR in function [TabularCooling::TabularCooling]" << std::endl - << "Index " << std::max(log_temp_col, log_lambda_col) << " out of range on \"" - << line << "\"" << std::endl; + << "Expected exactly two columns per line but got: \"" << line << "\"" + << std::endl; PARTHENON_FAIL(msg); } try { - const Real log_temp = std::stod(line_data[log_temp_col]); - const Real log_lambda = std::stod(line_data[log_lambda_col]); + const Real log_temp = std::stod(line_data[0]); + const Real log_lambda = std::stod(line_data[1]); // Add to growing list log_temps.push_back(log_temp); diff --git a/tst/regression/test_suites/cluster_tabular_cooling/cluster_tabular_cooling.py b/tst/regression/test_suites/cluster_tabular_cooling/cluster_tabular_cooling.py index e04cdc60..1b4b0077 100644 --- a/tst/regression/test_suites/cluster_tabular_cooling/cluster_tabular_cooling.py +++ b/tst/regression/test_suites/cluster_tabular_cooling/cluster_tabular_cooling.py @@ -170,8 +170,6 @@ def Prepare(self, parameters, step): f"problem/cluster/uniform_gas/uz={self.uniform_gas_uz.in_units('code_length*code_time**-1').v}", f"problem/cluster/uniform_gas/pres={self.uniform_gas_pres.in_units('code_mass*code_length**-1*code_time**-2').v}", f"cooling/table_filename={table_filename}", - f"cooling/log_temp_col=0", - f"cooling/log_lambda_col=1", f"cooling/lambda_units_cgs=1", f"cooling/integrator={integrator}", f"cooling/cfl={cooling_cfl}",