Australia OCD ID Update #367
Conversation
|
@azuser we have also added valid through dates to Agricultural Region, East Metropolitan Region, Mining and Pastoral Region, North Metropolitan Region, South Metropolitan Region, South West Region in councils.csv and updated also updated in country-au.csv and & sorted alphabetically on ID Column. |
| ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:baulkham_hills,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:kellyville,Baulkham Hills renamed to Kellyville | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:ku-ring-gai,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:wahroonga,Ku-ring-gai renamed to Wahroonga | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:mulgoa,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:badgerys_creek,Mulgoa renamed to Badgerys Creek |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
On the wiki for Badgerys Creek the renaming is mentioned however I was able to find anything related to this on page 13 of the PDF linked above. Do you have another source you can provide for this change?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@HKSenior This is an old change of 2023 of NSW, we are not sure, why this comment has been made here.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sorry there was a mistype on my part.
In the wiki linked above the renaming is mentioned however it isn't mentioned in the pdf (page 13/14) linked above. Do you have an official source that confirms the renaming change?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The wiki Link mentioned above is not the right source for reference with respect to Western Australia . And the reference which can be used for the same is mentioned below .
The Link for the State is -
https://www.boundaries.wa.gov.au/sites/default/files/content/2023%20Review%20of%20WA's%20Electoral%20Boundaries%20-%20Final%20Report.pdf
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@HKSenior @GoogleCivics-Kantar Just in regards to Badgerys creek the relevant information can be seen here https://elections.nsw.gov.au/voters/electoral-districts-redistribution/names-and-boundaries-of-electoral-districts but as @GoogleCivics-Kantar is correct Badgerys Creek is in NSW not WA
| @@ -1,5 +1,9 @@ | |||
| id,sameAs,sameAsNote | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
From page 1 of the pdf (last paragraph) these changes will go in affect at the next State General Election which is due to be held in March of 2025. Add a column column called validFrom and set all of the relevant changes validFrom column to 2025-03.
From page 12 of the pdf add 2 additional lines for North West Central and Moore to point to Mid-West. That is:
ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:north_west_central,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:mid-west,North West Central renamed to Mid-West
ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:moore,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:mid-west,Moore renamed to Mid-West
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@HKSenior The above suggestions is slightly tweaked. i.e. nsw is changed to WA. In assemblies.csv we do not have an option for putting comments. Also, we are not making changes in alias.csv because this is the case in which North West Central and Moore assemblies has been abolished and amalgamated as Mid West.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I see the corresponding changes in the assembles.csv file, thanks.
identifiers/country-au.csv
Outdated
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:bicton,Bicton,,,, | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:bunbury,Bunbury,,,, | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:burns_beach,Burns Beach,,,, | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:burns_beach,Burns Beach,ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:mindarie,Burns Beach renamed to Mindarie,, |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Add the validFrom date to this line (the date of the next State General Election). Same for other ids being added in.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@HKSenior validFrom dates are added in the same.
identifiers/country-au.csv
Outdated
| @@ -551,37 +553,41 @@ ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:kwinana,Kwinana,,,, | |||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:landsdale,Landsdale,,,, | |||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:mandurah,Mandurah,,,, | |||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:maylands,Maylands,,,, | |||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:wa/sldl:mid_west,Mid-West,,,,2025 | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Lets be as specific as possible with the date. According to the pdf these changes go into affect in March of 2025. So lets change the validFrom to 2025-03. Here, above and below.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@HKSenior validFrom dates are added in the same.
| ocd-division/country:au/state:vic/sldu:western_metropolitan,Western Metropolitan | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:vic/sldu:western_victoria,Western Victoria | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:tas/sldu:windermere,Windermere | ||
| id,name,validFrom,validThrough |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Can you provide documentation to confirm these changes?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@HKSenior These changes in Victoria and Tasmania are not made by us, wrong ocd ids are being referred here. Kindly guide us which changes you are referring to.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I see these changes are solely reorganizing into alphabetical order.
In the future it would be best to submit 2 PRs one with the updates due to the upcoming redistricting and another as cleanup. The sorting is nice to have but can bloat diffs and make discerning between cleanup and actual changes a bit difficult to spot.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
sure, we will follow this going forward
| ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:baulkham_hills,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:kellyville,Baulkham Hills renamed to Kellyville | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:ku-ring-gai,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:wahroonga,Ku-ring-gai renamed to Wahroonga | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:mulgoa,ocd-division/country:au/state:nsw/sldl:badgerys_creek,Mulgoa renamed to Badgerys Creek |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sorry there was a mistype on my part.
In the wiki linked above the renaming is mentioned however it isn't mentioned in the pdf (page 13/14) linked above. Do you have an official source that confirms the renaming change?
| @@ -1,5 +1,9 @@ | |||
| id,sameAs,sameAsNote | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I see the corresponding changes in the assembles.csv file, thanks.
| ocd-division/country:au/state:vic/sldu:western_metropolitan,Western Metropolitan | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:vic/sldu:western_victoria,Western Victoria | ||
| ocd-division/country:au/state:tas/sldu:windermere,Windermere | ||
| id,name,validFrom,validThrough |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I see these changes are solely reorganizing into alphabetical order.
In the future it would be best to submit 2 PRs one with the updates due to the upcoming redistricting and another as cleanup. The sorting is nice to have but can bloat diffs and make discerning between cleanup and actual changes a bit difficult to spot.
Hi @azuser
We have made the below changes for Australia.