Cannot find lX11 library on Mac OS Sonoma 14.1

[alex88ridolfi]

Hi @kazuakiyama ,

I would like to install pgplot on my Mac OS Sonoma 14.1 Intel mac through brew, and found your nice repository.

However when I run "brew install kazuakiyama/pgplot/pgplot", the compilation fails with the following error

ld: library not found for -lX11
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
make: *** [libpgplot.dylib] Error 1

Of course I have XQuartz, as well as the Xcode tools + Command Line tools installed.

I am pasting below the whole output.

Do you have any suggestions on how let the linker find the library?
I am not even sure where the latter is located, to be honest.

Many thanks in advance for your possible help!

Cheers,
Alessandro

alex@bellatrix:~$ brew install kazuakiyama/pgplot/pgplot
==> Fetching kazuakiyama/pgplot/pgplot
==> Downloading https://raw.githubusercontent.com/kazuakiyama/hb-pgplot-patches/5eba73c0f42daba2d6404550244cc74280d10c4a/patch-makemake.diff
Already downloaded: /Users/alex/Library/Caches/Homebrew/downloads/01775b03c3ee5a079b98979e5c6014930d3824121e21855c83de1fcd4993d541--patch-makemake.diff
==> Downloading https://raw.githubusercontent.com/kazuakiyama/hb-pgplot-patches/5eba73c0f42daba2d6404550244cc74280d10c4a/patch-proccom.c.diff
Already downloaded: /Users/alex/Library/Caches/Homebrew/downloads/6d79a9025118c75397674be06e5a381c733b5bbe43c1b29f6ea03dd42729abea--patch-proccom.c.diff
==> Downloading https://raw.githubusercontent.com/kazuakiyama/hb-pgplot-patches/5eba73c0f42daba2d6404550244cc74280d10c4a/patch-grtermio.c.diff
Already downloaded: /Users/alex/Library/Caches/Homebrew/downloads/68c2c88263522b61caa2f8a5cb7ab32c0d1fbf435b0e2bb3eb0aae8de41848b8--patch-grtermio.c.diff
==> Downloading https://raw.githubusercontent.com/kazuakiyama/hb-pgplot-patches/5eba73c0f42daba2d6404550244cc74280d10c4a/patch-grfileio.c.diff
Already downloaded: /Users/alex/Library/Caches/Homebrew/downloads/a3c09625178d74017d9318cd50893c91bd2e678b63b145eb79d11ab494940f22--patch-grfileio.c.diff
==> Downloading ftp://ftp.astro.caltech.edu/pub/pgplot/pgplot522.tar.gz
Already downloaded: /Users/alex/Library/Caches/Homebrew/downloads/afb04afea3c466aa13e93eb0f33393758c846a8d70211280580b5b3689abd1c6--pgplot522.tar.gz
==> Installing pgplot from kazuakiyama/pgplot
==> Patching
==> Applying patch-makemake.diff
patching file makemake
==> Applying patch-proccom.c.diff
patching file 'pgdispd/proccom.c'
==> Applying patch-grtermio.c.diff
patching file 'sys/grtermio.c'
==> Applying patch-grfileio.c.diff
patching file 'sys/grfileio.c'
==> sw_vers -productVersion
==> ../makemake .. darwin
==> make
Last 15 lines from /Users/alex/Library/Logs/Homebrew/pgplot/03.make:
gfortran -c -ffixed-line-length-none -fallow-argument-mismatch ../sys/grtrml.f
gfortran -c -ffixed-line-length-none -fallow-argument-mismatch ../sys/grtter.f
clang -c -DPG_PPU -I. ../sys/gruser.c
ar ru libpgplot.a \
		`ls pgarro.o pgask.o  pgaxis.o pgaxlg.o pgband.o pgbbuf.o pgbeg.o  pgbin.o  pgbox.o  pgbox1.o pgcirc.o pgcl.o   pgclos.o pgcn01.o pgcnsc.o pgconb.o pgconf.o pgconl.o pgcons.o pgcont.o pgconx.o pgcp.o   pgctab.o pgcurs.o pgdraw.o pgebuf.o pgend.o  pgenv.o  pgeras.o pgerr1.o pgerrb.o pgerrx.o pgerry.o pgetxt.o pgfunt.o pgfunx.o pgfuny.o pggray.o pghi2d.o pghis1.o pghist.o pghtch.o pgiden.o pgimag.o pginit.o pglab.o  pglcur.o pgldev.o pglen.o  pgline.o pgmove.o pgmtxt.o pgncur.o pgnoto.o pgnpl.o  pgnumb.o pgolin.o pgopen.o pgpage.o pgpanl.o pgpap.o  pgpixl.o pgpnts.o pgpoly.o pgpt.o   pgpt1.o  pgptxt.o pgqah.o  pgqcf.o  pgqch.o  pgqci.o  pgqcir.o pgqclp.o pgqcol.o pgqcr.o  pgqcs.o  pgqdt.o  pgqfs.o  pgqhs.o  pgqid.o  pgqinf.o pgqitf.o pgqls.o  pgqlw.o  pgqndt.o pgqpos.o pgqtbg.o pgqtxt.o pgqvp.o  pgqvsz.o pgqwin.o pgrect.o pgrnd.o  pgrnge.o pgsah.o  pgsave.o pgscf.o  pgsch.o  pgsci.o  pgscir.o pgsclp.o pgscr.o  pgscrl.o pgscrn.o pgsfs.o  pgshls.o pgshs.o  pgsitf.o pgslct.o pgsls.o  pgslw.o  pgstbg.o pgsubp.o pgsvp.o  pgswin.o pgtbox.o pgtext.o pgtick.o pgtikl.o pgupdt.o pgvect.o pgvsiz.o pgvstd.o pgvw.o   pgwedg.o pgwnad.o \
		pgadvance.o pgbegin.o   pgcurse.o   pglabel.o   pgmtext.o   pgncurse.o  pgpaper.o   pgpoint.o   pgptext.o   pgvport.o   pgvsize.o   pgvstand.o  pgwindow.o  grarea.o grbpic.o grchsz.o grclip.o grclos.o grclpl.o grctoi.o grcurs.o grdot0.o grdot1.o grdtyp.o gresc.o  grepic.o gretxt.o grfa.o   grfao.o  grgfil.o grgray.o grimg0.o grimg1.o grimg2.o grimg3.o grinit.o gritoc.o grlen.o  grlin0.o grlin1.o grlin2.o grlin3.o grlina.o grmcur.o grmker.o grmova.o grmsg.o gropen.o grpage.o grpars.o grpixl.o grpocl.o grprom.o grpxpo.o grpxps.o grpxpx.o grpxre.o grqcap.o grqci.o  grqcol.o grqcr.o  grqdev.o grqdt.o  grqfnt.o grqls.o  grqlw.o  grqpos.o grqtxt.o grqtyp.o grquit.o grrec0.o grrect.o grsci.o  grscr.o  grscrl.o grsetc.o grsets.o grsfnt.o grsize.o grskpb.o grslct.o grsls.o  grslw.o  grsyds.o grsymk.o grsyxd.o grterm.o grtext.o grtoup.o grtrim.o grtrn0.o grtxy0.o grvct0.o grwarn.o grxhls.o grxrgb.o grexec.o \
		gidriv.o lxdriv.o nudriv.o pndriv.o psdriv.o xwdriv.o  grdate.o grfileio.o grflun.o grgcom.o grgenv.o grgetc.o grglun.o grgmem.o grgmsg.o grlgtr.o groptx.o grsy00.o grtermio.o grtrml.o grtter.o gruser.o | sort | uniq`
ar: creating archive libpgplot.a
/usr/bin/ranlib libpgplot.a
gfortran -dynamiclib -single_module  -lX11 -install_name libpgplot.dylib -o libpgplot.dylib `ls pgarro.o pgask.o  pgaxis.o pgaxlg.o pgband.o pgbbuf.o pgbeg.o  pgbin.o  pgbox.o  pgbox1.o pgcirc.o pgcl.o   pgclos.o pgcn01.o pgcnsc.o pgconb.o pgconf.o pgconl.o pgcons.o pgcont.o pgconx.o pgcp.o   pgctab.o pgcurs.o pgdraw.o pgebuf.o pgend.o  pgenv.o  pgeras.o pgerr1.o pgerrb.o pgerrx.o pgerry.o pgetxt.o pgfunt.o pgfunx.o pgfuny.o pggray.o pghi2d.o pghis1.o pghist.o pghtch.o pgiden.o pgimag.o pginit.o pglab.o  pglcur.o pgldev.o pglen.o  pgline.o pgmove.o pgmtxt.o pgncur.o pgnoto.o pgnpl.o  pgnumb.o pgolin.o pgopen.o pgpage.o pgpanl.o pgpap.o  pgpixl.o pgpnts.o pgpoly.o pgpt.o   pgpt1.o  pgptxt.o pgqah.o  pgqcf.o  pgqch.o  pgqci.o  pgqcir.o pgqclp.o pgqcol.o pgqcr.o  pgqcs.o  pgqdt.o  pgqfs.o  pgqhs.o  pgqid.o  pgqinf.o pgqitf.o pgqls.o  pgqlw.o  pgqndt.o pgqpos.o pgqtbg.o pgqtxt.o pgqvp.o  pgqvsz.o pgqwin.o pgrect.o pgrnd.o  pgrnge.o pgsah.o  pgsave.o pgscf.o  pgsch.o  pgsci.o  pgscir.o pgsclp.o pgscr.o  pgscrl.o pgscrn.o pgsfs.o  pgshls.o pgshs.o  pgsitf.o pgslct.o pgsls.o  pgslw.o  pgstbg.o pgsubp.o pgsvp.o  pgswin.o pgtbox.o pgtext.o pgtick.o pgtikl.o pgupdt.o pgvect.o pgvsiz.o pgvstd.o pgvw.o   pgwedg.o pgwnad.o \
	pgadvance.o pgbegin.o   pgcurse.o   pglabel.o   pgmtext.o   pgncurse.o  pgpaper.o   pgpoint.o   pgptext.o   pgvport.o   pgvsize.o   pgvstand.o  pgwindow.o  grarea.o grbpic.o grchsz.o grclip.o grclos.o grclpl.o grctoi.o grcurs.o grdot0.o grdot1.o grdtyp.o gresc.o  grepic.o gretxt.o grfa.o   grfao.o  grgfil.o grgray.o grimg0.o grimg1.o grimg2.o grimg3.o grinit.o gritoc.o grlen.o  grlin0.o grlin1.o grlin2.o grlin3.o grlina.o grmcur.o grmker.o grmova.o grmsg.o gropen.o grpage.o grpars.o grpixl.o grpocl.o grprom.o grpxpo.o grpxps.o grpxpx.o grpxre.o grqcap.o grqci.o  grqcol.o grqcr.o  grqdev.o grqdt.o  grqfnt.o grqls.o  grqlw.o  grqpos.o grqtxt.o grqtyp.o grquit.o grrec0.o grrect.o grsci.o  grscr.o  grscrl.o grsetc.o grsets.o grsfnt.o grsize.o grskpb.o grslct.o grsls.o  grslw.o  grsyds.o grsymk.o grsyxd.o grterm.o grtext.o grtoup.o grtrim.o grtrn0.o grtxy0.o grvct0.o grwarn.o grxhls.o grxrgb.o grexec.o \
	gidriv.o lxdriv.o nudriv.o pndriv.o psdriv.o xwdriv.o  grdate.o grfileio.o grflun.o grgcom.o grgenv.o grgetc.o grglun.o grgmem.o grgmsg.o grlgtr.o groptx.o grsy00.o grtermio.o grtrml.o grtter.o gruser.o | sort | uniq` -lpng -lX11
ld: library not found for -lX11
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
make: *** [libpgplot.dylib] Error 1

If reporting this issue please do so at (not Homebrew/brew or Homebrew/homebrew-core):
  https://github.com/kazuakiyama/homebrew-pgplot/issues

These open issues may also help:
Segmentation fault during make of pgplot https://github.com/kazuakiyama/homebrew-pgplot/issues/3

[kazuakiyama]

Hello, very sorry that my response is extremely late. I was very busy in the last few months for other commitments (also I'm no longer an active user of pgplot).

I'm using Intel Mac with Sonoma 14.2.1 or earlier versions but I haven't seen this problem in my own local enviroment. Can you go to /usr/local/homebrew/lib and see if there is libX11.a or libX11.dylib? I want to make sure the library files installed by libx11 are there.