You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
There are two kinds of characters transformations in lead-ons/ carry-ons in Plotto.
You can find both kinds on the lead-ons of clause 1310.
One is of the form "647 ch A-5 to A", where character A-5 on 647 is switched with A. (A-5 > A)
The other kind, as in the last lead-on, is of the form "818a tr A & A-4" where character A is transposed with character A-4, that is, A is switched with A-4 and A-4 is switched with A. (A-4 <> A)
On the Plotto XML both are tagged the same. That is, the latter contains only <transform from="A" to="A-4"></transform>
for the transformation.
As I see it, either the transpositions should have a special tag, such as <transpose between="A" and="A-4"></transpose>
OR
two tags should be used to reflect the bidirectionality
Oh man, this is a good catch. I don't know how I missed the difference between tr and ch. I would propose that transform be replaced with either change or transpose, reflecting the original's language. Unfortunately, I don't seem to have the original script that I used to parse the HTML from https://github.com/garykac/plotto/blob/gh-pages/plotto-mf.html. One would need to write a script to compare both files and make the appropriate changes to the XML.
There are two kinds of characters transformations in lead-ons/ carry-ons in Plotto.
You can find both kinds on the lead-ons of clause 1310.
One is of the form "647 ch A-5 to A", where character A-5 on 647 is switched with A. (A-5 > A)
The other kind, as in the last lead-on, is of the form "818a tr A & A-4" where character A is transposed with character A-4, that is, A is switched with A-4 and A-4 is switched with A. (A-4 <> A)
On the Plotto XML both are tagged the same. That is, the latter contains only
<transform from="A" to="A-4"></transform>
for the transformation.
As I see it, either the transpositions should have a special tag, such as
<transpose between="A" and="A-4"></transpose>
OR
two tags should be used to reflect the bidirectionality
(Otherwise great encoding!)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: