Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Incorrect 'meaning' in GenericDSL message/variables #22

Open
jchmielewska opened this issue Sep 3, 2024 · 1 comment
Open

Incorrect 'meaning' in GenericDSL message/variables #22

jchmielewska opened this issue Sep 3, 2024 · 1 comment
Assignees
Labels
question Further information is requested

Comments

@jchmielewska
Copy link

jchmielewska commented Sep 3, 2024

That's a part of message I'm receiving from GUI on generic.DSL topic:

claimName: minio-pvc, variables=[{key=spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.cpu, path=/spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.cpu, type=float, meaning=spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.cpu, value={lower_bound=2, higher_bound=8}}, {key=spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.storage, path=/spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.storage, type=float, meaning=spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.storage, value={lower_bound=10, higher_bound=16}}], resources=[{_id=clrhjsa6j000r0oynb8776rc1, metaType=arrayItem, scopedArrayName=doc.application.resources, uuid=9e6644b6-cb58-4fc5-b5cf-bf7a571d92fe, title=AWs my resource, platform=aws, enabled=true, _docId=clrhjsa6k00170oyn4hghaauk:en:published, _edit=true}], templates=[{_id=cltcwpi2l004t2e5z3kn4isg4, metaType=arrayItem, scopedArrayName=doc.application.templates, id=myid, type=int, minValue=2, maxValue=4, unit=ms, _docId=clrhjsa6k00170oyn4hghaauk:en:published, _edit=true}], parameters=[], metrics=[{_id=clrhjsa6j000s0oyncf9za40p, metaType=arrayItem, scopedArrayName=doc.application.metrics, type=composite, level=Global, components=[], name=cars_by_second, formula=number_of_cars_discovered / total_number_of_cars, isWindowInput=true, input={_id=clrhjsa6j000t0oyngrl8a83d, type=all, interval=0, unit=ms, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.input}, isWindowOutput=true, output={_id=clrhjsa6j000u0oyn8enn9mbk, type=all, interval=0, unit=ms, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.output}, sensor=, config=[], isWindowInputRaw=false, inputRaw={_id=cltcwla8n001b0lv64v0e49jz, type=null, interval=null, unit=null, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.inputRaw}, isWindowOutputRaw=false, outputRaw={_id=clrhjsa6j000v0oyn0waq09do, type=null, interval=null, unit=null, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.outputRaw}, _docId=clrhjsa6k00170oyn4hghaauk:en:published, _edit=true, arguments=[number_of_cars_discovered, total_number_of_cars]}, {_id=clrhjsa6j000w0oyn23sychyv, metaType=arrayItem, scopedArrayName=doc.application.metrics, type=raw, level=Global, components=[], name=latency, formula=, isWindowInput=false, input={_id=clrhjsa6j000x0oyn8xb78mv4, type=null, interval=null, unit=null, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.input}, isWindowOutput=false, output={_id=clrhjsa6j000y0oyn0f94aiov, type=all, interval=0, unit=ms, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.output}, sensor=latency_discovery, config=[{_id=clrhjsa6j000z0oyn0czm7k3e, metaType=arrayItem, scopedArrayName=doc.application.config, name=buffer, value=10, _docId=clrhjsa6k00170oyn4hghaauk:en:published, _edit=true}], isWindowInputRaw=false, inputRaw={_id=cltcwla8n001c0lv6gj4r6rwb, type=null, interval=null, unit=null, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.inputRaw}, isWindowOutputRaw=true, outputRaw={_id=clrhjsa6j00100oynhyhs9rdf, type=all, interval=3, unit=ms, metaType=object, scopedObjectName=doc.application.outputRaw}, _docId=clrhjsa6k00170oyn4hghaauk:en:published, _edit=true}], sloViolations={nodeKey=d760437d-81cd-4675-9e40-e8d0ea4b9b4d, isComposite=true, condition=OR, not=false, children=[{nodeKey=b50b961b-6e9a-4f90-842c-e92fbab43f40, isComposite=false, metricName=latency, operator=>, value=10}, {nodeKey=7a91f324-7094-4536-a9b5-1eece0f19d66, isComposite=false, metricName=cars_by_second, operator=<=, value=50}]}, utilityFunctions=[{name=Utility Function 1, type=maximize, expression={formula=A * B + SIN(C), variables=[{name=A, value=cars_by_second}, {name=B, value=spec.components.properties.objects.spec.resources.requests.cpu}, {name=C, value=latency}]}}, {name=Utility Function B, type=constant, expression={formula=D /100, variables=[{name=D, value=Utility_Function_1}]}}], environmentVariables=[], status=deploying, _create=true, _delete=true}

The problem is with variables/meaning field. It is now the same as the key of the variable while it should contain the real meaning of the variable.
As it was agreed during the hackathon, it is expected to have the meaning as one of these values "cpu|ram|storage|replicas". It is enough if you just put the suffix of the variable name.

Reported by Marta and moved from Launchpad https://bugs.launchpad.net/nebulous/+bug/2058251

@jchmielewska jchmielewska added the bug Something isn't working label Sep 3, 2024
@jchmielewska
Copy link
Author

Need a confirmation if this is still an issue.

@vkefalas-exz vkefalas-exz added documentation Improvements or additions to documentation question Further information is requested and removed bug Something isn't working documentation Improvements or additions to documentation labels Sep 27, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
question Further information is requested
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants