Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

The RD points on Kodak #5

Open
tangzhisen opened this issue Jun 20, 2022 · 4 comments
Open

The RD points on Kodak #5

tangzhisen opened this issue Jun 20, 2022 · 4 comments

Comments

@tangzhisen
Copy link

Thanks for sharing the code! If possible, could you provide the RD points (the value of x and y axis) on Kodak dataset? (Preferably at least 4 RD points.) I would like to compare these results with the RD performance of my algorithm.

@mx54039q
Copy link
Collaborator

As models are released, you can test them on Kodak dataset.
Here is the result tested on our device,
bpp_entroformer = np.array([0.0866,0.1452,0.2632,0.4058,0.5925,0.9313,1.2559,1.6738,1.9657])
psnr_entroformer = np.array([27.63,29.16,31.38,33.18,35.13,37.72,39.68,41.57,42.70])

@tangzhisen
Copy link
Author

As models are released, you can test them on Kodak dataset. Here is the result tested on our device, bpp_entroformer = np.array([0.0866,0.1452,0.2632,0.4058,0.5925,0.9313,1.2559,1.6738,1.9657]) psnr_entroformer = np.array([27.63,29.16,31.38,33.18,35.13,37.72,39.68,41.57,42.70])

Thank you for your reply!However, the pre-trained models you released are optimized by MSE, can you provide rate-distortion points optimized by ms-ssim?That is, the rate-distortion results of Figure 12 in your paper.

@mx54039q
Copy link
Collaborator

mx54039q commented Jul 4, 2022

As models are released, you can test them on Kodak dataset. Here is the result tested on our device, bpp_entroformer = np.array([0.0866,0.1452,0.2632,0.4058,0.5925,0.9313,1.2559,1.6738,1.9657]) psnr_entroformer = np.array([27.63,29.16,31.38,33.18,35.13,37.72,39.68,41.57,42.70])

Thank you for your reply!However, the pre-trained models you released are optimized by MSE, can you provide rate-distortion points optimized by ms-ssim?That is, the rate-distortion results of Figure 12 in your paper.

The results optimized by MS-SSIM,
bpp_entroformer = np.array([0.1017,0.1572, 0.1975, 0.2288, 0.3286, 0.4701, 0.6686,0.9211,1.2701,1.7122, 2.0283])
msssim_entroformer = np.array([0.94454,0.96267,0.97046,0.97500,0.98306,0.98875,0.99265,0.99522,0.99694,0.99807,0.99854])

@TNTWEN
Copy link

TNTWEN commented Oct 28, 2023

@mx54039q 你好,请问可以提供一下论文中parallel模型的PSNR和MS-SSIM的RD points 数据嘛,您提供的parallel模型只有四个而且是MSE优化的。 感谢感谢!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants