Request to review calculated rating for Doom Eternal

[tuxayo]

I'm not sure to have understood the rating system well enough to have a valuable opinion.

Can you confirm that the gold rating is consistent with the reports?

https://www.protondb.com/app/782330

Doom Eternal works for a lot of people at the expense of

• using a custom proton build
• using run flags

For a sizable number of others:

• can't run with ACO
• can't run with HDR
• huge performance issues

More info: huge issue thread in Proton's repo:
ValveSoftware/Proton#3654

At the same time, gold might make sense or it's too positive.

So it don't know, which result should make more sense, your call to confirm :)

Any, still way better than the old system, thanks for your work.

[bdefore]

a new rating summary is under development that will give distinct ratings for tinker vs non-tinker. unfortunately for now, doom eternal represents an obvious example of why the current medal system is unhelpful

[CatalinPuscoci]

Keep in mind that for the moment AMD users have great performance with specific driver providers/proton builds, while nvidia users are doomed to use system memory and can not use too much VRAM until nvidia patches it.

I would imagine it being useful to show different scores for different graphics card vendors if it's the case.

Edit 2020-04-02: This has been fixed in the latest driver, coming soon(tm) to your repos, thanks @monban

[monban]

@CatalinPuscoci, This has been corrected as of the latest nVidia drivers

Fixes:

Added a workaround for Linux Steam Play title DOOM Eternal, which overrides application requested memory locations, to ensure performance-critical resources be placed in video memory [Linux]