Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Design Municipal Page #29

Closed
6 tasks done
theryankelly opened this issue Feb 3, 2021 · 8 comments
Closed
6 tasks done

Design Municipal Page #29

theryankelly opened this issue Feb 3, 2021 · 8 comments
Labels
design enhancement New feature or request

Comments

@theryankelly
Copy link

theryankelly commented Feb 3, 2021

This is a page that will allow a user to explore the submarkets that are within their municipality. Called "Find a Community" in Chicago site I think we may want to call "Explore".

Questions:

  • Name for page (/municipalities)
  • Need to decide if this is a full-page map and how it differed from the home page in layout. (not full)
  • Only municipalities groupings? (yes)
  • Tooltip to include % subregion in muni (no)
  • % bar in tooltip? (no)
  • What site copy do we want to include on this page?(policy embed)

Very drafty example:
image

@theryankelly theryankelly added the enhancement New feature or request label Feb 3, 2021
@theryankelly
Copy link
Author

Switch menu to differentiate
image

@theryankelly
Copy link
Author

Was trying to think of another layout that did not conflict with home page and still allowed the user to find their community and submarket within. What about a much more contained map. Still with zoom click options, but one that drives primarily by search? This mockup doesn't currently communicate/display the input or overlay factors for a community/submarkets in a community.

image

@atomtay
Copy link
Contributor

atomtay commented Feb 10, 2021

I really like having a different template than the homepage---I think it'll make it clearer to the user which page does what. The one concern I'm still thinking through, though, is how to connect the geocoder to the bottom lefthand "results" panel. It would work great if the user searches for "Boston" or "Acton," but we don't currently have data identified for individual neighborhoods (if the user searches for "Roxbury" or "Coolidge Corner", or maybe even their particular address). I see two potential solutions to this:

  1. Instead of using Mapbox's geocoder, create and use our own search feature limited to the 101 municipalities (like we have for the Zoning Atlas municipality filter)
  2. If possible, determine the municipality from the Mapbox search ("Boston" for "Roxbury," "Brookline" for "Coolidge Corner") and return those results.

I'm somewhat more partial to the first option, as it restricts possible inputs to our available outputs. In that case, I'd re-title the page "Municipal Search" to make clear that this is a very particular definition of "community" that we're searching by.

Tagging @Kit-Un as well to see her thoughts

@atomtay
Copy link
Contributor

atomtay commented Feb 10, 2021

I was able to combine these approaches and use the Mapbox geocoder (#19), filtered to the 101 municipalities in the region:
Screen Shot 2021-02-10 at 1 31 02 PM

Adding the second half (X% of municipality in submarket 2, Y% in submarket 4, Z% in submarket 7) relies on having the municipalities included in the tract data, from issue #28.

@atomtay
Copy link
Contributor

atomtay commented Feb 16, 2021

Screen Shot 2021-02-16 at 10 38 56 AM

Page is up live with the lattermost design, tweaked slightly. Current answers to the above questions:

Name for page Municipalities (I like "Explore" but it's pretty vague, and this is very specifically a search-by-municipality page/doesn't have any more specific search functionality, like neighborhood or subregion)
Need to decide if this is a full-page map and how it differed from the home page in layout. Not full-page, display side-by-side with bar chart
Only municipalities groupings? Yes
Tooltip to include % subregion in muni/% bar in tooltip No, tooltip only includes count; percent displayed below
What site copy do we want to include on this page? Minimal copy; municipal result shows short description of each included submarket

@theryankelly
Copy link
Author

theryankelly commented Feb 18, 2021

Notes/Tasks from 2/17/2020 Meeting

  • Going with Municipalities for page name
  • Change calculation of %. Use housing units as the denominator, land area a secondary option. The third option if time does not allow is to keep as is with denominator as the number of tracts.
  • Need to add label to bar chart
  • Additional site copy with an embed of policies. Need to decide if we are using airtable views to creating muni dependant variables.

@theryankelly
Copy link
Author

Interesting search issue if I search for "North" I don't get any pre-population until I start on second work "Reading". Might be true for munis with space in the name.
image
image

@theryankelly
Copy link
Author

Closing this issue as the page is up as will be for launch. Have created a new issue for the word break issue #41

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
design enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants