From 6f0ccf89ad9cb6860086742bcf45f09f48294c07 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Barry Trager Date: Thu, 5 Dec 2024 13:17:38 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] removed unneeded almost ex_series assumptions --- coq/QLearn/Tsitsiklis.v | 84 ++++++++++++- coq/QLearn/jaakkola_vector.v | 220 ++++++++++++++++++----------------- 2 files changed, 193 insertions(+), 111 deletions(-) diff --git a/coq/QLearn/Tsitsiklis.v b/coq/QLearn/Tsitsiklis.v index 33414f30..b9613765 100644 --- a/coq/QLearn/Tsitsiklis.v +++ b/coq/QLearn/Tsitsiklis.v @@ -1005,8 +1005,75 @@ Lemma is_lim_seq'_uniform_is_lim_almost (u : nat -> Ts -> R) (l : Ts -> R) : is_lim_seq'_uniform_almost u l -> almost prts (fun x => is_lim_seq (fun n => u n x) (l x)). Proof. - Admitted. + unfold is_lim_seq'_uniform_almost. + intros. + assert (forall eps : posreal, + almost prts (fun (x : Ts) => eventually (fun n => + (rvabs (rvminus (u n) l) x) < eps))). + { + intros. + specialize (H eps). + unfold const in H. + apply almost_eventually. + revert H. + apply eventually_impl. + apply all_eventually; intros ?. + apply almost_impl. + now apply all_almost; intros ??. + } + assert (forall N, + almost prts (fun x : Ts => eventually (fun n : nat => rvabs (rvminus (u n) l) x < / INR (S N)))). + { + intros. + assert (0 < / INR (S N)). + { + apply Rinv_0_lt_compat. + apply lt_0_INR. + lia. + } + now specialize (H0 (mkposreal _ H1)). + } + apply almost_forall in H1. + revert H1; apply almost_impl. + apply all_almost; intros ??. + apply is_lim_seq_spec. + intros ?. + assert (exists N, + / INR (S N) < eps). + { + generalize (archimed_cor1 eps (cond_pos eps)); intros. + destruct H2 as [N [??]]. + exists (N-1)%nat. + now replace (S (N - 1)) with N by lia. + } + destruct H2 as [N ?]. + specialize (H1 N). + revert H1. + apply eventually_impl. + apply all_eventually. + intros. + eapply Rlt_trans; cycle 1. + apply H2. + unfold rvabs, rvminus, rvplus, rvopp, rvscale in H1. + eapply Rle_lt_trans; cycle 1. + apply H1. + right. + f_equal. + lra. +Qed. +Lemma is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost (u : nat -> Ts -> R) (l : Ts -> R) : + is_lim_seq'_uniform_almost (fun n ω => sum_n (fun n0 => u n0 ω) n) l -> + almost prts (fun x => ex_series (fun n => u n x)). +Proof. + intros. + apply is_lim_seq'_uniform_is_lim_almost in H. + revert H. + apply almost_impl. + apply all_almost; intros ??. + exists (l x). + now rewrite series_seq. +Qed. Lemma uniform_lim_all_almost (u : nat -> Ts -> R) (l : Ts -> R) : is_lim_seq'_uniform_fun u l -> @@ -1177,14 +1244,16 @@ Proof. Qed. Lemma uniform_converge_sum_sq_tails (α : nat -> Ts -> R) : - almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω)) -> let A := fun ω => Lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω)) in - is_lim_seq'_uniform_almost (fun n ω => sum_n (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω) n) A -> forall (eps : posreal), eventually (fun n => almostR2 prts Rbar_le (fun ω : Ts => Lim_seq (sum_n (fun n0 : nat => (α (S n + n0)%nat ω)²))) (const eps)). Proof. - intros ex_ser A uniform eps. + intros A uniform eps. + assert (ex_ser : almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω))). + { + now apply is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost with (l := A). + } specialize (uniform eps). revert uniform. apply eventually_impl. @@ -1248,13 +1317,16 @@ Proof. Qed. Lemma uniform_converge_series_sum_sq_tails (α : nat -> Ts -> R) : - almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω)) -> let A := fun ω => Series (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω) in is_lim_seq'_uniform_almost (fun n ω => sum_n (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω) n) A -> forall (eps : posreal), eventually (fun n => almostR2 prts Rle (fun ω : Ts => Series (fun n0 : nat => (α (S n + n0)%nat ω)²)) (const eps)). Proof. - intros ex_ser A uniform eps. + intros A uniform eps. + assert (ex_ser : almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun k => rvsqr (α k) ω))). + { + now apply is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost with (l := A). + } specialize (uniform eps). revert uniform. apply eventually_impl. diff --git a/coq/QLearn/jaakkola_vector.v b/coq/QLearn/jaakkola_vector.v index 3d043b4b..dda73a46 100644 --- a/coq/QLearn/jaakkola_vector.v +++ b/coq/QLearn/jaakkola_vector.v @@ -5168,8 +5168,7 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. almost prts (fun ω => forall i pf, is_lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => vector_nth i pf (α k ω))) p_infty) -> almost prts (fun ω => forall i pf, is_lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => vector_nth i pf (β k ω))) p_infty) -> - (forall i pf, almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun n => Rsqr (vector_nth i pf (α n ω))))) -> - (forall i pf, almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun n => Rsqr (vector_nth i pf (β n ω))))) -> + (almost prts (fun ω => forall k i pf, @@ -5211,21 +5210,21 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. - intros. apply lt_dec. - intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H13. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H11. } - destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H13 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H8 i pf))). + destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H11 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H6 i pf))). exists x. - apply H14. + apply H12. } - apply eventually_bounded_forall in H13. - revert H13. + apply eventually_bounded_forall in H11. + revert H11. apply eventually_impl. apply all_eventually; intros. apply almost_bounded_forall. + intros; apply lt_dec. + intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H14. - + apply H13. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H12. + + apply H11. - assert (forall i pf, eventually (fun n => almostR2 prts Rle (vecrvnth i pf (β n)) (const 1))). { @@ -5239,21 +5238,27 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. - intros. apply lt_dec. - intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H13. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H11. } - destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H13 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H9 i pf))). + destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H11 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H7 i pf))). exists x. - apply H14. + apply H12. } - apply eventually_bounded_forall in H13. - revert H13. + apply eventually_bounded_forall in H11. + revert H11. apply eventually_impl. apply all_eventually; intros. apply almost_bounded_forall. + intros; apply lt_dec. + intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H14. - + apply H13. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H12. + + apply H11. + - intros. + eapply is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost. + apply H6. + - intros. + eapply is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost. + apply H7. - assert (forall i pf, exists epsilon : posreal, eventually @@ -5265,28 +5270,28 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. (fun x : Ts => const epsilon x))). { intros. - specialize (H9 i pf). - generalize (uniform_converge_sum_sq_tails _ (H6 i pf)); intros. + specialize (H7 i pf). + generalize (uniform_converge_sum_sq_tails _ H7); intros. assert (0 < 2) by lra. - exists (mkposreal _ H14). + exists (mkposreal _ H12). assert (0 < 1) by lra. - simpl in H13. - specialize (H13 H9 (mkposreal _ H15)). - destruct H13. + simpl in H11. + specialize (H11 (mkposreal _ H13)). + destruct H11. exists (S x). intros. - specialize (H13 (n-1)%nat). - cut_to H13; try lia. - revert H13. + specialize (H11 (n-1)%nat). + cut_to H11; try lia. + revert H11. apply almost_impl. apply all_almost; intros ??. simpl. - simpl in H13. + simpl in H11. assert (Rbar_lt 1 2) by (simpl; lra). eapply Rbar_le_lt_trans; cycle 1. - apply H17. + apply H15. eapply Rbar_le_trans; cycle 1. - apply H13. + apply H11. apply slln.eq_Rbar_le. apply Lim_seq_ext; intros. apply sum_n_ext; intros. @@ -5304,8 +5309,8 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. Lim_seq (sum_n (fun nn : nat => rvsqr (vecrvnth i pf (β (nn + n)%nat)) ω))) (fun x : Ts => const eps x)))); intros. - cut_to H14; trivial. - destruct H14. + cut_to H12; trivial. + destruct H12. pose (eps := Rvector_max_abs (vector_map pos x)). assert (0 < eps). { @@ -5316,20 +5321,21 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. eapply Rlt_le_trans; try eapply leq. destruct ((vector_nth 0 (Nat.lt_0_succ N) x)); simpl in *. rewrite Rabs_right; lra. - } - exists (mkposreal _ H15). - apply eventually_bounded_forall in H14. - revert H14. + } + + exists (mkposreal _ H13). + apply eventually_bounded_forall in H12. + revert H12. apply eventually_impl; apply all_eventually; intros ? HH ??. specialize (HH i pf). revert HH. apply almost_impl; apply all_almost; intros ??. eapply Rbar_lt_le_trans. - apply H14. + apply H12. unfold const, eps; simpl. generalize (Rvector_max_abs_nth_le (vector_map pos x) i pf); intros. eapply Rle_trans; cycle 1. - apply H16. + apply H14. rewrite vector_nth_map. apply Rle_abs. Qed. @@ -5927,8 +5933,7 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. almost prts (fun ω => forall i pf, is_lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => vector_nth i pf (α k ω))) p_infty) -> almost prts (fun ω => forall i pf, is_lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => vector_nth i pf (β k ω))) p_infty) -> - (forall i pf, almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun n => Rsqr (vector_nth i pf (α n ω))))) -> - (forall i pf, almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun n => Rsqr (vector_nth i pf (β n ω))))) -> + (almost prts (fun ω => forall k i pf, @@ -5967,21 +5972,21 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. - intros. apply lt_dec. - intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H12. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H10. } - destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H12 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H8 i pf))). + destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H10 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H6 i pf))). exists x. - apply H13. + apply H11. } - apply eventually_bounded_forall in H12. - revert H12. + apply eventually_bounded_forall in H10. + revert H10. apply eventually_impl. apply all_eventually; intros. apply almost_bounded_forall. + intros; apply lt_dec. + intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H13. - + apply H12. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H11. + + apply H10. - assert (forall i pf, eventually (fun n => almostR2 prts Rle (vecrvnth i pf (β n)) (const 1))). { @@ -5995,21 +6000,27 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. - intros. apply lt_dec. - intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H12. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H10. } - destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H12 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H9 i pf))). + destruct ( uniform_converge_sq _ H10 ( uniform_converge_sum_sq _ (H7 i pf))). exists x. - apply H13. + apply H11. } - apply eventually_bounded_forall in H12. - revert H12. + apply eventually_bounded_forall in H10. + revert H10. apply eventually_impl. apply all_eventually; intros. apply almost_bounded_forall. + intros; apply lt_dec. + intros. - erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H13. - + apply H12. + erewrite vector_nth_ext; try apply H11. + + apply H10. + - intros. + eapply is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost. + apply H6. + - intros. + eapply is_lim_seq'_uniform_ex_series_almost. + apply H7. - assert (forall i pf, exists epsilon : posreal, eventually @@ -6021,28 +6032,28 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. (fun x : Ts => const epsilon x))). { intros. - specialize (H9 i pf). - generalize (uniform_converge_sum_sq_tails _ (H6 i pf)); intros. + specialize (H7 i pf). + generalize (uniform_converge_sum_sq_tails _ H7); intros. assert (0 < 2) by lra. - exists (mkposreal _ H13). + exists (mkposreal _ H11). assert (0 < 1) by lra. - simpl in H12. - specialize (H12 H9 (mkposreal _ H14)). - destruct H12. + simpl in H10. + specialize (H10 (mkposreal _ H12)). + destruct H10. exists (S x). intros. - specialize (H12 (n-1)%nat). - cut_to H12; try lia. - revert H12. + specialize (H10 (n-1)%nat). + cut_to H10; try lia. + revert H10. apply almost_impl. apply all_almost; intros ??. simpl. - simpl in H12. + simpl in H10. assert (Rbar_lt 1 2) by (simpl; lra). eapply Rbar_le_lt_trans; cycle 1. - apply H16. + apply H14. eapply Rbar_le_trans; cycle 1. - apply H12. + apply H10. apply slln.eq_Rbar_le. apply Lim_seq_ext; intros. apply sum_n_ext; intros. @@ -6060,8 +6071,8 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. Lim_seq (sum_n (fun nn : nat => rvsqr (vecrvnth i pf (β (nn + n)%nat)) ω))) (fun x : Ts => const eps x)))); intros. - cut_to H13; trivial. - destruct H13. + cut_to H11; trivial. + destruct H11. pose (eps := Rvector_max_abs (vector_map pos x)). assert (0 < eps). { @@ -6073,19 +6084,19 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. destruct ((vector_nth 0 (Nat.lt_0_succ N) x)); simpl in *. rewrite Rabs_right; lra. } - exists (mkposreal _ H14). - apply eventually_bounded_forall in H13. - revert H13. + exists (mkposreal _ H12). + apply eventually_bounded_forall in H11. + revert H11. apply eventually_impl; apply all_eventually; intros ? HH ??. specialize (HH i pf). revert HH. apply almost_impl; apply all_almost; intros ??. eapply Rbar_lt_le_trans. - apply H13. + apply H11. unfold const, eps; simpl. generalize (Rvector_max_abs_nth_le (vector_map pos x) i pf); intros. eapply Rle_trans; cycle 1. - apply H15. + apply H13. rewrite vector_nth_map. apply Rle_abs. Qed. @@ -6440,8 +6451,7 @@ Section jaakola_vector2. almost prts (fun ω => forall i pf, is_lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => vector_nth i pf (α k ω))) p_infty) -> almost prts (fun ω => forall i pf, is_lim_seq (sum_n (fun k => vector_nth i pf (β k ω))) p_infty) -> - (forall i pf, almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun n => Rsqr (vector_nth i pf (α n ω))))) -> - (forall i pf, almost prts (fun ω => ex_series (fun n => Rsqr (vector_nth i pf (β n ω))))) -> + almost prts (fun ω => (forall k, @@ -6473,7 +6483,7 @@ Proof. { intros. destruct (isfe_L2_variance prts (filt_sub k) (vecrvnth i pf (XF k)) _) as [?[?[?[?]]]]. - revert H15. + revert H13. apply IsFiniteExpectation_proper. intros ?. unfold rvsqr, rvminus, rvplus, rvopp,rvscale, vecrvnth. @@ -6519,7 +6529,7 @@ Proof. apply IsFiniteExpectation_scale. apply isfe. } - revert H13. + revert H11. apply IsFiniteExpectation_proper. intros ?. unfold vecrvnth. @@ -6552,7 +6562,7 @@ Proof. (rvsqr (rvminus (vecrvnth i pf (fun ω : Ts => pos_Rvector_mult (XF k ω) W)) (FiniteConditionalExpectation prts (filt_sub k) - (vecrvnth i pf (fun ω : Ts => pos_Rvector_mult (XF k ω) W)))))) in H13; trivial. + (vecrvnth i pf (fun ω : Ts => pos_Rvector_mult (XF k ω) W)))))) in H11; trivial. - apply rvscale_rv. apply rvsqr_rv. apply rvminus_rv. @@ -6567,9 +6577,9 @@ Proof. + apply (RandomVariable_sa_sub (filt_sub k)). apply FiniteCondexp_rv. - generalize (FiniteCondexp_scale prts (filt_sub k) (vector_nth i pf W) ); intros. - specialize (H14 _ _ (isfe k i pf)). - apply almost_prob_space_sa_sub_lift in H14. - revert H14; apply almost_impl. + specialize (H12 _ _ (isfe k i pf)). + apply almost_prob_space_sa_sub_lift in H12. + revert H12; apply almost_impl. apply all_almost; intros ??. unfold rvsqr, rvminus, vecrvnth, rvplus, rvopp, rvscale; simpl. assert (rv_eq @@ -6593,7 +6603,7 @@ Proof. { now apply FiniteConditionalExpectation_ext. } - rewrite H16, H15, H14. + rewrite H14, H13, H12. unfold rvscale, Rsqr. unfold vecrvnth. lra. @@ -6613,7 +6623,7 @@ Proof. - apply (RandomVariable_sa_sub (filt_sub k)). apply FiniteCondexp_rv. } - specialize (jaak _ _ _ H H0 H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6). + specialize (jaak _ _ _ H H0 H1 H2 H3 H4). assert (almost prts (fun ω : Ts => @@ -6634,21 +6644,21 @@ Proof. intros. apply vector_nth_IsFiniteExpectation. intros. - specialize (H13 k). - apply vector_IsFiniteExpectation_nth with (i := i) (pf := pf) in H13. - revert H13. + specialize (H11 k). + apply vector_IsFiniteExpectation_nth with (i := i) (pf := pf) in H11. + revert H11. apply IsFiniteExpectation_proper. intros ?. reflexivity. } generalize (fun k => pos_scaled_vec_fincondexp W (filt_sub k) (XF k)); intros. - apply almost_forall in H15. - revert H15; apply almost_impl. - revert H7; apply almost_impl. + apply almost_forall in H13. + revert H13; apply almost_impl. + revert H5; apply almost_impl. apply all_almost; intros ω??. intros. - clear H0 H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H8 H9 jaak. - specialize (H7 k). + clear H0 H1 H2 H3 H4 jaak. + specialize (H5 k). generalize (vector_FiniteConditionalExpectation_nth prts (filt_sub k) (XF' k)); intros. specialize (H0 i pf ω). replace (FiniteConditionalExpectation prts (filt_sub k) (vecrvnth i pf (XF' k)) ω) with @@ -6657,16 +6667,16 @@ Proof. apply Rvector_max_abs_nth_le. left. eapply Rle_lt_trans; cycle 1. - apply H7. + apply H5. right. f_equal. unfold XF'. - unfold pre_inter_of_collection in H15. - now rewrite H15. + unfold pre_inter_of_collection in H13. + now rewrite H13. - rewrite vector_FiniteConditionalExpectation_nth. now apply FiniteConditionalExpectation_ext. } - specialize (jaak H13 H8 H9). + specialize (jaak H11 H6 H7). assert (exists C : R, 0 < C /\ almost prts @@ -6676,8 +6686,8 @@ Proof. (vecrvnth i pf (XF' k)) ω <= C * (1 + Rvector_max_abs (X' k ω)) ^ 2)). { - clear H0 H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H8 H9 jaak. - destruct H10 as [C [Cpos HH]]. + clear H0 H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 jaak. + destruct H8 as [C [Cpos HH]]. assert (forall k i pf, rv_eq (vecrvnth i pf (XF' k)) (rvscale (vector_nth i pf W) (vecrvnth i pf (XF k)))). @@ -6805,7 +6815,7 @@ Proof. - apply Rle_0_sqr. } eapply Rle_trans; cycle 1. - apply H8. + apply H12. rewrite <- H5. right. apply FiniteConditionalVariance_ext. @@ -6861,25 +6871,25 @@ Proof. - intros. apply H1. } - specialize (jaak H14). + specialize (jaak H12). cut_to jaak; trivial. - revert jaak. apply almost_impl. apply all_almost; intros ??. intros. - specialize (H15 i pf). - unfold X' in H15. - unfold pos_Rvector_mult in H15. + specialize (H13 i pf). + unfold X' in H13. + unfold pos_Rvector_mult in H13. assert (is_lim_seq (fun m => (vector_nth i pf W) * vector_nth i pf (X m x)) 0). { - revert H15. + revert H13. apply is_lim_seq_ext. intros. rewrite Rvector_nth_mult, vector_nth_map; lra. } - apply is_lim_seq_scal_l with (a := Rinv_mkpos (vector_nth i pf W)) in H16. - rewrite Rbar_mult_0_r in H16. - revert H16. + apply is_lim_seq_scal_l with (a := Rinv_mkpos (vector_nth i pf W)) in H14. + rewrite Rbar_mult_0_r in H14. + revert H14. apply is_lim_seq_ext. intros. unfold Rinv_mkpos. @@ -6891,7 +6901,7 @@ Proof. - intros. unfold X'. intros ?. - rewrite H11. + rewrite H9. unfold pos_Rvector_mult, vecrvminus, vecrvplus, vecrvmult, vecrvopp, vecrvscale. repeat rewrite Rvector_mult_plus_distr_r. f_equal.