Why does devel/llvm show version 90?

[dlangille]

          > I found some odd version numbers for https://dev.freshports.org/devel/llvm/ . Odd in the sense of being really old.

The following list "90" (meaning 9.0 back then) . . . FreeBSD:12:armv6 quarterly FreeBSD:12:armv7 quarterly FreeBSD:13:armv6 latest FreeBSD:13:powerpc64 latest

The repo dates listed in the hover-text go back in 2020-Dec and 2021-Jan.

FYI: devel/llvm90 was "removed" in git back in 2023-Jan:

author Tobias C. Berner [email protected] 2023-01-04 11:03:44 +0000 committer Tobias C. Berner [email protected] 2023-01-14 23:14:56 +0000 commit 21778d8958f518e2179b1053d75cfb6c71405558 (patch) . . . Cleanup: Remove devel/llvm[789]0 * remove old devel/llvm70 * remove old devel/llvm80 * remove old devel/llvm90

• remove ports explicitely depending on either of the three

Removing devel/llvm90 from git does not destroy the repo. It still exists. It still contains version 90.

But:

[18:16 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % fetch https://pkg.freebsd.org/FreeBSD:12:armv6/latest/packagesite.txz 
packagesite.txz                                       5572 kB 8941 kBps    00s
[18:29 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % time jq -rc '[1, .origin, .name, .version] | @tsv' < packagesite.yaml | > packagesite.csv
jq -rc '[1, .origin, .name, .version] | @tsv' < packagesite.yaml  0.83s user 0.04s system 99% cpu 0.872 total
 > packagesite.csv  0.00s user 0.01s system 0% cpu 0.871 total
[18:29 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % grep devel/llvm packagesite.csv
1	devel/llvm70	llvm70	7.0.0
1	devel/llvm60	llvm60	6.0.1_2
1	devel/llvm50	llvm50	5.0.2_1
1	devel/llvm40	llvm40	4.0.1_10
[18:29 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % 

I don't see a 90 in there.

Checking the database, it's in there:

freshports.dev=# select * from packages where package_name = 'llvm';
   id    | abi_id | package_set | package_name | package_version | port_id 
---------+--------+-------------+--------------+-----------------+---------
 4031937 |      9 | quarterly   | llvm         | 15,1            |   16597
 4064717 |      1 | latest      | llvm         | 15,1            |   16597
 4098555 |      1 | quarterly   | llvm         | 15,1            |   16597
 4155229 |     15 | quarterly   | llvm         | 90              |   16597
 4178001 |     16 | quarterly   | llvm         | 90              |   16597
 4185659 |      8 | latest      | llvm         | 15,1            |   16597

Originally posted by @dlangille in #511 (comment)

[dlangille]

So such package. No such version.

Any more.

freshports.dev=# select * from packages_raw where package_origin = 'devel/llvm';
 id | package_origin | package_name | package_version | abi | abi_id | port_id | package_set 
----+----------------+--------------+-----------------+-----+--------+---------+-------------
(0 rows)

freshports.dev=# select * from packages_raw where package_version = '90';
 id | package_origin | package_name | package_version | abi | abi_id | port_id | package_set 
----+----------------+--------------+-----------------+-----+--------+---------+-------------
(0 rows)

freshports.dev=# 

[dlangille]

The package information is correct. In this example, the information is downloaded, extracted, and grep'd. There is a version 90:

[18:16 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % fetch https://pkg.freebsd.org/FreeBSD:12:armv6/quarterly/packagesite.txz           

packagesite.txz                                       5224 kB 7077 kBps    01s
[18:21 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % tar -xzf packagesite.txz                                                                 
[18:21 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % time jq -rc '[1, .origin, .name, .version] | @tsv' < packagesite.yaml | > packagesite.csv
jq -rc '[1, .origin, .name, .version] | @tsv' < packagesite.yaml  0.81s user 0.00s system 99% cpu 0.809 total
 > packagesite.csv  0.00s user 0.01s system 0% cpu 0.808 total
[18:21 dev-ingress01 dan ~/tmp/package-importing] % grep llvm packagesite.csv                                                                
1	devel/py-llvmlite	py27-llvmlite	0.31.0
1	devel/py-llvmcpy	py27-llvmcpy	0.1.5_1
1	devel/xtoolchain-llvm90	xtoolchain-llvm90	0.2
1	devel/xtoolchain-llvm80	xtoolchain-llvm80	0.1
1	devel/py-llvmlite	py37-llvmlite	0.31.0
1	devel/py-llvmcpy	py37-llvmcpy	0.1.5_1
1	devel/spirv-llvm-translator	spirv-llvm-translator	10.0.0
1	devel/llvm90	llvm90	9.0.1_2
1	devel/llvm80	llvm80	8.0.1_4
1	devel/llvm70	llvm70	7.0.1_4
1	devel/llvm60	llvm60	6.0.1_7
1	devel/llvm11	llvm11	11.0.0
1	devel/llvm10	llvm10	10.0.1_2
1	devel/llvm	llvm	90

Going back to the .yaml file, I ran it through less looking for the original data. I found it. I have added newlines into the output to make it wrap nicely here.

{"name":"llvm","origin":"devel/llvm","version":"90","comment":"Meta-port for the default version of the LLVM Toolchain",
"maintainer":"[email protected]","www":"http://llvm.org/","abi":"FreeBSD:12:*","arch":"freebsd:12:*","prefix":"/usr/local",
"sum":"98052068d70c4870d1174b61a6a6dff07d00ebf95f1948d03aef1cbcbe994a0e","flatsize":2870,
"path":"All/llvm-90.txz","repopath":"All/llvm-90.txz","licenselogic":"single","licenses":["BSD2CLAUSE"],"pkgsize":6812,
"desc":"The LLVM Project is a collection of modular and reusable compiler and\ntoolchain technologies.\n\nThis port 
includes Clang (a C/C++/Objective-C compiler), LLD (a linker),\nLLDB (a debugger), and the LLVM infrastructure these are 
built on.\n\nPorts developers: do not depend on this port from other ports.\n\nWWW: http://llvm.org/",
"deps":{"llvm90":{"origin":"devel/llvm90","version":"9.0.1_2"}},"categories":["devel","lang"],
"options":{"CLANG":"on","EXTRAS":"on","LIT":"on","LLD":"on","LLDB":"on"}}

[dlangille]

I think we're good. :)