diff --git a/Content.Server/Chat/Systems/ChatSystem.cs b/Content.Server/Chat/Systems/ChatSystem.cs
index d2ed6e04346..6cab6a8ee5b 100644
--- a/Content.Server/Chat/Systems/ChatSystem.cs
+++ b/Content.Server/Chat/Systems/ChatSystem.cs
@@ -223,7 +223,7 @@ public void TrySendInGameICMessage(
             message = message[1..];
         }
 
-        bool shouldCapitalize = (desiredType != InGameICChatType.Emote);
+        bool shouldCapitalize = (desiredType != InGameICChatType.Emote && desiredType != InGameICChatType.Subtle);
         bool shouldPunctuate = _configurationManager.GetCVar(CCVars.ChatPunctuation);
         // Capitalizing the word I only happens in English, so we check language here
         bool shouldCapitalizeTheWordI = (!CultureInfo.CurrentCulture.IsNeutralCulture && CultureInfo.CurrentCulture.Parent.Name == "en")