Using recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_914 on CMIP6 data

[flicj191]

Describe the bug

I have been using the recipe_flato13ipcc_figure914.yml to produce the plot with CMIP6 data and have found that I have to edit the diagnostic script ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_14.py for it to work as it is using the attribute 'model_id' which doesn't exist in CMIP6 attributes so have edited to 'source_id' as well as the plot titles that say CMIP5.

Should we update script and recipe? or make it more configurable?

Attached log.txt from the diagnostic script.

[valeriupredoi]

hi @flicj191 just to confirm esmvaltool/recipes/ipccwg1ar5ch9/recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_914.yml is the one you using, right? In these sort of circumstances, it's always good to tag/assign first the recipe maintainer(s) and/or authors, if they are from among us ie ESMValTool developers taggable on GitHub (@axel-lauer in this case, @LisaBock is a good hit too, since she knows the IPCC stuff inside out), then, if there's no movement from the recipe maintainer(s), ask the scientific community 🍺

[axel-lauer]

My preferred option would be to make the diagnostic script more flexible, i.e. using model_id or source_id depending on the project of the dataset (CMIP5, CMIP6) and as a fallback option (for all other projects) simply the dataset name.

[LisaBock]

There is an updated version of this figure in AR6: Figure 3.24

It was created with ESMValTool (and a python diagnostic) by @ledm and @malininae but the code is not yet merged in the public ESMValTool branch. If you are interested in the new code you could find all information here: https://github.com/ESMValGroup/ESMValTool-AR6-OriginalCode-FinalFigures/blob/main/IPCC_README_files/README_AR6_WG1_Chap3_Fig3_24_sst_bias.md

[malininae]

There is an updated version of this figure in AR6: Figure 3.24

It was created with ESMValTool (and a python diagnostic) by @ledm and @malininae but the code is not yet merged in the public ESMValTool branch. If you are interested in the new code you could find all information here: https://github.com/ESMValGroup/ESMValTool-AR6-OriginalCode-FinalFigures/blob/main/IPCC_README_files/README_AR6_WG1_Chap3_Fig3_24_sst_bias.md

Oh oh, I am planning to merge my IPCC figures still, but not sure when exactly, maybe roughly in half a year?