You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
In Guiguts 1, the behavior for Hebrew text is approximately this:
Text pastes in properly, but is displayed LTR, not RTL
Cursor movement within the text can be strange
If not edited in Guiguts, but saved and viewed/edited in a RTL-aware editor, it works fine.
The best outcome in Guiguts 2 is RTL is displayed properly. But we should only support this if maintaining the functionality would not be a burden; Hebrew is not extremely prevalent in our books, though some have more than others.
Current situation
Results seen so far in Guiguts 2:
Windows: seems the same as GG1
Mac: seems to display correctly RTL
Linux: seems the same as GG1
Screenshots
Mac
(GG1 at bottom; GG2 at right; sample text from forum at left). Appears the RTL is handled properly.
Linux
Seems to display LTR like GG1.
Windows
@windymilla if you'd like to post a Windows screenshot, feel free; if it looks similar to Linux just point to that...
Interesting module
AwesomeTkinter (GitHub) has some base bidi support we could potentially build on, either in a fork, or by contributing back to that project. Currently it seems to focus on Arabic (meaning it also has a nice ligature system, but I'm not sure that's of use in Hebrew; we can ask the experts). It supports Label and Entry; how difficult it would be to add support to Text would be something to explore.
Their docs only mention Linux and Windows. It's not clear if that's because Mac is untested, or because it's not needed.
A Huge Caveat
The character set / alphabet for Hebrew would need implementing in AwesomeTkinter, assuming that would work at all. Doing this sanely would REQUIRE a decent amount of help and testing from our resident Hebrew experts. If this idea becomes interesting later, we should feel out if one or more of them has any bandwidth to help with this, or else there's no way we could do it at all.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Summary
In Guiguts 1, the behavior for Hebrew text is approximately this:
The best outcome in Guiguts 2 is RTL is displayed properly. But we should only support this if maintaining the functionality would not be a burden; Hebrew is not extremely prevalent in our books, though some have more than others.
Current situation
Results seen so far in Guiguts 2:
Screenshots
Mac
(GG1 at bottom; GG2 at right; sample text from forum at left). Appears the RTL is handled properly.
Linux
Seems to display LTR like GG1.
Windows
@windymilla if you'd like to post a Windows screenshot, feel free; if it looks similar to Linux just point to that...
Interesting module
AwesomeTkinter (GitHub) has some base bidi support we could potentially build on, either in a fork, or by contributing back to that project. Currently it seems to focus on Arabic (meaning it also has a nice ligature system, but I'm not sure that's of use in Hebrew; we can ask the experts). It supports Label and Entry; how difficult it would be to add support to Text would be something to explore.
Their docs only mention Linux and Windows. It's not clear if that's because Mac is untested, or because it's not needed.
A Huge Caveat
The character set / alphabet for Hebrew would need implementing in AwesomeTkinter, assuming that would work at all. Doing this sanely would REQUIRE a decent amount of help and testing from our resident Hebrew experts. If this idea becomes interesting later, we should feel out if one or more of them has any bandwidth to help with this, or else there's no way we could do it at all.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: