Misaligned squiggle in LaTeX document

[matthewelmer]

The yellow squiggle under "I" shows up on the line above the "I" instead of right under it as expected. Reproduction:

\documentclass[11pt, letterpaper]{article}

\begin{document}
There is a serene tranquility to the quiet hours of the early morning.
A secret world, all to myself. An otherwise ordinary commute instead offers the
rhythmic cycling of chain against sprocket; the gentle hum of an electric motor;
the glistening elegance of morning dew on sleepy grass. Fog that highlights
beams of light completes the transformation into a wondrous adventure.

I make this journey free of the noisy commotion that is otherwise inescapable in
a town with so many people.
\end{document}