diff --git a/controllers/ConsultationController.php b/controllers/ConsultationController.php
index b402f28020..f25c999fda 100644
--- a/controllers/ConsultationController.php
+++ b/controllers/ConsultationController.php
@@ -319,8 +319,8 @@ public function actionIndex(): ResponseInterface
             'myself' => $myself,
             'myMotions' => $myself?->getMySupportedMotionsByConsultation($this->consultation),
             'myAmendments' => $myself?->getMySupportedAmendmentsByConsultation($this->consultation),
-            'myMotionComments' => $myself?->getMyPrivatelyCommentedMotionsByConsultation($this->consultation),
-            'myAmendmentComments' => $myself?->getMyPrivatelyCommentedAmendmentsByConsultation($this->consultation),
+            'myMotionComments' => MotionComment::getPrivatelyCommentedByConsultation($myself, $this->consultation),
+            'myAmendmentComments' => AmendmentComment::getPrivatelyCommentedByConsultation($myself, $this->consultation),
         ]));
     }
 
@@ -594,8 +594,8 @@ private function tagMotionResolutionList(int $tagId, bool $isResolutionList): Re
             'tag' => $tag,
             'cache' => LayoutHelper::getTagMotionListCache($this->consultation, $tag, $isResolutionList),
             'isResolutionList' => $isResolutionList,
-            'myMotionComments' => $myself?->getMyPrivatelyCommentedMotionsByConsultation($this->consultation),
-            'myAmendmentComments' => $myself?->getMyPrivatelyCommentedAmendmentsByConsultation($this->consultation),
+            'myMotionComments' => MotionComment::getPrivatelyCommentedByConsultation($myself, $this->consultation),
+            'myAmendmentComments' => AmendmentComment::getPrivatelyCommentedByConsultation($myself, $this->consultation),
         ]));
     }
 
diff --git a/models/db/AmendmentComment.php b/models/db/AmendmentComment.php
index 2b55a5715e..35d6a9c29f 100644
--- a/models/db/AmendmentComment.php
+++ b/models/db/AmendmentComment.php
@@ -121,6 +121,34 @@ public static function getNewestByConsultation(Consultation $consultation, int $
         }));
     }
 
+    /**
+     * @return AmendmentComment[]
+     */
+    public static function getPrivatelyCommentedByConsultation(?User $user, Consultation $consultation): array
+    {
+        if (!$user) {
+            return [];
+        }
+
+        $query     = AmendmentComment::find();
+        $query->innerJoin(
+            'amendment',
+            'amendmentComment.amendmentId = amendment.id'
+        );
+        $query->innerJoin('motion', 'motion.id = amendment.motionId');
+        $query->where('motion.status != ' . IntVal(Motion::STATUS_DELETED));
+        $query->andWhere('amendment.status != ' . IntVal(Motion::STATUS_DELETED));
+        $query->andWhere('motion.consultationId = ' . IntVal($consultation->id));
+        $query->andWhere('amendmentComment.userId = ' . IntVal($user->id));
+        $query->andWhere('amendmentComment.status = ' . AmendmentComment::STATUS_PRIVATE);
+        $query->orderBy('motion.titlePrefix ASC, amendment.titlePrefix ASC, amendment.dateCreation DESC, amendmentComment.paragraph ASC');
+
+        /** @var AmendmentComment[] $comments */
+        $comments =  $query->all();
+
+        return $comments;
+    }
+
     public function getMotionTitle(): string
     {
         $amendment = $this->getIMotion();
diff --git a/models/db/MotionComment.php b/models/db/MotionComment.php
index ccb07d038f..de03c3a71d 100644
--- a/models/db/MotionComment.php
+++ b/models/db/MotionComment.php
@@ -126,6 +126,32 @@ public static function getNewestByConsultation(Consultation $consultation, int $
         }));
     }
 
+    /**
+     * @return MotionComment[]
+     */
+    public static function getPrivatelyCommentedByConsultation(?User $user, Consultation $consultation): array
+    {
+        if (!$user) {
+            return [];
+        }
+
+        $query = MotionComment::find();
+        $query->innerJoin(
+            'motion',
+            'motionComment.motionId = motion.id'
+        );
+        $query->where('motion.status != ' . intval(Motion::STATUS_DELETED));
+        $query->andWhere('motion.consultationId = ' . intval($consultation->id));
+        $query->andWhere('motionComment.userId = ' . intval($user->id));
+        $query->andWhere('motionComment.status = ' . MotionComment::STATUS_PRIVATE);
+        $query->orderBy('motion.titlePrefix ASC, motion.dateCreation DESC, motion.id DESC, motionComment.paragraph ASC');
+
+        /** @var MotionComment[] $comments */
+        $comments = $query->all();
+
+        return $comments;
+    }
+
     public function getConsultation(): ?Consultation
     {
         $motion = $this->getIMotion();
diff --git a/models/db/User.php b/models/db/User.php
index a7e8d34424..bf5d655f95 100644
--- a/models/db/User.php
+++ b/models/db/User.php
@@ -583,46 +583,6 @@ public function getMySupportedAmendmentsByConsultation(Consultation $consultatio
         return $supporters;
     }
 
-    /**
-     * @return MotionComment[]
-     */
-    public function getMyPrivatelyCommentedMotionsByConsultation(Consultation $consultation): array
-    {
-        $query = MotionComment::find();
-        $query->innerJoin(
-            'motion',
-            'motionComment.motionId = motion.id'
-        );
-        $query->where('motion.status != ' . intval(Motion::STATUS_DELETED));
-        $query->andWhere('motion.consultationId = ' . intval($consultation->id));
-        $query->andWhere('motionComment.userId = ' . intval($this->id));
-        $query->andWhere('motionComment.status = ' . MotionComment::STATUS_PRIVATE);
-        $query->orderBy('motion.titlePrefix ASC, motion.dateCreation DESC, motion.id DESC, motionComment.paragraph ASC');
-
-        return $query->all();
-    }
-
-    /**
-     * @return AmendmentComment[]
-     */
-    public function getMyPrivatelyCommentedAmendmentsByConsultation(Consultation $consultation): array
-    {
-        $query     = AmendmentComment::find();
-        $query->innerJoin(
-            'amendment',
-            'amendmentComment.amendmentId = amendment.id'
-        );
-        $query->innerJoin('motion', 'motion.id = amendment.motionId');
-        $query->where('motion.status != ' . IntVal(Motion::STATUS_DELETED));
-        $query->andWhere('amendment.status != ' . IntVal(Motion::STATUS_DELETED));
-        $query->andWhere('motion.consultationId = ' . IntVal($consultation->id));
-        $query->andWhere('amendmentComment.userId = ' . IntVal($this->id));
-        $query->andWhere('amendmentComment.status = ' . AmendmentComment::STATUS_PRIVATE);
-        $query->orderBy('motion.titlePrefix ASC, amendment.titlePrefix ASC, amendment.dateCreation DESC, amendmentComment.paragraph ASC');
-
-        return $query->all();
-    }
-
     public function getNotificationUnsubscribeCode(): string
     {
         return $this->id . '-' . $this->createConfirmationCode('unsubscribe');