Large summarised list of requests (AI problems, incorrect information, Forge problems)

[MorihiroS]

Hi, Forge team! I wrote a lot of requests and I think it's a time to structure them by themes for your comfort. The list will be updated with requests from time to time. So:

1. Artificial intelligence (AI) problems:

1.1. AI doesn't cast/suspend/play at all:

• AI doesn't cast cards with "Activated abilities of sources with the chosen name can’t be activated" #4261
• AI doesn't cast Solitary Confinement/Forge Anew/Springleaf Drum, but it uses them more or less skillfully #4279
• AI doesn't cast Unmoored Ego #4302
• AI doesn't play bounce lands if it has few lands on the battlefield #4326
• AI casts Scale Up only for overload cost #4336
• AI doesn't cast Shape Anew #4347
• AI doesn't suspend Restore Balance #4359
• AI doesn't cast some combat tricks to protect his permanents or itself #4464
• AI doesn't cast Tishana's Tidebinder #4641
• AI doesn't cast Invert Polarity #5897
• AI doesn't cast Shatterskull Smashing #5899
• AI doesn't cast Strike It Rich #5900
• AI doesn't cast Glistening Deluge #6378

1.2. AI doesn't resolve:

• AI doesn't resolve Glimpse of Tomorrow from cascade #4113
• Kozilek's Command, which was cast by AI, couldn't add to stack, failed to target #5954

1.3. AI casts very rarely or only under certain conditions:

• AI never casts Searing Blaze #3997 (it's just rather hesitant to use it)
• AI doesn't cast Violent Outburst without attacking creatures #4210
• AI very rarely casts Collected Company #4215
• AI doesn't cast Adventure Spells if it can cast main spells #4352

1.4. AI doesn't cycling:

• AI doesn't cycling Eagles of the North #4227

1.5. AI casts incorrectly:

• AI casts Lightning Bolt and similar spells and target a creature that is unkillable by them #3994
• AI casts Persist on Orcish Bowmasters #4122
• AI casts Underworld Breach for no reason #4124
• AI casts second Inquisition of Kozilek to irrelevant hand #4130
• AI often casts Venerated Loxodon and Knight-Errant of Eos without convoke #4201
• AI evokes Grief when player has hexproof #4233
• AI casts Up the Beanstalk after spells with mana value 5 or greater #4278
• AI casts Preordain with Teferi, Time Raveler in player's upkeep #4299
• AI casts Angel's Grace for non-lethal damage #4325
• AI casts Tamiyo's Safekeeping not in response #4434
• AI casts Bloodchief's Thirst with kicker to kill creature with 2 cmc #4443
• AI uses insta-fliсker on Grief when player hasn't cards in hands #5891
• AI doesn't cast Lava Spike while the player has more than 10 hp #6014
• AI doesn't cast Skullcrack while the player has more than 10 hp #6015
• AI casts spells with X in cost, paying X as 0 #6390

1.6. AI doesn't activate ability:

• AI doesn't use activated ability of Waker of Waves #4391
• AI doesn't activate ability of Unstable Amulet #5904
• AI doesn't activate Channel abilities that don't deal damage #5935
• AI doesn't activate first ability of The Underworld Cookbook #6108
• AI doesn't activate first ability of Psychic Frog #6379
• AI doesn't activate ability of Emry, Lurker of the Loch #6387

1.7. AI uses abilities incorrectly:

• AI prefers to attack with Stoneforge Mystic/Elvish Piper rather than activating their ability #4022
• AI ineffectively activates Stoneforge Mystic ability #4023
• AI sacrifices fetchlands and puts tapped shockland/triom on the battlefield in its own turn #4087
• AI uses Arbor Elf incorrectly #4116
• AI uses second ability of Wrenn and Six too often #4131
• AI doesn't use ability of Agatha's Soul Cauldron in response to Unearth #4169
• AI sacrifices all of its creatures after they gain Sakura-Tribe Elder's ability #4214
• AI activates ability of Elvish Piper at it's turn #4280
• AI doesn't exile creature cards from its graveyard by Agatha's Soul Cauldron #4331
• AI often activates last ability of Nahiri, the Harbinger after combat #4349
• AI activates abilities of Assault Formation/Giver of Runes before combat and doesn't attack #4373
• AI doesn't use ability of Elvish Piper if it can cast creature #4430
• AI chooses wrong targets for Might of Old Krosa #4439
• AI activates ability of Quicksilver Amulet to put a creature with cmc 1 onto the battlefield #4435
• AI activates some activated abilities as soon as it can with no reason #5604
• AI untaps Sleep-Cursed Faerie in response to any player action #6391

1.8. AI chooses wrong targets for abilities:

• AI sacrifices Undercity Informer and targets player #4348

1.9. AI's problems with combat:

• AI doesn't always block with Sakura-Tribe Elder #4003
• AI attacks player with protection from creatures #4264
• AI doesn't leave creatures to block/doesn't take into account player's Noble Hierarch effect #4265
• AI activates abilities of creatures/lands to to give them the ability to block but doesn't block with them #4301
• AI doesn't attack with creatures with trample if it has a few lifes #4360
• AI attacks with a single Signal Pest #4656

1.10. AI chooses wrong targets for removal/to take control (irrelevant hierarchy):

• AI would rather kill a Sakura-Tribe Elder than a more valid target #4025
• AI casts some spells only as a removal but they're used in a different way #4118
• AI finds creatures with 6+ toughness more dangerous than Doran, the Siege Tower #4129
• AI would rather kill Serrated Scorpion than Zulaport Cutthroat/Blood Artist #4171
• AI isn't properly interacting with the player's Oath of Nissa #4193
• AI kills its creature or damages itself by suspended Rift Bolt/triggers of Valakut if player and its creatures have hexproof/protection #4208
• AI finds Birds of Paradise more dangerous than Elvish Piper/Champion of Rhonas #4225
• AI searches for itself/discards to player cards with high cmc in early game #4282
• AI gains control of player's Pithing Needle #4300
• AI casts Surgical Extraction and chooses the most expensive card from both graveyards #5892
• AI chooses a first (usual weaker) trigger when casting Tishana's Tidebinder/Consign to Memory #5894
• AI casts Path to Exile and targets mana dork in early game #5907

1.11. AI searches wrong cards:

• AI tries to find Walking Ballista by Chord of Calling #4332
• AI searches for currently irrelevant cards using Treefolk Harbinger #4369

1.12. AI doesn't take into account or ignores:

• AI doesn't predict Unsettled Mariner's ability in advance #4054
• AI ignores player's Ratchet Bomb / The Filigree Sylex #4152
• AI doesn't cast another The One Ring to get rid of burden counters #4162
• AI kills itself with Bitterblossom #4305
• AI doesn't take into account abilities of Kaldra Compleat #4324
• AI counts MDFC lands only as lands #5603
• AI is trying to get the player to sacrifice his permanents even if it's impossible to do so #5860
• AI ignores the effect of Roiling Vortex and casts free spells #5879
• AI doesn't cast Suspend spells with As Foretold when it has mana open for Suspend #5890
• AI doesn't use second ability of Guide of Souls #5901
• AI doesn't cast Calibrated Blast if the player gets hexproof/shroud from his creature #5940
• AI puts the same Urza's lands on the battlefield even if it has different ones in its hands #6031
• AI casts Stony Silence instead of Suppression Field when player has non-artifact permanents with activated abilities #6105
• AI pays energy counter to keep Static Prison without exiled permanent #6380

1.13. AI chooses wrong card name:

• AI choose a wrong card to name with Pithing Needle #4260
• AI chooses a single target with a higher cmc for two different Pithing Needles #5896

1.14. AI keeps a bad hand:

• AI keeps a hand with no lands but with spells with 0 cmc or with only phyrexian mana #4209

1.15. AI wrong use cascade:

• AI cascades to Living End and casts Living End when it has a lot of creatures on the battlefield #4389

2. Incorrect information:

• Relic of Progenitus's first ability is incorrectly displayed on the stack #4318
• Spells/abilities are incorrectly displayed on the stack #5634

3. Forge problems:

3.1. Problems with names:

• Forge doesn't recognise cards that have the letters á, É, é, í, ó, ú, û in their names  #4365

3.2. Problems with game:

• Game crashes when player kills AI's planeswalker #4213
• AI can target player with hexproof #4323
• Game crashes when a player puts two frames together #4438
• Game crashes when a player push "Ask AI for suggestion" and "Ask Simulation AI for suggestion" #4465
• AI Sideboarding mode "Human for AI" is broken  #5606
• Boggart Trawler and Malakir Rebirth frizzes out AI #6106
• Damping Sphere breaks autopay for painlands #6107

3.3. Problems with preferences:

• Forge can't be updated by Check for Updates #6408

[MorihiroS]

@Hanmac, is there any way to pin this request to the top? Like this:

[Hanmac]

@MorihiroS found the pin for this

[MorihiroS]

@Hanmac, thank you very much!

Can you also add AI label, keep label and assign Agetian for all of this requests (https://github.com/Card-Forge/forge/issues/created_by/MorihiroS) at once (so you don't have to do it every two/three days)?

[Hanmac]

@Hanmac, thank you very much!

Can you also add AI label, keep label and assign Agetian for all of this requests (https://github.com/Card-Forge/forge/issues/created_by/MorihiroS) at once (so you don't have to do it every two/three days)?

you really need to take care of when issues are duplicates

like "but creature onto the battlefield" effects should be all the same

[MorihiroS]

you really need to take care of when issues are duplicates

I try, for example in #4118 I added a similar spell in the same request at a later date

like "but creature onto the battlefield" effects should be all the same

If you mean "put creature onto the battlefield", there are 3 different problems:

#4280 - about activation time;
#4430 - about ability priority over casting;
#4435 - about ability activation for targets with less cmc than the ability cost.

@Hanmac, or do you think these requests should be merged into one?

[MorihiroS]

@Hanmac, @tool4ever, @Agetian, @tehdiplomat, guys, I've closed 23 issues (some are no longer relevant, some have that unfortunate AI:RemoveDeck:All tag; some are merged into more enlarged issues). I tried to correct the list so that there are no issues with a common problems. I try my best.

[MorihiroS]

I've also closed 6 issues (2 non-actual + 4 merged into more enlarged issues)